>Has anyone used the above tool? It's sort of like a Hunter tool with a carbide cutter. The Packard has a tapered shaft with flats to hold the cutter at 45 degrees left and right. Comments please. Thanks.
>I absolutely love mine! The shaft with flats milled at 45 deg. took a bit of getting used to...(about 20 minutes!)...but it's almost like cheating it cuts with such precision and control.
>Barry It looks like a great tool to me but I like to rotate the tool for different cuts and it would be harder to do with the eliminator. I like the round shaft. A good example is that you can "flatten" the angle for quick rough cutting and then "steepen" the angle for really clean cuts on difficult woods. I can see how it would be easier for first time users to find the "sweet spot" but this only takes a few minutes with the hunter.
The Bar is longer on the eliminator. The smaller Hunter tools will fit many of the other boring bars which gives you more options. I find the #4 Hunter in my wooden handle is my most reached for tool but then I don't do a lot of deep vessels. The #1 mounted in my John Jordan bar is the one I reach for when hollowing deeper stuff.
I have been experimenting with the Hunter tools on the outside of vessles. I don't know if you can do that with the Eliminator. Someone will have to tell us if it can be rotated so the cutter is tilted to the right. With Hunter you can rotate the tool either way easily so you can do rim to bottom or bottom to rim cutting. You can also work on the outside.
I turned a spindle with it the other day. It cuts really clean but may not be the best tool for this job as it takes a different feel to stay on the bevel.
>Like John, I would think the flat would tend to limit your options. I use my #3 Hunter for everything and don't always stay with the 45, depending on how I want to cut. I do use it on the out side of pieces as well.
>The eliminator has two 45 degree flats one for the inside and the other works well for the outside. It works well, especially if you want to eliminate a lot of sanding.
>Like Gary said (just below here), it cuts so nice, I just about stopped sanding the inside of my coffee scoops and small boxes.
As to the flat sides, before I tried it, I had the same feeling as John and Carole, that it would limit the use, however, there's just one use for me, hollowing and not having to sand. I don't have a handle on it, it has such a smooth cut I can hollow a small form with one hand, it cuts like it's cutting butter.
>Thanks Mike, but I'm looking for the primary source, from which they would undoubtedly be significantly cheaper. I took a quick look at the Enco and MSC catalogs but can't find them because I don't know what they're called. (There are literally thousands of various carbide cutters out there, so precision in nomenclature is required.) I really have a problem with the fact that woodturning is now an "in" thing, and the prices of everything that can be associated with it have doubled from their true values. ...Gary
>Does the flat on a skew stop you from changing the presentation angle? The eliminator's flats insure one doesn't present the cutter in an aggressive position. Once the cut is start it is easy the open up the presentation for a more aggressive cut. I think the tapered point and the flats make it a better tool for someone who is still learning the dynamics of the cutter.