>Does anybody know how to turn a square bowl? I have been trying, but my walls very in thickness. They end up thicker at the bottom of the arc than in the corners. Also, what would be the best way of centering the bowl in a chuck? (I use an old Nova chuck) The corners in my bowls end up different thicknesses, which I am guessing is due to the piece not being mounted perefectly on center. Any help in this would be creatly appreciated. Thanks in Advance.
>Jamie Donaldson, who frequents WC turns beautiful square bowls and will be teaching a course "It's Hip to Turn Square" at John C. Campbell Folk School in March. He should be able to help.
>The trick, if there is one, to turning square bowls is being really light on the bevel and very careful directional control. Well of course sharp tools are a must. When you start the cut on the edges try to put as little pressure on the bevel as you can. You can tell by the noise. The softer the noise the lower the pressure on the bevel. This keeps from flexing the wood which takes a larger cut.
Then you have to aim the bevel just right to make the wings the same thickness. One trick I use is to figure out where the wing is getting thicker. I then move the tool into this area but at such an angle that the bevel will be touching the wood but the edge isn't cutting. I move the tool back and forth very gradually adjusting the handle until it just starts to cut at the point that the wing is thick. Then I make a cut toward the bowl. Sometimes it helps to put a pencil mark on your tool rest to know where to start the cut.
I start my square bowls between centers. This lets me move either the tailcenter or drive center to get the bowl properly aligned both center and flat.
>....with uniform edges is to true up the outside edges before starting on the inside. Then the edges can be cut to a uniform thinness by adjusting the interior cuts with the long edge of the bowl gouge. Takes some practice and a bit of risk taking, but the results won't be just another round bowl! Watch your knuckles!!
>Another way to turn a square bowl is to turn a larger shallow round bowl and then cut it square on the bandsaw. You still have to get the thickness constant but there are no flying corners to tear out or to break your fingers. And it can end up triangular or whatever.
This method does take a bigger piece of wood, of course.
>The safest way to do it is to use "slaves." This is to say, glue surrounding pieces of scrap wood to the good wood, and turn "normally". Then cut off the slave pieces. This is how Vic Wood does it. This method has two advantages: one is that it is much safer; the other is that you don't waste any good wood.
>....cheating! And the idea of using waste wood glued to end grain is rather more risky than just doing a square turning the honest and most exciting way!
Cut blank square on tablesaw, using the ripfence. Mark the center point of blank on both sides. Start between centers as John Lucas said, using the center points that you marked, bottom of the piece at the tailstock end. Turn tenon or recess to fit the chuck, and outside profile. When you reverse onto the chuck, bring up tailstock to align on center where the spur drive center was. Apply some pressure with the tailstock and then tighten the chuck the last little bit. My cheap chuck does not center perfectly, but this procedure gets it very close. Remember that the piece should bottom out on the ends on the chuck jaws, so a recess should have a smooth, flat bottom where the jaws sit, and a tenon should similarly have a smooth, flat area surrounding the base of the tenon.
There has been a lot of good advice in the responses here. I am with Jamie and believe that sacrificial wood glued to end grain can be more dangerous. There is a 'How I turn straight sided bowls' on my website www.turnspain.com
>Arndt turners great? Start with round trees, cut square pieces out of them and then turn round pieces out of those and complain about the waste.
I wonder why you started with a round blank and cut the pentagon first? There is some allure to flirting with those whirling tips of death, but why not turn the bowl first and cut the pentagon later?
So gluing on waste blocks is wasteful? or dangerous? The fear would be that the end grain glue joint would fail and the waste block fly off. Why not start with a rectangular block and glue pieces on the sides to the long grain to make it square or nearly so? Then make the composite blank round on the bandsaw.
I have turned a number of square or flat sided bowls and candle stands and having been whacked a few times by the tips, I like the waste blocks. I turn the price and then cut the sides either on the bandsaw or TS. Cut on flat side and use your miter gauge to orient the piece for the next cuts. Having the blank over sized and trimming it later allows you to power sand or sand as you would a bowl without fear of getting whacked or breaking off a wing and without rounding over the edges or deforming the wings.
Several things are critical. You must keep the thickness very consistent in any part of the bowl that will be cut away or exposed to make it square or flat sided. Or you can vary the thickness on purpose to create a arched effect if that is what you want. The blank must be positioned and centered very accurately in order to end up symmetrical.
>Jamie it isn't dangerous at all. glueing on scrap wood was the only way I knew how to turn square bowls for years. I never had one come off. In fact I glued a lot of them with paper joints and didn't have a problem. I will admit it is much easier to turn the wings to an even thickness with the scrap blanks glues on.
The hassle of course is getting the scraps back off. Even with a paper joint you have to sand like crazy to get rid of the paper and glue and that clogs up your sandpaper.
I much prefer to start with a square blank and turn them like you do. It's just faster and I guess I like the challenge of turning those "propellers".
>This is the system I use when I need to cut odd shapes on the table saw. It works especially well for cutting round blanks into squares, pentagons, etc. As long as I can clamp it I can cut it. Sometimes it takes some shimming of the piece if it warped or I hot glue some odd shaped adaptor pieces to my clamps to help hold something.
It has 5/16" T nuts inset in the bottom. Then I took some 5/16 all thread and made the knobs. The clamps have slots cut in the bottom of the circular holes so they can tilt around the all thread rod.
>Who said anything about gluing to end grain? You can get the whole thing square by just gluing two long grain strips to the long grain edges of the work piece. Using slaves also lets you turn off center. Again , check out Vic Woods. I saw an accident recently where a LARGE piece of "propeller" flew off at tremendous speed. It happened to a VERY experienced turner at a demonstration. Quite literally, the turner or someone near the front could have been killed. The missile DID strike the demonstrator and bloodied up his forearm. He was EXTREMELY LUCKY! Jimmy Clewes does these the hard way, and certainly it is fun to watch. But it is dangerous as can be. He was taken to task by a reviewer in some magazine for doing it at a demonstration, where others would be exposed. I asked Clewes why he doesn't use the Vic Woods method. He did have an answer: he likes to see the thickness of the edges develop as he turns. You can't do that if the piece is encased in the slave pieces. I've done it both ways; trust me, the slave method is easier and much safer.
>I have no idea as to mounting but in my limited experience the only square bowls and platters have been turned at the highest speed I dare to use because it minimises the free space cutting air!
As to the uneven thickness IMO tool handling is usually the cause.
As a tip to avoiding the whirling corners: Use Tippex or some White paint to highlight just the tips and a good light and the White shows up really well!
>Cool sled, John. Have one similar (but crude) to square the ends of segmented half rings. The adjustment is via pieces of paper (0.004" thick) in order to remove the minimum necessary to square the half ring ends without making the resulting ring any more oval than necessary.
>That is exactly why i built that sled many years ago. Now my cutting is usually accurate enough not to need it or they are so close I can hand sand the half rings with a 2x4 that has been flattened and sandpaper glued to it. I simply hold the 2x4 against my workbench and then slide the ring along it. A few passes on both halves usually all it takes.