Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Shop Ceiling?

Posts

Shop Ceiling?

#1

Shop Ceiling?

Carole Valentine

>I am doing the inside of my shop with ply walls and was going to put the same thing on the ceiling. My builder says I should put drywall on the ceiling so the joints could be better sealed against heat loss. My idea to use ply was so I could hang light stuff (air hose, ducts, additional spot lights, etc. ) from the ceiling without worrying about finding a joist. What advice do you guys/gals have? All walls and ceiling will be painted white, BTW. I think it takes less force for a flying chunk of wood to go through drywall than it does ply.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#2

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Stuart Johnson

>I like the idea of being able to hang stuff. I don't think it would make that much of a difference in heat loss especially if you install some insulation. This is a pure guess from someone who can heat the shop with a propane heater in half an hour.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#3

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Allen Neighbors

>I agree with you, Carole. You can caulk between the pieces of ply, to keep the air transfer to nil, but I'd wait a month or so after hanging it to do the caulking... that way it'll settle in and draw up or expand the way it wants to. And you're right... it's going to be easier to hang stuff where you need it, instead of on the joists.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#4

Re: PS: Wafer board is cheaper

Allen Neighbors

>than sheetrock in this area. $5 vs. $9. I don't know about around VA.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#5

Re: PS: Wafer board is cheaper

Carole Valentine

>Yeah, OSB is cheaper here too, but I put that in the ceiling of my old shop and I don't want it in this one. After a year the stuff is still killing every bug that sets foot (or wing) in the shop. Got to be something bad in that stuff even if they say it's not.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#6

Re: Shop Ceiling?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Drywall has more fire resistance than plywood. Taping and finishing the drywall usually takes more labor than the drywall installation. A textured finish takes less labor than a smooth finish. Many building codes require a new garage to have 5/8" drywall on the interior for fire resistance. Plywood is more time consuming to install than drywall because it must be cut with a saw instead of a knife. But you save on the taping and finishing. I wouldn't want to be around waferboard in a fire. All that glue gives off nasty fumes. If you want plywood and want to keep the air leakage down staple a layer of tyvek or plastic to the ceiling joists before installing the plywood. You could put drywall over the plywood and have the best of both worlds, but also the greatest cost.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#7

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I did my shop with drywall, both walls and ceiling. I like the appearance better. My shop ceiling/roof has trusses 24" on center, and they used 5/8" drywall to avoid sagging problems between the trusses. 5/8" drywall is pretty sturdy. My shop has a sloped ceiling, 10' high in the center, so the only things I hang from the ceiling are lights and an air cleaner. I can post a picture if you'd like.

My old shop was in my basement and I do miss being able to hang tools and jigs from the joists, but then I'm tall and the bottoms of the joists were in easy reach.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#8

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Mac

>Go with the 5/8" drywall...........

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#9

Richard Allen

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Richard Allen

>If you put the plywood on top of the rafters you will be able to nail to the plywood and to the sides/ bottoms of the rafters.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#10

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Mike Jones

>5/8" Sheet Rock. It won't warp. I'd put some blocking where I think my fixtures will need support and rock over them.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#11

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Richard Jones

>Carole,

My $.02.............

Drywall. If you insulate the ceiling well, i.e., R-30 or R-38, you won't get much infiltration/heat loss from the open joints, in case you don't want to finish or tape the joints. (Is this attached to the house?)

If you're going for looks, drywall, tape and finish and paint. I'd trust OSB to hold a flexible air hose, but darn few other things, and certainly not any type of lighting fixture.

In my basement "studio", drywall ceiling is screwed only, so I can take it down if need be to get into the joist spaces and do any additional wiring, etc.

Good luck, and now let's see those PICS!!!!

Richard

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#12

Re: Shop Ceiling?

russ Fairfield

>2 things you need to consider.

It might be kinda noisy in there with all of those hard surfaces. The softer the ceiling the better.

It is far better to have flying objecys stick to the walls and ceiling than for them to bounce off.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#13

Plywood

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>When I built my shop, I used 1/2" plywood on the ceiling and walls. They were also well insulated, and I caulked the joints. I then painted walls and ceiling white. Made for a bright, tight workspace that was quite quiet and comfortable.

keithz

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#14

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Carole Valentine

>Richard, it's not attached to the house. Don't have any pics yet, but I will start taking them as soon as they start the clearing which should be this week or next.:) It's to be 24x32. A 16' x 8' section will be partitioned off in the back (with sound proofing of some sort) for all the noisy stuff like DC, and compressor and will have shelf storage for blanks and rough-outs. The roof will NOT be truss construction (forget what they call it when it's not trusses) and the upstairs will be insulated and floored so it can be used for storage as well.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#15

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Carole Valentine

>Good points, Russ. It sure won't be any noisier than my current shop because the DC and compressor will be isolated in their own room. I suppose you are right about stuff bouncing rather than punching through. Hadn't thought about that.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#16

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Carole Valentine

>Why? Yeah, I always want to know why...PITA aren't I? ;)

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#17

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Carol

Check your local building code and do it that way. Remember your insurance company does not have to pay if they can blame a fire on a non code issue. I think you said you had trusses. If you do, do some decking in tha attic before you finish the ceiling. Pre decking, if you don't have 2 x 6 trusses, nail some 2 x 4 on top of the rafters and put in 6 in insullation and then the floor. Also be sure to put in an attic access that is large enough to use. If you can afford it do a pull down stair.

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#18

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Carole Valentine

>Bill, we already checked the codes...nothing on an accessory buildings requiring SR. If it was attached to the house, it would have to be sheetrock.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#19

No problem with OSB here...

Rick Urban

>My shop is wall-to-wall OSB including the ceiling. There is a 10x8 garage door, 5 windows, 2 other doors, and the joints are unsealed, but the R-19 in the walls and R-31 above the ceiling do nicely. It's much more comfy after a cold night than the garage attached to the house.

I still have to kill the bugs myself (maybe ours are tougher or mutants), and my worst experience with it has been the splinters.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#20

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Brian Simmons, Heflin, AL

>The cost of plywood around my parts is equall to both the drywall and OSB combined. I would put up OSB and then sheath over it with drywall. It is not difficult or too time consuming to tape and mud the joints. After the mud dries, give it a qick sand and paint with a white primer. You will end up with nailing surface through the drywall (OSB), fire resistance and more thermal mass in the drywall and a ceiling that is easy to blow clean with a leaf blower. Just my opinion.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#21

Re: PS: Wafer board is cheaper

Allen Neighbors

>It's the formaldehyde in the glue. (that's my story and I'm stickin' to it.) :)

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#22

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Gil Jones

>Carole,

I used 4' X 8' X 1/2" OSB for all walls and the ceiling. All joints are caulked. R-19 (2" X 6") walls, and R-30 ceiling. No worries about stuff going thru the OSB. The shop is more temperature stable than our home is. Not so smooth as drywall, but who cares, it's a shop.

Gil

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#23

Dick Hines

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Dick Hines

>My first question to the builder is" who is paying for the shop?" You can but strips over the joints like board and batton houses. A friend of mine has his shop done that way and it works just fine.

I laso would not spend the time and money to paint the walls either. Once you start painting the walls you have to keep at it.

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#24

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Peter Hyde

>Carol you said

<>

If this is so why do you need a ceiling at all? The floor will be above the joists and seal off the work area from the storage upstairs.

Someone also mentioned using Tyvec to prevent air filtation well I'm sorry to say it doesn't work. Tyvek is designed to allow air to pass through.

With a stick construction roof and a floored attic there really is no need for a ceiling as long as the roof itself is insulated and has a vapour barrier installed. Here's a sketch of how the roof should be insulated. In your case the drywall under the roof rafters would not be necessary as it only is there to protect the vapour barrier. You could use 1/4" ply for that


img

Re: Shop Ceiling?

#25

Re: Shop Ceiling?

Karen F.

>Carol, If you can stand one more post on the subject. I just finished my shop last summer and left the trusses and joist showing and stapled insulation between the ceiling joist. I put in two of the wind turbines on the roof to circulate the air and drywall on the walls. When I was placing the drywall, I put tape on the floor at every wall studs so I would be able to find them later for hanging stuff. I have Home Depot epoxy on the floor and everything sweeps up and very little sticks to it. It's not slippery with the little sprinkles.

I then taped it all off and textured and spray painted myself. I must say it looks great. The white walls and ceiling bounce the light off and I can find everything I need. I hung my lights and I don't feel closed in at all. I built a Dixieline Garage kit (which is all the parts) which is 24 x 30.

That's my experience. Thanks Karen