Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

two-axis goblet

Posts

two-axis goblet

#1

two-axis goblet

JohnKJordan in East TN

>This black walnut goblet is in repsonse to a club challenge some months ago. I'm not sure about the base, but I love the way the rim turned out. For the first turning step, I used a mathematical sine wave for the profile.

I'll try to include a little how-to in the following message in case anyone is interested.

JKJ


img

Re: two-axis goblet

#2

two-axis goblet, sequence

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Turning sequence.

Modeling and rendering with 3DS Max.


img

Re: two-axis goblet

#3

Clever - thanks for posting!

Bill Howatt

>

Re: two-axis goblet

#4

JL

Re: So you could conceivably have two goblets?

JL

>That is if you had a large enough space between the turning axis and the bed. A 1642 would be a bit short, but a 3520 or so would be just the ticket.

Re: two-axis goblet

#5

Very clever, John, and ...

Ed Moore

>thanks for the modeling pictures. Having taught a lot of multivariable calculus and written extensive notes for it, I truly appreciate your efforts here.

Ed

Re: two-axis goblet

#6

I can cipher a little and do sums

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Actually I got as far a trig. I never did use it for anything though. Plane geometry was always my favorite math. I ended up using the geometry to lay out wall lines and the like.

Re: two-axis goblet

#7

Re: two-axis goblet, sequence

Ralph Watts

>John,

And, a fine looking goblet it is!

Ralph

Re: two-axis goblet

#8

Re: two-axis goblet, sequence

Donna Banfield

>John, that is VERY cool.

And thanks for the 3-D diagram. I'm math-impaired, and if you tried to explain it by describing this in writing, my eyes would've glazed over, and then my head would've exploded!

Re: two-axis goblet

#9

Re: two-axis goblet, sequence

Allen Neighbors

>John, you have gone much out of your way to help others. Thank you very much for being that type of person. You rock! :)

I can envision several different ways to use this same technique. Gotta go on my to-do list. :)

Re: two-axis goblet

#10

Cool! Thanks.

GaryG in MD

>Nice work and nice explanation. Unique and very helpful.

It gives me ideas. Love it.

BTW, looks like a cosine to me. ;-) ...Gary

Re: two-axis goblet

#11

Re: two-axis goblet, sequence

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Thanks for the kind words. Over the years I've illustrated and animated many hundreds of mostly technical, scientific, and architectural things used for explaining, planning, funding proposals, analysis, lobbying, and homicide reinactment, everything from brain tumor treatment to space vehicles to OJ Simpson's estate.

Now I'm retired, I'm always looking for an excuse to model something! It's almost as addictive as wood turning.

JKJ

Re: two-axis goblet

#12

Re: two-axis goblet, sequence

Lan Brady

>I agree with Allen,

You have gone above the call to help others.

Thanks,

Lan

Re: two-axis goblet

#13

Re: Cool! Thanks.

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>BTW, looks like a cosine to me. ;-)

We are both correct! Sine and cosine curves are identical - they are just out of phase by pi/2 (90deg).

I actually started at [0,0] on the left side of the square block and drew one complete sine cycle across the width. (the magenta curve in the little plot below) Shaping the outside cut away more of the left side of the curve then the right due to the wider diameter of the goblet at the further down from the top. In addition, hollowing took off far more of the "hump" at 90deg than I initially expected.

Like the inside-out turnings, visualizing the result in advance can be tricky!

JKJ


img

Re: two-axis goblet

#14

Re: You're an expert at it, too!

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: two-axis goblet

#15

Very good John!

Ron McKinley

>Thanks for the illustration! .....Ron

Re: two-axis goblet

#16

yes, but...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>So you could conceivably have two goblets?

>That is if you had a large enough space between

>the turning axis and the bed.

JL,

Yes, I considered that. For the 1642, making a couple of cups or small bowls instead would eliminate the need for a long stem. Seems like turning a long piece end over end on a big lathe would provide a certain amount of entertainment, or perhaps terror. Grain splitting off the trailing edge might get worse with a long stick. (BTW, wood choice is important for this kind of turning.)

However, I think there is another reason to keep the distance from the drive center to the endgrain curve as short as possible. The longer the distance, the "flatter" the endgrain curve will be (when viewed from the side, parallel to the first turning axis). The more extreme that curve, the more extreme the compound curved surface of the lip of a piece like this one.

A couple of things I forgot to mention:

1, instead starting with a cylinder, I actually left flats on the sided of the blank to make it easier to mount sideways between centers. 2, when remounting between centers to cut the tenon, I used a chisel to flatten small spots in the endgrain on both ends to properly seat the centers. I forgot to carry the flat spot through to the other illustrations.

JKJ


img

Re: two-axis goblet

#17

Re: two-axis goblet

eliot d

>Nice job. and beautifully described! I happen to be a mathematician, so I have no trouble with your sin function. What I don't see in your explanation is how to transfer the particular mathematical function, whatever it happens to be, to the turning. Do you make some kind of template and then just fit it by trial and error? Or is it a more exact method of some kind?

Re: two-axis goblet

#18

Re: two-axis goblet

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>how to transfer... to the turning. Do you make

>some kind of template and then just fit it by trial and error?

I drew out the desired curve on a 3x5 card, cut to make a template, traced the profile onto the wood, then used the template to check while turning. But eyeballing would have been fine. I just picked a sine wave for fun since it had a both high and low portions connected by a smooth transition. A freehand curve of any kind might have worked have worked as well, although I didn't particularly like the examples I saw at the club meeting.

BTW, I didn't mention it but I did make a quick prototpe with scrap wood as "proof of principle" before chucking up a good piece of walnut. I used a different profile curve on the prototype and decided a more extreme curve would work better.

JKJ

Re: two-axis goblet

#19

Sin function? Tell us more!

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>

Re: two-axis goblet

#20

Re: Sin function? Tell us more!

JohnKJordan in East TN

>The function of sin is self gratification, therefore it is written, deny thysel... oops, you were jest joshin', eh?

JKJ

Re: two-axis goblet

#21

Just having fun!

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Eliot's use of the word sin for the word sine tickled my funny bone. Usually it is me slaughtering the English language. I couldn't sit down through half of the eighth grade, because our English teacher gave us a swats for each word we missed on our spelling test if we missed more than three. I'm really glad computers have spell check.

Re: two-axis goblet

#22

Re: Just having fun!

eliot d

>The mathematical symbol for the sine function is 'sin' just as "cos" is what's used for the cosine; so I slipped into that mode. It never occurred to me for a minute that it's also the word for being sinful!

Re: two-axis goblet

#23

I forgot that!

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I haven't had to use that kind of math since 1971.