Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

To quench or not to Quench

Posts

To quench or not to Quench

#1

To quench or not to Quench

john lucas

>While looking through my copy of The compete guide to sharpening by Leonard Lee I came upon this. I believe it's been quoted by Jerry Glaser as well. You can't argue with those guys by here's my take. I've been quenching tools for years, long before I ever read that you shouldn't. I've never noticed a problem with my tools. Now I don't heat my tools up to the point that they turn color. Not even straw color. I quench often in water to keep the tool below this level. This is below 400 degrees. That was just the way I was taught. I'm always willing to learn and take this article seriously but it's hard to fall back on the old ways and I'll probably keep on quenching. I'll just keep the tool as cool as possible.

Thought you all might find this interesting.


img

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#2

Re: To quench or not to Quench

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>When I was just learning to sharpen my bowl gouges. I didn't have good wheels or a light touch. I got a Crown PM gouge way too hot and quenched it. Quenching is particularly bad for powdered metals. I Put the gouge to the wood and about and 1/8" of gouge's edge just fell off. The metal back past that point was still good and it is one of my favorite gouges. I find Leonard Lee's book very helpful also.

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#3

Re: To quench or not to Quench

Carole Valentine

>I never quench, but I use a very light touch on the grinder.

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#4

Steven Antonucci

I have perfect technique: Tormek :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#5

Re: To quench or not to Quench

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hmm....I don't quench as in dunk. But I do have a spray bottle of water that I use occasionally.

I'm probably cracking my tools all to hell. Good thing I have two and three of each one. Ha! Kidding, only two :)

I mostly do it so the end isn't hot when I go immediately back to the turning.

Jen

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#6

Re: To quench or not to Quench

Ron in Drums PA

>I don't quench, but then I can still touch the tool after sharpening without burning myself.

I use a high speed 6" grinder

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#7

Re: To quench or not to Quench

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I don't quench HSS alloys. When I'm doing major re-shaping, the tool sometimes gets way too hot to hold - a dark straw color - and I'll just set it aside to cool and do something else for a while. If I'm in a hurry, I'll use a spring clamp to hold it flat against the band saw table to cool more rapidly.

I still quench carbon steel, but I rarely grind carbon steel tools these days.

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#8

Here is a spray mist unit for any grinder. *LINK*

Keith Newton

>It sprays a fine cool mist right on the tool while the grinding is generating the heat, it is very effective at taking away the heat.

If you already have a grinder, spend $30 for this, you wont have to work about ruining your temper.

I have been using them for about 25 years.


http://www.littlemachineshop.com/products/product_view.php?ProductID=2725&category=

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#9

Re: To quench or not to Quench

Doug Turner

>John,

Jerry Glaser is a retired aerospace metalurgist and has performed tests to back up his statements.

Doug

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#10

Re: To quench or not to Quench

john lucas

>Doug I don't doubt Jerry or Leonard at all. Those guys have more brains in their little finger that I do. I'm simply saying that the way I sharpen and use my tools I can't tell the difference. I'm more of a practical kind of guy but I take all this reading and testing seriously and try to see how it applies to me and use the techniques if I can.

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#11

Re: To quench or not to Quench

Cyril Griesbach

>I'm with you on this one Brian.

Re: To quench or not to Quench

#12

Re: To quench or not to Quench

JohnKJordan in East TN

>If there are hidden cracks after quenching as he indicates, you can possibly detect them with a dye penetrant test. (Clean part, apply special dye, remove surface dye, spray with white powdery developer, inspect.) I've never inspected anything that small, but I think it will work.

Small aerosel cans of the materials are available from numerous sources. If you get back to Knoxville, it might be interesting to try this - I think I still have a partial can of the dye and developer from my days of crawling around inspecting nuclear reactors under construction.

JKJ