Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Bedan vs Skew

Posts

Bedan vs Skew

#1

Bedan vs Skew

john lucas

>You peeked my interest this morning so I played with all my skews tonight. I turned lots of beads with skews sharpened to steeper and shallower angles and my bedan with the bevel up and bevel down.

I really love the new Thompson skew. You can definitely feel the difference in vibration reduction with a skew that is thicker. The thompson is 5/16" thick and the Bedan is a little thicker.

I turned beads with skews sharpened 30 degrees, 40 degrees and 55 degrees. The Bedan is 40 degrees. That's measured from bevel to bevel by the way. I find the 40 degree skew the easiest for me to control on beads. The 30 was easier on long planing cuts. The 55 degree is one I ground so I could turn steeper coves using the skew. It is definitely the hardest when turning beads.

The bedan is very hard for me to control with the bevel up on beads. It works fine on flat surfaces but I just feel more comfortable with the bevel down. That's probably because I learned using a standard skew.

I was turning a knotty piece of pine. I ran through the knots a bunch of times with my Sorby skew and the Thompson. Then I did some planing cuts again with both. The Thompson is still giving me curls while the Sorby was giving curls but not as large or as clean. This was just a simple test but it tells me the Thompson holds a keen edge longer than my HSS tool.

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#2

Re: Bedan vs Skew

Allen Neighbors

>Okay, John, you have me really going, now. When you posted a pic of a skew earlier, and I questioned why it only had 1 bevel, you said a bedan only had one bevel. So it wasn't a pic of a skew, right?

Another question: When you name the angle of the skew, you said it was measured bevel to bevel. Like measuring this " < " and calling it an 80 degree angle?

Sorry I'm so dense. :)

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#3

Re: Bedan vs Skew

eliot d

>I suppose I shouldn't but it, but I like the way Allan Laser describes how to get a good angle for a skew. He suggests that the length of the ground portion of the edge should be about 1 1/2 times as long as the skew is thick. For example, if the skew is 3/16 " thick, then grind back the edges so that they are both 3/8 " long. This method will yield a bevel-to-bevel angle of 38.94 degrees ,which is to say 40 degrees for all practical purposes. If you want 30 degrees, instead, then grind back so the length of the grind is 1.93 times the thickness, i.e a little less than two times. This way, by using trigonometry, you don't have to make delicate angle measurements.

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#4

Re: Bedan vs Skew

john lucas

>Allen The Bedan is like a woodworking chisel. The back is flat and the other side has a bevel. A skew has a bevel on both sides. I've seen skew angles labeled both ways, bevel to bevel, and center line to bevel. In the examples below I show the bedan angle as 25 degrees. This is the way chisels and plane irons are measured.

When I say my skew is 40 degrees I use the bevel to bevel measurement because that is the wedge that splits the wood. This is the way drill bits are described as well. A drill with a 189 degree point is measured from the bevel of both cutting edges.

The bottom photo is the way I have seen some authors describe the angle of a skew. I don't know which is correct and I looked through several of my sharpening and metallurgy books trying to find a description and the proper terms for these 2 measurements. I seem to remember that the bevel to bevel measurement is called "included angle" and the center to bevel is called the sharpening angle. Since I can't find this in my books so far I am open to suggestions from the turning crowd so we can all speak the same language.


img

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#5

Re: Bedan vs Skew

john lucas

>Eliot That is the way I learned to sharpen a skew. 1 1/2 times the thickness. I didn't realize that it falls in the 40 degree range. I used it for years with that grind without ever measuring. I made a few skews and ground them differently to find the grind I liked and it ended up that I still like the 40 degrees. As my skills improve I find the 25 degree much easier to use but it's still more difficult for me.

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#6

Re: Bedan vs Skew

Robert D. Macgregor

>Some nitpicking: I think you have mixed up your geometry notation in the second and third drawings, since it looks to me like you have labelled a 320 degree angle as 40 degrees and a 160 degree angle as 20 degrees.

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#7

Re: Bedan vs Skew

john lucas

>Yea I guess it depends on how you look at it. Is your glass half full or half empty. I was comparing the 40 degree cutting angle to that of the bedan or chisel. Like I say, I don't really know the correct terms and I'm still digging through books to see what they say. Chisels and planes give the angle from the bottom to the bevel which would appear to be from bevel to bevel. Drill bits and metal lathe cutting tools often give the the other angle. It's confusing.

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#8

JL

Re: Why 25 degrees for a bedan?

JL

>

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#9

Re: Bedan vs Skew

eliot d

>25 degrees! Wow! That's a really shallow angle; it translates to grinding the edge back to about 2 1/3 times the thickness of the skew. So it's truly shallow. That is why you may be having some trouble controlling it. It probably will cut difficult woods better and need frequent sharpening, I would imagine.

Bill Grumbine demonstrated last night at our club (Montgomery County Woodturners ) in Bethesda, Maryland) , showing us some great skew chisel basics. He likes to turn spindle work at about 3000 rpm. And I thought 1800 was fast!

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#10

Re: Why 25 degrees for a bedan?

john lucas

>That was just a number I pulled from my head for the drawing. I really haven't measured the angle on that tool but I think it's somewhere in the 40 to 45 degree range. It looks very similar to my mortising chisels and I think they are 45 degrees.

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#11

I am "piqued" at your "peeking".

adrien

>

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#12

Re: Bedan vs Skew

eliot d

>The bottom photo is just wrong. Those angles are both greater than 180 degrees, which , of course, couldn't cut anything. The only proper way to interpret those diagrams is that one is to understand that --obviously -- the angle must be less than 180 and that the arrows are there simply to show which edges define the interior, acute, angle.

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#13

Re: Bedan vs Skew

john lucas

>Eliot your right. The arrows should be on the inside of the drawings. I did that early this morning and must not have been awake.

Re: Bedan vs Skew

#14

new drawing

john lucas

>Gordon was nice enough to redo my drawings so they are correct. Guess I'll have to devour more sugar and coke in morning before I start trying to use what little brain I have left. The tool I use to measure the anagles goes around the outside and I guess that was just in my brain.


img