Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

nice but not worth the trouble

Posts

nice but not worth the trouble

#1

nice but not worth the trouble

MFoster

>I was spltting firewood over the weekend and came across this nice spalting in section of the log. I had to put it on the lathe to see if it could be turned. Several places were just too punky to be worth the effort to get a finished piece from. I've tried the usual stabalization techniques before, and just don't feel it is worth the effort. Would have made a really nice hollow form though.


img

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#2

Re: 2X Wow!! So close... yet so far. :(

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#3

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

GaryG in MD

>I'll raise Allen to 3xWow!

IMO, that's worth a whole can of wood hardener!

Never seen anything quite like it. ...Gary

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#4

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

Keith Newton

>I'm curious. Is there a little bug hole in the middle of each of the tight little ring patterns on the lower half?

If you are not ready to give up on it yet, I would think about immersing it in water, and letting it get totally saturated. Then put it in a plastic bag, and freeze it. Turning ice is nice.

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#5

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

Pat Mulligan

>Too bad, Mike.There will be others.

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#6

Look nice but I totally agree, Mike

Ruth Niles

>You're right, it would have made a beautiful hollow form. You're also right, it's not worth all the work. I used to try to save spalted wood, now it all goes on the burn pile.

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#7

Steven Antonucci

You're kidding, right?

steve antonucci

>Mike-

That doesn't look too bad at all? I've turned a lot of spalted maple, and trust me, it can get a lot softer than what this one looks like.

If I didn't have 400# or so of the stuff in my turning pile, I'd ask you to send it to me. It's not a burner at all, and perhaps you just need to rethink the shape or size to get past the "soft" stuff.

Life is too short to burn "crappy" wood. Anyone can turn straight grained, solid kiln dried hardwood. Set it down, and take another look at it when you feel adventurous.

Steve

P.S. Whatever you do, please don't make it green! ;-)

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#8

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>I'm thinking stabilization and pen blanks!!!

Take care,

Jim

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#9

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Mike

I would love to have it. Let me know how much and I will send a check.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#10

Roger Dunn

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

Roger Dunn

>Dave Schweitzer is in our turning club. He demonstrated a technique for us on wood that was really punky. He turned the Maple to about 3/4 of an inch. then he mixed a two part epoxy (System 3) and thinned it 50/50 with Acetone. Then he heated the wood with a heat gun on both sides and painted on the epoxy and turned on the heat gun and it bubbled. He applied more epoxy and more heat until there were no more bubbles. Then when it was cooled, he finished turned , sanded and finished it and saved many beautiful bowls with this method.

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

#11

Re: nice but not worth the trouble

MFoster

>This was from a roadside sugar maple that was mostly dead and hollow. This piece of log came from a little ways up and represents 1/2 of the log. The ring "targets" have no bug in the middle, but seemed to be all through this section of the log, and were what really got my attention to give a go at turning it. Much of the whiter sections are punky, but some of the brown colored wood is REALLY punky. I tried a severe shear cut with a really sharp tool, and still got tear out. This brown wood makes it's way most of the thickness of the wood. I gave a quick try using thin CA, but really got no improvement. I have gone more the way that Ruth thinks, it could be possibly saved with stabalization techniques, but I would rather work with good wood and not fuss with trying to save bad wood.

Bill, if you want the wood, I'll seal it and send it to you for the cost of shipping. I have the piece shown, and it's match is out in the trash wood pile. They are both wet and relatively heavy. Email me if you're interested and I can weigh them and give you and idea of size.

Mike mfoster@vermontel.net