Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

What am I doing wrong?

Posts

What am I doing wrong?

#1

What am I doing wrong?

Ray Binnicker

>Have you ever got so mad at "yourself" you just wanted to throw something?

First; You would have to really stretch your imagination to call me a woodturner.

I want to be a woodturner. I think I have the potential to be a decent turner. I spend a good deal of time on the lathe. I make a pretty decent lidded end grain box. My bowls are not meant for the gallery, yet. But sharpening these @#$#%% tools is about to drive me up a wall !!!!! Especially these bowl gouges; trying to put swept back grind on them. I have the vari grind jig and have watched the video on-line a dozen times. I just came in from the shop totally, 100%, without a doubt, the most frustrated I can ever remember being!

I am 64 years old and served 26 years in the US Army and I can't ever remember feeling this dumb about something that can't be that difficult. I have ground away over an inch of a pretty good bowl gouge and finally give up.

UNCLE !!!

Ray Binnicker

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#2

Re: What am I doing wrong?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Ray, I have heard of turners using a bolt or some round stock to practice sharpening rather than their gouge. I don't know about the sharpening jig you are using; I have the Wolverine.

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#3

Re: What am I doing wrong? *LINK*

George Van

>Ray, Doug Thompson has a good instruction PDF on his web site that uses the Wolverine Jig. His instructions are pretty straight forward and will produce a good fingernail grind.


Thompson Tools

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#4

Re: What am I doing wrong?

john lucas

>Ray What most people I see do wrong is they just run to tool from on wing around the tip and back up the other wing. If you do this every time you just add to the problem. What you need to do is look for the high spots on the grind. As you rotate the tool from one wing to the other slow down and stay longer on the high spots until they start to look straight forming a smooth U shape. If you have low spots try to avoid them or touch them extremely lightly.

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#5

Re: What am I doing wrong?

Darryl

>Don't feel like one of a kind. I had and have the same problem. I sloved my horrible sharpening activities when I bought a Tormek system. Now I use the "Elsworth Grind" most of the time and just touch up the bevel in seconds when needed. Expensive yes but in my estimation it was the only thing that finally allowed me to rid myself of sharpening frustrations. Jet had a knock off of the Tormek that might be a bit less costly. Elsworth had a video that covers how to sharpen his grind. The AAW put out a sharpening video last year with membership that is very good for us in this boat. In short you are probably not doing anything wrong just covering the same footsteps that has and ave plagued many of us. Darryl

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#6

Re: What am I doing wrong?

adrien

>http://www.oneway.on.ca/multi-media/index.htm

is Oneway's site which has some pretty good videos free for the downloading.....

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#7

Being a NAVY man.....

Mike Jones

>Being a NAVY man, I never had that problem. (yeah, right!) I helped myself a great deal when I began to take very light passes, and looking at the grind often so that I could see what the stone was doing before I went too far. I got one side of the gouge to look like the picture, then worked at matching the other side, finally satisfied with that, I rounded the point little bits at a time, until it all came together.

I feel your pain, brother, and hope all these suggestions help.

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#8

Re: What am I doing wrong?

Ray Binnicker

>Thanks folks !!!

It helps a lot to just hear I'm not the only one struggling. I'm sure some one-on-one with an experienced turner would help a whole lot. Maby I should put some money in that direction for a while instead of ruining good tools.

Thanks again.

I'll be back.

Ray Binnicker

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#9

I feel your pain!

Rick Urban

>Been there done that, Ray. Looks like you have a lot of technical and product suggestions that are all good. Let me suggest...

I also use the varigrind for my gouges, and it was some time before I learned to use it to my satisfaction. (Disclaimer: everything here is my opinion.) *NAIL SOMETHING DOWN!* It doesn't matter what setting you start with. Keep that constant until you have a reason to change it. After that, have a reason for changing it. For reference, the varigrind I use has "notches" in the adjustment . For bowl gouges I use the notch second closest to "no angle at all" (usually). I then adjust the angle of the ground bevel to about 45 degrees (for general purpose use - more acute or obtuse for special instances). I make sure the profile is what I want on each side (generally symetrical) and then blend the nose. The side grind is anywhere between 1 and 2 times the diameter of the gouge steel.

One last comment before I run out of wind...

I recently helped another local woodturner with his sharpening. He had been doing it manually and was very frustrated. When he brought his tools over, I was amazed. He had been doing a fantastic job, and only the slightest adjustment in technique was needed.

Some one-on-one time with one of your fellow club members could do wonders!

Good luck! Be sure to give us a progress report.

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#10

Ditto re. the Tormek

JohnKJordan in East TN

>

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#11

Ric Taylor

I think the "Army" part is the problem

Ric Taylor

>There are some things about turning that are very difficult to learn by watching videos or reading books. Hopefully there is a turner or a club in your area that you can connect with, which will relieve much of your frustrations. If you check on the AAW website you can see if there are any clubs in your area.

Ric

Air Force, Retired

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#12

Go NAVY! Beat ARMY! AND ...

Ed Moore

>NOTRE DAME! WHAT A DAY!

Navy 46 Notre Dame 44

Ed Moore

Professor Emeritus

U.S. Naval Academy

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#13

Richard Allen

Re: What am I doing wrong?

Richard Allen

>Get some hands on help (it will take longer to drive over than the instruction will take).

Use a magic marker to help fine tune the extension of the "V" arm.

Use a light touch when sharpening.

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#14

Steven Antonucci

OT: slightly off color joke my grandfather told me

steve antonucci

>An Navy Admiral walks up to a latrine next to a Marine. They both tend to their business and the Admiral goes to the sink to wash his hands as the Marine begins to leave.

"Soldier, don't they teach you to wash you hands after you go in the Marine Corps?"

And the Marine responded, "No, sir. They teach us not to pee on our hands!"

Feel free to tell it any way you see fit, but that's how my grandfather (USMC) told it to me...

:-)

S

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#15

Re: OK soldier, by the numbers! Find a ......

Jamie Donaldson

>...good local turner to help you hands on, and practice on a bolt or some scrap rather than an expensive tool. The type of grinder is less important than understanding the process, and hello from former Sgt. Jamie,Screamin'Eagles!

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#16

Second the AAW video *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>I'm not master at the grinding wheel either. Twice as frustrating because sometimes I can do exactly what I want and then next time I seem to have forgotten how.

The AAW sharpening video is a very good one. Especially because it shows sharpening done by several people so you get more perspectives. I've also started using the set-up blocks described in a recent issue of American Woodturner to speed setting up the vari-grind jig.

You don't have to be a member to buy the video, but it is a little cheaper if you are one and the magazine you get for joining is probably the best one out there on turning. The back issue with the set-up blocks should be available as well. I'd have to check, but you may get the sharpening video for signing up to be a member. Might help to call and ask.

-Craig


American Association of Woodturners

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#17

Re: What am I doing wrong?

Ray Binnicker

>Thanks again folks,

I knew if I got the military envolved I would get this problem solved.

Well, it's 11:00 PM and time to go to bed; for all you non-Army types; that means the short hand is on the 11 and the long hand is on the 12. (:-)

SGM Binnicker

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#18

Re: What am I doing wrong?

kenny in indep MO

>Hello, for us Navy types that would be 2200 hours cause we can count higher :-)

Kenny LST 1161 Vernon Cty

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#19

Re: What am I doing wrong?

Karen F

>Well for us Non-Military but Law Enforcement type 11:00 PM is 2300 hours not 2200 hours (10:00 PM) and I'm working the night shift:(

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#20

Black Felt Marker

Jorge Castaneda

>Ray,

I had the same troble as you ; then somebody sugeasted to shape the profile of the tool first and then sharpen it, that works, but the best tip was to use a marker to blaken all the bevel, then touch lightly and see where it is grinding and keep making minute corrections and blackening again until you get a uniform grind, now I don't even think about it...

Practice makes perfect

Jorge

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#21

Re: What am I doing wrong?

Barry Irby

>I apply the KISS principle.

I took a class from David Ellsworth at Arrowmont and liked what I saw. I bought the gouge and the Sharpening attachment while I was there. I got the 8" low speed grinder from Woodcraft and some square steel tubing form The Borg and set up a grinding station. I did not buy the Wolverine jigs.

I drilled a hole in the front of the grinder base and glued in a nickel at the right depth. The nickle keeps me from wearing out the hole and making it deeper over the years. I put the square tube in a set of tracks under the right hand wheel and attached a little block of hardwood to it with a pocket in it to receive the foot of the Ellsworth Jig. I arranged the height and distance as the instructions indicated. The Tube will slid in and out, but after I got it set, I bolted it down. Everything stays put. The socket for the jig stays in place and the jig is dedicated to this task and is not adjustable. I put the jig on the gouge and set it by inserting it into the hole, so the "extension' remains the same. Then I give the tool one or two quick very light passes over the stone and go back to turning. I have not changed any part of the setup in years. I know the stone grinds away, but the Ellsworth tool is my "go to" tool and I seldom use this wheel on the grinder for anything else, so any loss in diameter has been extremely slight. I have been using this set up for about seven years and it may be time to check the diameter of the wheel and the distances to see if something has changed enough to make any difference. I think I have ground away less than an inch of the gouge.

To sharpen my gouge I insert it in the jig and kiss it very lightly to the wheel and take the crud off the bevel, leaving it shiny. Or if you ink that surface, you knock the ink off and almost no metal. Literally way under a hundredth of an inch. Someone in the local turning club said he turns the grinder on, lets it come up to speed, turns it off and sharpens his gouge as it slows down.

I participated in a club event where about ten of us were turning. someone brought their grinder and we shared. They had the Wolverine set up. Appeared very similar to mine and I used it for a day. The differences were subtle, but it slightly changed the profile of my gouge. The changes made the gouge feel "grabby" to me and I was glad to get back to my grinder and get it back to its old profile. This is not a criticism of the Wolverine jig. I am just saying that once you find a set up you like, stick with it. Really stick with it. Not sort of like it or close, lock it down and stay with what works for you.

Also, once you get the tube on the Wolverine set where it works for you, you can make a gauge block that lets you reset it accurately. Perhaps a "triangle" that touches into the socket of the tool, the steel tube and the face of the wheel so that you can get it just right every time you have to move it.

Re: What am I doing wrong?

#22

Wolverine Jig Jig

Rick Urban

>Here's a picture of a jig to consistently set the distance from the Wolverine cradle to the grinding wheel modeled after one Joe Ruminski showed my club. I've since made an adjustable model, but these cheap 'n ugly ones served well for some time. This one is marked "medium" and there were others for the acute and obtuse grinds I was using at that time. Whatever the design, the idea is to maintain the "correct" angle at the business end of the gouge being sharpened.


img