Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Made two toolrests for my lathe.

Posts

Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#1

Made two toolrests for my lathe.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>When I purchased my used PM 3520 it came with a Best Tools modular toolrest. After using this for the few items I have turned on my lathe I decided to replace it as I don't think it was the right toolrest for my skill level. I felt that I needed to get tool support closer to the work. Longer, beefier tool handles would also help. My lathe is the pre A model and it has a banjo for use with a post of 1 1/8" dia. I couldn't find any of the original type toolrests on the internet, for sale, so I decided to make an 8" and 12" myself.

I used a close variant of the toolrest cross section that is described in Mike Darlow's "Fundamentals of Woodturning" book (pg. 29). I used 5/8" 4142 precision ground material from McMaster-Carr. The post material is O1 drill rod material, also from McMaster-Carr.

I was able to use a freed up mill at my friend's shop to do the milling of the "bird's mouth" on the round and bevel on the flat stock. For the 30 degree bevel I had to make a fixture to hold and clamp the bar so that I could use an endmill to machine the bevel. The project took a little longer than I thought and overall consumed 12hrs. The TIG welding was done at a local motorcycle shop. for $40.00, as my welder doesn't have enough power for this thickness of material. I'm real, real glad that my friend let me use his shop and equipment. I'll be buying him lunch for a while.

Now that I have the lathe it was just the tool rest that was holding me back, right? I hope to try these out tomorrow evening.


img

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#2

Pic. of jig for beveling cross piece.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>This is a simple clampig jig that I had to make to hold the flat stock in the milling machine vise to create the 30 degree bevel. While it was a simple jig it took me a while to make as I was using scrap Alu. pieces and had to square up the various pieces. The main body was made as one piece then sawed in two. It's a bad picture and it doesn't show the corner relief to acommodate the sharp corner of the flat stock.

Now it's pretty clear why these toolrests,the good ones, are so pricey. The set up and fixturing is costly for a short run.


img

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#3

Re: Pic. of jig for beveling cross piece.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Eddie, you did a fine job on the tool rests. The 30 degree angle is a great idea, let us know how they work.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#4

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

eaglesc

>I have made tool rests for my Jet using 5/8ths bolts as round stock and are serviceable.

I like your design as it allows you to position the rest closer to the work piece.

After seeing your design I came up with the idea of welding a piece of angle inverted on the round stock to allow the leading edge of the rest to be placed closer to the work.

This would alleviate having to mill the sqaure stock.

Tool rests for pens need not be as robust as yours.

Thanks for posting the picture

Nice job

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#5

Real Nice Eddie

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#6

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

john lucas

>Good job Eddie. I'm still trying to design the perfect tool rest but I will probably need a metal casting facility to do it. Robust lathes has the closest design to what I want.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#7

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

Brent English

>Hi Eddie - the rests are really well crafted but one thing to watch out for is that you welded two heat-treatable alloys. In other words, you may have an isolated hard (read brittle) area in the weld that could fail during heavy cuts. Maybe your welding guys annealed the weldment, but based on the bright color of the steels, my guess is they did not. Now I know some of you will claim that these grades are oil-hardening and as long as they are not quenched, this won't be a problem. The thing is, when you have a big mass like this and a small isolated are of high heat from welding, the big mass acts as the quench. A simple test would be to take a sharp file with a fine cut and gently try to file the weld and the metal immediately adjacent to the weld. If the file cuts it, you're fine. If the file skims over the weld like it's on glass, then the weld is hard (brittle) and you need to get these annealed for safety sake. To anneal you bring the steel up above it's critical temperature (roughly 1600-1800F) and let it cool slowly - best done in a heat treat oven, but there are ways to "blacksmith" it if you have a oxy/fuel torch. Reguluar old mild steel would have been a better material choice if you make welded rests. Good luck, as I said, they are really well made, just the material selection and welding might cause you a problem when you least expect it.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#8

Steven Antonucci

Those would make nice Xmas presents!

steve antonucci

>Seriously, now that you have the jigs and such ready, how long would it take to make a bunch? You could bring a couple of sets to your turning club for raffles, and send them out to your turning friends as presents.

You'd never know they weren't "professional"...

Great job.

Steve

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#9

How about cold rolled?

Rick Urban

>Do I understand correctly, Brent, that my tool rests made from welding cold rolled round should be ok? Mine are nowhere as nice looking as Eddie's, but they were a lot easier to make, and I've not had any problems in the year I've been using them. I was planning on making some others, but this thread suggests I should get smarter before doing so.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#10

Pic didn't upload before

Rick Urban

>trying again...


img

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#11

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

eliot d

>I promise you that I'm not trying to be a PITA, but ... I honestly don't understand what's wrong with the tool rests that come with the PM 3520A. I have never had any serious problems with either of ones I have. What is it that you think you can do with your new (beautifully made) tool rests that you can't do with the original ones? (I confess that sometimes, when using a skew chisel, I wish I could wrap my left for

finger under the rest, and the tool rest post gets in the way. But I'm not sure your designs would solve that problem.) Would you tell us, honestly, how your turning has improved with these new rests?

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#12

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

Troy German

>Eliot,

I think you explained one of the problems when you talked about the tool post being in the way. It�s like having someone bump your elbow every once in a while. Even if it�s predictable, it�s annoying and can cause mistakes. It looks like on the new toolrest ones finger could slide along the flat part of the rest unmolested.

Eddie,

They look great. Enjoy using them.

Troy

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#13

You're not being a PITA , Eliot.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Yes, I wish I had the stock Powermatic toolrest as well. I got the lathe used from the 2nd owner and when he got it it didn't have a tool rest. He purchased the Best Woodtools tool rest. These pre-'A' 3520's need 1 1/8" dia. tool posts and they are hard to find on the used market. Skillwise, I'm not there yet to be able to use a modular tool rest without getting some chatter from my cutting tools on small work. The gap from support line of contact to cutting edge is about 1/2" depending on the piece being worked.

Here is the link to the Best Woodtools site.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#14

Yes, I was concerned too.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>I was mainly concerned with the 4142 material as it comes at a C28-C32 hardness. It machined better than I thought and I was taking off .030" material with each pass. This was on a Bridgeport mill with no oil mister, no digital readout, and I walked uphill both ways to the shop...:-) I was handbrushing the oil on.

On a nice CNC machine, with full coolant spary, the bevel would really look nice. It would be done quicker too!

Last night when I smoothed the edges I did file at the the weld area and I was able to remove material at the same rate. I'll go check again to make sure as I would have to call in another favor to get access to a small heat treat oven for annealing.

I certainly think regular steel would have worked, but after 3 trips to a local place that has lots of scrap and new steel, I didn't find any 1 1/8" rod. I could have turned down larger material to size which would have entailed more sponging of my friend's generosity. I certainly went overboard on the steel selection.

Thanks.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#15

Some Shop Made Tool Rests by Art Ransome *LINK*

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>Here is a link to Art's website. He has other interesting things on it.

Art is one my hero's. He is so practical and a genuine nice guy, for a lot of reasons.

I have made some rests using Art's ideas and he explains how he makes his. He doesn't apologize for them not being pretty, but they sure are functional.

They are not at "professional" as Eddie's but they are another way of making a useful rest.

Clem


Art Ransome's Shop Made Tool Rests

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#16

Those aren't going to break, Rick.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>You'd be on the floor, after bouncing off the ceiling, before those welds let go. Don't grind too much on the welds to clean them up as it reduces their strength.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#17

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

john lucas

>I like the powermatic 12" rest but the short rest sucks. I had to grind off the lump where the tool post goes and it's hard to get my fingers around it when turning small things.

I'm very happy with my Bestwoodtools tool rest most of the time. The only problem I have with it is your hand hits the center post as you slide by it doing long cuts. Vic suggested buying a 1" post instead of the 3/4. That would solve the problem but I still think I can build a better one, or I'll just buy the one from Brent and give it a try.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#18

Re: Some Shop Made Tool Rests by Art Ransome

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>I had seen that website a long time ago and forgot to bookmark it. Thanks for reposting it.

thansk for the compliment too.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#19

OK... Let's rock and roll!

Rick Urban

>Thanks, Eddie. That's about all I needed to encourage me to get off my duff and make those others I need (read that as want).

I learned (sort of) how to weld from my dad 45 years ago. I don't know much about what rod to choose or other technical stuff, but I've done some pretty hefty things (all mild steel) and had only 2 break (rebar to mild steel), but I'm in a different arena now. I need to do more homework, but it's tough to work in with my "honey do" list.

Thanks again for the encouragement.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#20

Re: You're not being a PITA , Eliot.

eliot d

>Sorry, but there's no link.

Are you saying that a modular tool rest requires more turning skill? Why would it? I guess I have not thought enough about the tool rest issue.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#21

Re: How about cold rolled?

Brent English

>To the fellow that asked about cold rolled - you bet, that's fine. It's mild steel.

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#22

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

Pete in Holland

>Eddie -

I assume you used a vertical mill, kinda like a Bridgeport to mill your stock? The head on those mills tilt left to right, and front to back. You didn't need to build the fixture to create the angle. Just tilt the head, clamp the stock in the vice, and go !

Pete

Re: Made two toolrests for my lathe.

#23

That scheme works if it's your own mill.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>In a production shop, setting up amd retraming a mill is not taken lightly. It's way better to make a dedicated fixture that you can take from mill to mill, shop to shop.