Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Alcohol soaking question?

Posts

Alcohol soaking question?

#1

Alcohol soaking question?

Jim Miles-Charlotte, NC

>Always read about alcohol soaking, but never tried it.

I now have some wood that I need to process as quickly as possible into bowls. Couple of questions:

1. I assume you would rough turn the bowl - when it soaks does it go oval? How much oversize do you need to turn it?

2. How long do you soak? 3. Does alcohol change anything about how you have to finish the wood? TIA

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#2

Steven Antonucci

my experience

steve antonucci

>I DNA soak for "a while"- sometimes a few hours, sometimes I forget for a day or ten. Usually , at least overnight.

Bowls go out of round and need to be returned. Usually, I follow the 10% rule thickness vs width.

No issues with finishing so far.

Steve

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#3

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

Ruth Harding

>Jim, go into the articles section on the left and you will see Dave Smith's details. Also do a search here because it comes up about every two months.

r

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#4

Re: my experience

arthur mc viccar

>I have 7 small bowls soaking right now. I roughed them out before lunch today. I will take them out of the dna tomorrow morning when I first go to the shop. They range in dia from 4-7" and all have wall thickness of about 1/2 to 5/8". Pretty thin, especially to be rechucking, but I got this show coming up in about 45 days and I got get them dry. I am lucky enough to own a diginal weight scale, and I have done a lot of dna soaking and then weighting, and tracking the weigh for a number of days. I can tell you that for bowls this size the weight will stabalize in 2 weeks, and in the 3rd week I will be returning them. For bowls of 1" wall thickness I have for that the weight will stabalize in about a month. I understand that the little digital postal scale can be had for about $30.00.

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#5

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

ryker acuna

>I just starting using alcohol and I always leave my peice overnight. I use pure alcohol, no thining. I change the solution about every 10 to 15 turnings depending on the size. This might not be the conventional or professional way but it works really well for me. No problems with finishing so far. Good luck.

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#6

Re: my experience

Jim Miles-Charlotte, NC

>I would think that a bowl turned to 1/2 to 5/8 would "dry" to stable weight just sitting on the shop table without anything done to it in 3 weeks. So what effect does the alcohol have ?

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#7

I'll be darned!!

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hello Arthur,

I guess they do have internet sevice down there. :)

Hope all is well. We sure miss you at the meetings.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

Dick Hines

>I have been useing the DNA method for a couple of years and love it. Most of my turnings start as wet wood. I don't weight my roughed out pieces because some are large and I am to cheap to buy a large set of scales. Useily 4-6 weeks on the shop floor will dry the pieces so I can return them.

I have never changed the DNA I just add to the vat. When I started useing it the price was $10 a gal. The last I got was $15 a gal. When I add new to the vat I useily pout in 3-4 gal at a time and that seems to work ok.

Read Dave Smith's artical about DNA. It will tell you all you need to know.

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#9

Ruth Is Right, Go To The Source

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Alcohol soaking - FUNCTION THEORY

Jesper, Denmark

>let me start by saying that I have not tried this method. I seem to make far more blanks than finished bowls, so time of drying is not a problem.

There has been a lot of discussion of how to do this, but I do not remember any explanations of why it works. The following is just a logical reasoning from physical behavior of mixtures.

Nature wants everything to be evenly mixed. So when you dump a wet bowl in 95% alcohol, 5% water solution, the liquid in the bowl wil equilibrate with the liquid in the bucket, so that the water/alcohol proportion is the same inside the wood as in the liquid in the bucket.

That this process takes from a few hours to a few days makes sense. When you are finished, the water in the wood is now replaced with the same water/alcohol mixture in the bucket. You have in fact extracted water from the wood and replaced it with alcohol.

The second function is that water and alcohol forms an azeotrope (look it up). It is a minimum boiling azeotrope, where the liquid mixture evaporates faster than either of the two liquids alone, AND the proportion of water in the vapor space is higher than in the liquid in the wood. At the same time, it takes less energy (about 75% less)to evaorate alcohol than water.

So in short: the alcohol extracts water from the wood and the drying alcohol also extracts more water and takes less energy: Result is faster drying.

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#11

Re: Alcohol soaking

pfduffy

>There is an additional benefit; reduction of distortion of the wood. The DNA process allows the bowl blanks to achieve a level of stability without a whole lot of distortion, it seems to me, and that in itself is a big benefit to the process. my2cnts. Philip

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#12

Ellis Walentine

Wow, a technical explanation!

Ellis Walentine

>Jesper, thanks for your explanation. Not being a scientist, I can only assume that what you say is accurate. Regardless, it explains a lot to me.

Ellis

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#13

bound as well as free?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Jesper,

Thanks for your comments. This has always been a fascinating subject. I am collecting a file of notes on this subject. A few questions, if you have time. You wrote:

>the liquid in the bowl wil equilibrate

>with the liquid in the bucket,

1. Do you imagine the bound water (that in the cell walls) comes to equilibrium as well as the free water (that in cell cavities) during the typical soaking times? If so, I've always wondered how long that would take for cells, say, 1/2" deep in something like the wall of a 1" cherry bowl?

[The literature indicates shrinkage doesn't begin until the bound water begins to evaporate (below fiber saturation point(FSP)).]

2. Do you have an idea about how much faster, say, a 50% alcohol-water solution evaporates than water, say, at 70% humidity and 70F?

If it takes (rule of thumb) one year for 1" thick wood to come to equilibrium moisture content (EMC) in those conditions, about how much faster would an alcohol-water saturated piece of 1" wood come to EMC? Would it actually drop BELOW EMC due to the azeotropical property you mentioned?

3. Most people who use this process appear not to use "fresh" alcohol each time but reuse the alcohol solution, adding undiluted alcohol as needed to make up lost volume. After soaking a number of bowls, would not the water content of the solution become high and the effectiveness of the process decrease? Is there a simple process to remove the water from the alcohol (other than, say, using a still)?

Also, I have a rough sketch of a perhaps scatterbrained theory as to one reason this may work to reduce warpage in bowls as some report. Since the typical (non-burl) bowl is cross-grain, it normally shrinks a great deal across the grain (tangential or radial to the tree) and very little with the grain (longitudinal). Since the end grain pores are open to the surface, the cells should be able to come in contact with the alcohol solution and mix far more rapidly AND evaporate more rapidly than out through the side grain. It would be interesting to find out if alcohol does something chemically to the lignin, similar that of the traditional boiling method, or if it affects the total shrinkage in either the radial, tangential, or longitudinal direction relative to untreated wood.

I would love to do some experiments on this someday. I thought I'd have more time after retirement but so far that hasn't happened.

JKJ

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#14

Dick Hines

Re: bound as well as free?

Dick Hines

>We are getting into this way to deep. I use and I think it works for me. I guess that is the important thing. It's the "If it feels good ,do it" thing.

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#15

Re: bound as well as free?

Ruth Harding

>I believe all of these questions, and more, have been asked and answered by Dave several times in the last couple of years....and more before that.

He has done all of the research, he will give you all the scientific words you want...just read his stuff.

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#16

Percentage of water

Charlie Anderson

>I asked a chemist friend how to measure the percentage of water and alcohol. He only had one way for me to tell. Said to take the lid of the container for a couple of days and the solution will be 100% water!!!

Dave Smith explains how to determine the percentage on his website.

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#17

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

Jim Miles-Charlotte, NC

>Thanks for all the imput, opinions, experience advice and direction to additional info

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#18

No reason not to.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Remember, bound water is a woodworker's term. The water isn't strongly bonded to the wood structure with chemical (i.e. covalent) bonds. As someone mentioned two years ago, the bonding is probably hydrogen bonding. Alcohols play the hydrogen bonding game almost as well as water does. The "bound" water will be in equilibrium with the water/alcohol mix inside the cells. The empirical evidence indicates that alcohol replaces the water in the cell wall structure. The empirical evidence also indicates that the inner cells reach equilibrium during an overnight soak.

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#19

Most answers posted on blog *LINK*

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>The property that is at work is miscible:

Relating to two or more substances, such as water and alcohol, that can be mixed together or can dissolve into one another in any proportion without separating.

I have compiled a lot of information on a blog which helps to keep the information from getting fragmented. Unfortunately as the information is passed from turner to turner is gets changed a little like the old game of telephone.

I presented at SWAT last month and met several people who are using the process with excellent results. I would like the chance to present at other symposiums but my funds are limited.

Dave Smith

Soaking and turning in Longview, WA.


Alcohol soaking blog

Re: Alcohol soaking question?

#20

Jesper, Denmark

Re: bound as well as free?

Jesper, Denmark

>John,

To answer your questions:

1. I do not really know, but it would makes sense that it would. The cell walls are permeable membranes, so there should be no reason why the alcohol would not penetrate, as we know the water does.

2. i also do not kow, but the physical properties sugeest that it would be faster.

3. The alcohol will extract water from the wood into the alcohol in the bucket, and over time, the mixture will be less alcohol. I do not know at what concentration it will work less efectively, but I suspect that you will have to be below 40% alcohol before it would have any effect.

I will have to re-iterate: I have not tried this and have no bowl soaking experience. It was just suddenly clear in my head why it worked.