bound as well as free?
JohnKJordan in East TN
>Jesper,
Thanks for your comments. This has always been a fascinating subject. I am collecting a file of notes on this subject. A few questions, if you have time. You wrote:
>the liquid in the bowl wil equilibrate
>with the liquid in the bucket,
1. Do you imagine the bound water (that in the cell walls) comes to equilibrium as well as the free water (that in cell cavities) during the typical soaking times? If so, I've always wondered how long that would take for cells, say, 1/2" deep in something like the wall of a 1" cherry bowl?
[The literature indicates shrinkage doesn't begin until the bound water begins to evaporate (below fiber saturation point(FSP)).]
2. Do you have an idea about how much faster, say, a 50% alcohol-water solution evaporates than water, say, at 70% humidity and 70F?
If it takes (rule of thumb) one year for 1" thick wood to come to equilibrium moisture content (EMC) in those conditions, about how much faster would an alcohol-water saturated piece of 1" wood come to EMC? Would it actually drop BELOW EMC due to the azeotropical property you mentioned?
3. Most people who use this process appear not to use "fresh" alcohol each time but reuse the alcohol solution, adding undiluted alcohol as needed to make up lost volume. After soaking a number of bowls, would not the water content of the solution become high and the effectiveness of the process decrease? Is there a simple process to remove the water from the alcohol (other than, say, using a still)?
Also, I have a rough sketch of a perhaps scatterbrained theory as to one reason this may work to reduce warpage in bowls as some report. Since the typical (non-burl) bowl is cross-grain, it normally shrinks a great deal across the grain (tangential or radial to the tree) and very little with the grain (longitudinal). Since the end grain pores are open to the surface, the cells should be able to come in contact with the alcohol solution and mix far more rapidly AND evaporate more rapidly than out through the side grain. It would be interesting to find out if alcohol does something chemically to the lignin, similar that of the traditional boiling method, or if it affects the total shrinkage in either the radial, tangential, or longitudinal direction relative to untreated wood.
I would love to do some experiments on this someday. I thought I'd have more time after retirement but so far that hasn't happened.
JKJ