Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Point tool grinding - Lucas?

Posts

Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#1

Point tool grinding - Lucas?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Seems like I read or saw a clever way of using a large hex nut to index the sides when grinding a three-facet point tool but I can't remember the details. Was this a John Lucas special?

Seems like it involved resting three of the sides on the toolrest while grinding. I tried this and it worked well, but I didn't come up with an elegant way to hold the nut firmly on the tool shaft. ???

JKJ

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#2

If I may

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I believe I can be of some assistance here. One of the easiest ways to use a hex nut to aid in the sharpening of a 2 point tool is to use a Brass Compression nut as the ferrule!

Alas I cannot take credit for this astonishing find. I believe it was William Duffield who showed it to me at the 2006 5 Barns BBQ. And Stacey Hager wrote several fantastic articles for the American Association of Woodturner's Journal

But on the off chance that you've already made your 3 point tool with a round ferrule, I would get a large brass compression nut with a large enough inner diameter to accommodate your 3 point tool shaft. You could always turn a small bushing from hard wood to make it fit snugly over the shaft and then use that to help position the tool for sharpening. Heck, you could even drill and tap a hole in the side for a small set screw if your industrious enough!

Good luck,

Dominic


img

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#3

Re: If I may

john lucas

>Excellent idea Dom. I put a set screw in one side of the nut and fasten it to the shaft. Then just grind the tool on every other flat. What I didn't do was grind a flat somewhere on the blade so the nut could be replaced in exactly the same place every time it needs regrinding. Dominic's friend solved that problem very nicely.

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#4

Re: Point tool grinding - My way

Mike Brazeau

>I made a Point tool from a shock absorber based on the article that appeared in the AWT, but felt the difficulty of sharpening is way overblown, but that could be because we are bilingual in Canada and use English and Metric measurements. I wrapped a piece of masking tape around the shaft, sliced through the overlapped joint with an exacto type knife, removed the tape and stuck to a piece of plastic. I then measured the length in millimeters and divided into three, marked clearly with a Sharpie marker, reapplied the tape, marking the joint as well. Then to sharpen just hold so that a mark is vertical and grind away. Subsequent grindings are then quick touchups holding the tool so a facet is pointing up and sharpening until you see sparks flying off both outside surfaces. I use the tool rest when re-grinding only to support my hand. I have been using for almost two years now with no problems of it going awry and always give a quick touchup before using. Here is a shot on initial grinding on a 1/4" version I made out of drill rod. This tool is a great asset to have.


img

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#5

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

Colin Spencer

>John

FWIW I have found that it doesn't matter that all three sides are the same. I have in fact ground mine with a longer facet on one side and find that it is even more flexible this way. AS to the initial shaping I used my grinder first and then used my disk sander to flatten the facets. Now all I do to sharpen it is a couple of quick swipes per facet with my diamond file. This works for me anyway.

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#6

Colin Grind :)

john lucas

>That might be interesting to try. I'll have to tell everyone I have a Colin grind on my point tool. :)

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#7

Steven Antonucci

That's how mine is too

steve antonucci

>When I made mine, I figured it didn't really matter what the angles were, as long as they met in a point. I ground three flats on an inverted belt sander, then sharpened the point on the side of my Tormek wheel. I hone with a little diamond file in between sharpening as well.

By having the different angle available, sometimes it makes it easier to get into details with the "skinny point". Plus, I don't need to worry too much about perfect setup on sharpening. I didn't even bother to harden the point, since you remove so little wood with it (I didn't want the blackened tip...)

Steve

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#8

Re: If I may

JohnKJordan in East TN

>John L, ah, the set screw. I used some tape which worked OK but a set screw would be better. Thanks.

After my limited use, I agree about the angles not being critical, however the little nut guide really works well.

Dominic, good idea about the nut ferrule. However, I reground a tool that was already handled. Also, it when I used a nut I found it convenient for my grinding setup to put it much closer to the tip.

JKJ

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#9

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I grind mine by setting the handle in the pocket of the sliding arm of my wolverine jig. I laid out three dots on the perimeter of the butt of the tool handle. I scribed a center line on the end plate of the sliding arm. I align a dot with the scribed line and slide the arm until I have the grind angle matched. Grind lightly: rotate tool, align second dot, grind: rotate tool, align third dot, grind, done! I can do that faster than I can type this message. I do touch up with a diamond card between trips to the grinder.

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#10

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

eliot d

>What can you do with this point tool that you can't do with a skew?

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#11

it is a better weapon

robert davis

>

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#12

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas? *LINK*

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>What can you do with this point tool that you can't do with a skew?

Someone posted this link to a video recently:


point tool demonstration

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#13

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

eliot d

>Just about impossible to get the link to work.

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#14

Re: it is a better weapon

eliot d

>Haven't answered my question.

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#15

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

Lan Brady

>Wow! 1001 ways to do the same thing.

as for advantages over the skew, I can work it in and out on the next bead much easier without a catch. I am always cutting below the equator of the tool. Experienced people may not have that concern, but I do.

Lan

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#16

Steven Antonucci

Point tools don't catch

steve antonucci

>While they don't cut as well as a skew, you can't get a catch with a point tool. Somedays, I'll use my skew, and other days when I'm not "feeling it", I reach for the point tool knowing that there's almost no chance I'll mess it up.

Steve

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#17

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Just about impossible to get the link to work.

That's what I thought at first, but after waiting a while the video played fine. High speed cable here.

JKJ

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#18

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

Halsey

>Vidio worked fine John.Thanks Halsey

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#19

Re: Point tools don't catch

john lucas

>Ditto what Steve said. I'm pretty good with a skew but when I'm in the final stages of duplicating something for a client, sometimes I'll get nervous and reach for the point tool to finalize the shape of the bead. I could do it with the toe of the skew but the point tool really is comfortable to use once you've played with it enough.

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#20

Re: to answer Eliot's question

russ Fairfield

>There are many ways to do the same thing. You can do the things shown in the video with either a skew or a spindle gouge. I have seen an old time spindle turner do these same things with the corners on a roughing gouge, and I use a parting tool.

Some tools require more skill than others, and which one you use is a personal choice. The 3-point tool has the lowest "fear factor" of any of the tools that we might use. John referred to that as its being the least likely to having a catch.

Re: Point tool grinding - Lucas?

#21

Re: to answer Eliot's question

eliot d

>O.K. fair enough. Ever since I added a Jet Mini lathe without-- variable speed-- to my shop, I been practicing turning at fairly high speed (1800 rpm) with a skew chisel (because I'm too lazy to fool with the pulleys.) So I've gotten fairly comfortable with it now. So, apparently, the answer to my question is not that you can make a different cut, but that it's may be possible for some of us to do it at all.