Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Posts

Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#1

Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Philip Morris

>OK, all the recent treads on box turning have got me interested in trying one. What are the advantages/disadvantages of the different grain orientations (i.e., face vs end grain)?

Thanks,

Philip

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#2

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Doug Turner

>Side grain tends to warp out of round and then the lid doesn't fit.

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Mike Stafford

>Doug summed it up in a very few words. A box lid will fit much better for a longer of time when the box is turned end grain wise. This is true until the box gets too large and too large is somewhere around 5 inches or so. At that point seasonal contraction and expansion will have some effect on the fit of the lid.

You can turn boxes with face grain but just don't expect the lid to fit well all the time. When I turn boxes from face grain blocks I always make the lid a loose fit so it can be opened one handed. If you make it fit too snugly you can count on seasonal variation causing some fitting problems.

Here is a picture of one I turned recently from some curly maple that is 4 1/2" in diameter and 2 1/2" tall.


img

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#4

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Philip Morris

>Mike,

Thanks for the response. Like the rest of the work you have posted recently, it is a beautiful box. Based on your comments and most of what I have seen you post, I assume that you prefer the end grain boxes?

I saw the article you posted on WOW for turning an end grain lidded box. The page numbering implied that it was an excerpt of a larger document on box turning. Is the entire work available somewhere on the web?

Thanks again,

Philip

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#5

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Philip Morris

>Doug,

Thanks for the response. I have seen several face grain boxes on display in a local gallery with the problem you describe. On some, I gave up trying to remove the lid for fear I would break off the finial.

Philip

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Mike Stafford

>Phillip, it was an excerpt of a much longer document that I use when teaching new turners to turn boxes. It starts at turning an elementary face grain box and then several variations thereof including inlays, overfitting lids, infitting lids and lidded bowls with finials (not of the Cindy Drozda caliber by the way). The culmination of the course was turning an end grain box. It was designed to be a 5 day course. Incidentally the tutorial for turning end grain boxes is available now in the WoodCentral articles section.

Yes, I do prefer turning end grain boxes because I like the challenge. However I still turn a lot of face grain boxes because they are easier, sell well and sometimes do a better job of displaying grain than an end grain box. Folks like a box that can be opened with one hand and can store anything from paper clips to a stash of candy.

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#7

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>WHERE do you teach these classes, Mike?

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Mike Stafford

>Carol, I taught at American Sycamore in Indiana last year and I teach at Woodcraft. I hope to assist Ed Moore in a box and ornament class at John C. Campbell Folk School in August in Brasstown, NC.

All of my students received an illustrated 100+ page handout for all the projects we did in the class. The end grain box tutorial referred to earlier was the last section in the handout.

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

#9

Re: Box Question (End or Face Grain)

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>Darn! The wrong side of the country for me. I have read about the Campbell school. It's on my wish list, but alas, I am beginning a new career and time off is years away! I still have 2 years of school (read 'poverty'!) to go.