Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

wood ID?

Posts

wood ID?

#1

wood ID?

Ruth Harding

>Hello, This is the first turning I have posted ..... I don't need critiques because I do it myself constantly.

This bowl is made from a tree from Moreno Valley, CA. It is very soft to turn and the slightest touch puts a dent in it. The bowl is approximately 14x3; the lathe is a stubby 750.

thanks for your time.

r


img

Re: wood ID?

#2

Re: wood ID?

gtwwilkins

>Ruth,

I turned a bowl that looks almost identical in grain and colour to yours , it was weeping willow that I salvaged and milled, it was air dried when I turned it and very soft but over the last 3 years the colour has turned golden red and the wood has hardened considerably.

I am in southern B.C but I think willow is prevalent on the left coast.

Trevor

Re: wood ID?

#3

Re: wood ID?

Ruth Harding

>Thanks Trevor....I don't think it's a willow. It was a very tall tree, over 30' and it had a bark that looked like a fir tree but only in looks. The texture and feel is completely different. I can't remember the leaves. For some reason I always thought it might have been from the eucalyptus family. Don't know why. It had very few branches and most of the leaves were at the top.....hummm, now I think of it, I think the upper branches may have hung like a willow but with a short length.

where in S. BC are you Trevor? I'm on Bowen Island.

Re: wood ID?

#4

Re: wood ID?

Keith Newton

>Looks and sounds like it could be Alder to me.

Re: wood ID?

#5

From the Picture

Ruth Niles

>If you lived in PA, that would be cherry. It's identical but that's just going by the picture and, I believe, you put a finish on it.

The similarities are there.


img

Re: wood ID?

#6

Re: From the Picture

Carole Valentine

>That was my thought when I first saw it. Hard to tell with no bark and a finish applied.

Re: wood ID?

#7

Re: wood ID?

Craig Daymon

>My understanding is that most of the eucalyptus trees are quite hard.

Maybe Camphor? Did it have a distinct smell? Both Camphor and Eucalyptus would have had very distinctive smells.

-Craig

Re: wood ID?

#8

Ellis Walentine

My guess is...

Ellis Walentine

>...madrone. The color and geographic location are similars. Typically madrone is a bit harder than you suggest, but I've worked with specimens that are easily bruised.

Ellis

http://www.nwfinewoodworking.com/wood_types/madrone.htm

Re: wood ID?

#9

Ruth and Carole...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>are you just looking at the pictures again? LOL

Re: wood ID?

#10

Re: Ruth and Carole...

Carole Valentine

>Huh? I don't think I missed anything. What did we miss this time?

Re: wood ID?

#11

Re: wood ID?

robo hippy

>It could be alder, which is quite soft. It is much lighter when first turned, then gets red as it drys. However, the bark is smooth and greyish. They can grow like Christmas trees if out in the open unless trimmed, but in groves will be more tall with most branches at the top. I doubt that it is madrone which tends to be more pinkish, and warps like crazy. Also it is very hard when dry, but a delight to turn when wet. Madrone has big waxy leaves, similar to laurel, and they are not deciduous. The bark is rusty colored, and thin but coarse, and where it peels off, it is kind of an olive green color. Looks like firewood to me.

robo hippy

Re: wood ID?

#12

Chinaberry?

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Ruth,

You gave me some chinaberry several years ago when I met you in Southern California. The bark sounds like chinaberry and the soft wood also. The bowl looks like the pieces I made for the wood. Is it open pored?

Dave Smith

Alder has smooth bark in Longview, WA.

Re: wood ID?

#13

Don't they have Cherry in CA?

Ruth Niles

>

Re: wood ID?

#14

Re: Ruth and Carole...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I never have found Cherry to be so soft.:-)

Re: wood ID?

#15

Re: Don't they have Cherry in CA?

Ruth Harding

>Thanks everybody. I will have to get a wood book because it's none of the wood mentioned. The finish is more to help sanding - Mahoney's walnut oil.

I have cut down a wealth of alder and this is like alder in weight and turning, but unless there is a completely different looking alder tree in CA it's not alder. Also turned lots of cherry, this isn't like cherry in any way, I've turned a lot of madrone which is significantly different in texture, weight, turning.

Thanks so much for the ideas. when I discover what it is I will let you know.

Have a great Sunday.

Re: wood ID?

#16

Re: Don't they have Cherry in CA?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Ruth,

Looks like cherry to me, but mostly since cherry is very common locally. Knowing the area the wood came from might get a better guess.

But while you can get numerous guesses, it is almost impossible to distinguish between species based on a photograph of a finished piece except in those cases where the wood has some obvious distinguishing features. Having the bark helps a little, but bark is often widely variable - there have been threads here with multiple wrong guesses based on good pictures of chunks of wood with bark. Even having the leaves often doesn't assure IDs since many species are similar. Having flowers and fruit along with the leaves gives you a far better shot!

If you really want to learn to distinguish woods from just the wood itself, R. Bruce Hodley wrote an outstanding book called "Identifying Wood". He shows how to shave a small sample of wood with a razor blade and look at the pores, rays, tyloses and other features with a low power magnifier lens. I use a low power binocular microscope but an inexpensive 10x hobbiest lens works fine. Hoadley provides photos for a large number of common woods for comparison. You can also keep samples of known woods you come across for future reference.

I use this book so much the cover fell off. Many times people have given or sold wood to me that turned out to be not what they thought it was.

JKJ

Re: wood ID?

#17

Re: wood ID?

gtwwilkins

>Ruth,

I used to live in Grand Forks, that's where I got the willow but I recently moved to Powell River (too cold in G.F).

Also recommend Hoadley I have been using it for years, it used to possible to send a sample of wood to the U.S Forestry Service Lab for ID however I don't know if that service is still available.

Just went past Bowen on the ferry last week, it's one of the few islands I have never visited.

Trevor

Re: wood ID?

#18

Re: wood ID?

Ruth Harding

>Thanks for the reference Trevor. I am going on an ebay site to have a look.

Bowen is wonderful.....you will have to put it on your list. Powell River is too remote for me!

thanks again.

Re: wood ID?

#19

Re: Don't they have Cherry in CA?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Ruth, any cherry that grows in Ca is in an orchard or somones's backyard.

Wally

Re: wood ID?

#20

Re: Don't they have Cherry in CA?

Ruth Harding

>Thanks Wally. I know this isn't cherry. I am wondering if it might be chinaberry as Dave Smith suggested. I don't remember the piece I gave him. Sombody mentioned camphour, but I have turned that as well and this isn't it.

The shame is that neither the owner or the tree faller knew what it was either.

My next step is a book.

Re: wood ID?

#21

Re: Don't they have Cherry in CA?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I've just finished rough turning several pieces of camphor and the very powerful smell tells you exactly what it is. I've had no experience with chinaberry.

Ruth, do I remember you saying that you live in the Gulf Islands in B.C.? I've done a lot of cruising there in my boat and I love it.

Wally

Re: wood ID?

#22

Re: Bowen Island

Ruth Harding

>I guess Bowen Island falls under the moniker of the Gulf Islands. It's a 20 minute ferry ride from Horseshoe Bay, very much a Vancouver commuter island as the trip to downtown is only about half an hour in rush hour.

Horseshoe Bay is the beginning point of the 'Sea to Sky Highway'...the road to Whister and the 2010 Olympic games.

Re: wood ID?

#23

Re: Don't they have Cherry in CA?

Keith Newton

>I have to wonder why you are resisting the alder suggestion. It looks like, is the right weight and density, and texture. The only thing left is smell. I have not use alder in a long time, but if my memory serves me, I would say that it is similar to dry cardboard.

On the other-hand, I am sure that it is not chinaberry, but could go with willow. Most of that which I have used smelled like mildewed wet cardboard, but maybe it had started to sower and decay.

Re: wood ID?

#24

Re: Don't they have Cherry in CA?

Ruth Harding

>Keith...why do you think I am resisting the Alder suggestion? What a curious thing to say. I am trying to ID the wood, not deny what it is.

I am not resisting the Alder suggestion I am saying most definitely it is not Alder.

After having a very large property I have taken down a large number of Alders, Fir, Hemlock, Cedars and Cherry. Where I live Alders are considered to be weeds. I know the wood I have is not Alder.

As I have mentioned, thanks to all for the ideas and I will be getting a wood ID book.