Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

water based finish

Posts

water based finish

#1

water based finish

joaz

>Now that the Maine winter is almost here, I have to plastic the windows in the studio and fire up the wood stove. Because of the closed atmosphere and for health saftey I've decided to give up the chemical finishs and try the water based.

Any reccommendation??

I really like the semi-gloss look.

Thanks all.

Re: water based finish

#2

Re: General Finishes High Performance.

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: water based finish

#3

Re: General Finishes High Performance.

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Jamie are you spraying that finish or using a brush? I've sprayed hydrocote resisthane and had pretty good results. I just wonder how the two products compare.

Re: water based finish

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re-think the rationale......

Jesper, Denmark

>If your decision to used water reducible finishes in plase of the hydrocarbon solvent reduced finishes is your own long term health, maybe you should reconsider.

The main hazards with solvents in the "oil based" finishes are the flammability, odor and long term exposure. By long term exposure, I mean that your are working with the materials and use the finishes every day, not that the paint is in your haouse after painting.

These hazards are well know and can be dealt with by proper ventilation - AND WHEN THE PAINT IS FULLY CURED, THEY HAVE GONE. There is nothing but a film of paint resin left.

There is really no real "water based" finish other than stuff like whitewash. The water base paints should be called water reducible, as they can be thinned with water. The finished paint resin film is really not much different from the oil based paints, and there is a co-solvent in the mixture than allows the water to mix with the hydrocarbon paint resin. The VOC content is a little less than the oil base, but it is there.

Here is where you should be concenrned: The co-solvents used are things like Propylene Glycol Monomethyl Ether Acetate, PGMEA, which caused birth defects in women working with this in the semiconductor industry some years ago. This and many similar chemicals are in the water reducuble paints. They have rather high boiling points, and will therefore evaporate into your home over longer period of time. The long term effects of these are not so well known, so you should ask yourself:

"Do I deal with the short term known effects of hydrocarbon solvents in paint or do I prefer the unknowns of the water reducible stuff?" Please read the contents in the can. If there are things with long chemical names you do not understand, get the information you need from MSDS sheets or Google and then decide.

Here is the thing that really ticks me off: The use of the term "Waterbased". it is at best a misnomer and at worst a near criminal attempt at falsely labelling product to make the consumer think it 100% safe.

I'll get off the soapbox now......

Re: water based finish

#5

Re: water based finish

john lucas

>I use Minwax wipe on Poly during the winter when I can't spray lacquer.

Re: water based finish

#6

Jesper, Denmark

More info.......

Jesper, Denmark

>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellosolve.

Start here and then click on the individual compounds to investigate the various hazards.

Re: water based finish

#7

Re: water based finish

eaglesc

>I use a Kerosene or propane heater in my small shop all winter.

I have no qualms about spraying as I use an air brush for my Deft lacquer when I Use it.

My DC is vented out doors and is behind the lathe.

Fumes from spraying are exhausted outside.

The DC pulls in fresh air for the flame without causing it to super heat,

For a water based lacquer I reccomend Unaxol from Mobey Dick supplies.

Re: water based finish

#8

Thanks So Much

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I had no idea that there was a problem with the "water based" finishes. I am going to read further.

Re: water based finish

#9

Re: I just wipe it on with with a piece of carpet

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: water based finish

#10

Yup...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I know someone that has to use a respirator when painting with latex interior house paint. Otherwise she is worshiping the porcelain goddess within 30 minutes.

Re: water based finish

#11

Re: water based finish

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Joaz

Consider setting up a small paint booth. Does not have to be fancy just a small closed area with an exhaust fan. Put the fan behind where you spray and exhaust either into the attic or outside. In the little shop I had in Colorado all I had was a bench in front of a window with a window fan. I use a lazy susan to set the work on and turn it as I spray.

Bill

Re: water based finish

#12

Re: John, I spray lacquer year-around.

Allen Neighbors

>When the humidity gets high enough to cause blush, I add reducer. If it's too cold, I build a fire in my shop stove, and fan a little heat into my spray booth by turning on the exhaust fan. This raises the temp enough that the reducer will do it's job.

I know they say not to, but I use thinned (about 15%) pre-catalyzed lacquer. I put a 35mm film canister full (1/4" from the top) of reducer to each quart of lacquer, which thins it just a tiny bit more.

Re: water based finish

#13

Re: Bill, that's what I do...

Allen Neighbors

>I have a small 8x8 room with a shrouded, motor-enclosed, fan mounted in a louvered opening to the alley outside. I set my pieces on a stand-mounted lazy susan to spray them. I never have to breath the fumes when I spray lacquer.

Re: water based finish

#14

Re: water based finish

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I've recently been trying Minwax spray Polycrylic Semi-gloss when I want a clear finish. So far, the results have been promising.

keithz

Re: water based finish

#15

MSDS

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>The MSDS sheets for the General Finishes Products and the Hydrocote products don't seem to agree with your statement. I am by no means an expert on reading these sheets. If I am reading them right the Water Born Finishes are less dangerous than the oil based finishes. I know a lot of improvements have been made in the last few years in water based finishes. I like the idea of water based, but I am a little confused on the health factors. I have asthma and need to be extra careful in what I am breathing. Can anyone shed some light on this? I'll try to contact Tim Jewel from Homestead Finishes and see what his take on the matter is.

Re: water based finish

#16

Jesper, Denmark

The point is......

Jesper, Denmark

>Not to make any decision based on the current fad, but to make everybody aware that there is no free lunch.

" Water Based" do not jusy contain water. Thay also contain some solvents we do not have a long experience with.

I do not know if the Glycol materials are OK in the long run, but How can I make sure I am around in the the long run to find out?

Re: water based finish

#17

Re: John, I spray lacquer year-around.

john lucas

>Allen I don't spray inside, don't have the space so my spray booth gets dark at night and light by day. Cold in the winter and hot and humid in the summer. It's huge with lot's of open space but gets a little damp when it rains.

Re: water based finish

#18

Re: John, I spray lacquer year-around.

Allen Neighbors

>I understand now, John. You made it plain, in a poetic sort of way. :)