Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

A humble request from the cockpit

Posts

A humble request from the cockpit

#1

Ellis Walentine

A humble request from the cockpit

Ellis Walentine

>Folks, this is a place for turners to share opinions, theories, facts, news, techniques, stories, successes, failures and all manner of personal interaction. It has really become a diverse community, and with diversity comes individuality. That's okay until it becomes a source of personal conflict that spills onto the forum, as some recent threads have begun to do.

I would like to point out, as Russ has, that there are certain topics that will not be settled in a message thread, plagiarism prominently among them. People get married to their views and sometimes can't agree to simply disagree. When everyone has to have the last word on something, it turns into a mele�, and there's no room for that here.

I respectfully request that everyone refrain from personal attacks and from endless bickering. Those are two of the mostly unspoken rules of order around here that are sometimes forgotten in the midst of heated debate. If there is a problem, you are welcome to bring it to the attention of the moderators and/or directly to me. Otherwise, don't allow the civility and value of this forum to be distracted by futile arguments and personal confrontations.

I am talking to several folks privately and I think we can get things resolved in good order. Thanks for your patience and your cooperation.

Best,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#2

Martin Harris

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

Martin Harris

>Thanks you. As a new member and recently retired after many years in both academia and government, I was beginning to think I had gone back to work!

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#3

AMEN

robert davis

>RUDY OSOLNIK WOULD SPIN IN HIS GRAVE

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#4

Absolutely

Norm Smith

>

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#5

Dick Hines

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

Dick Hines

>Good call Ellis.

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#6

Re: Yep, good call.

Allen Neighbors

>You would make a good pilot... the flying kind.

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#7

Re: Robert- how did Rude ....

Jamie Donaldson

>... get mixed up in this. He loved a good fight, and would be right in the middle of it!!!

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#8

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

Barry Elder

>Thank you, Ellis!

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#9

Ric Taylor

Thanks, Ellis!

Ric Taylor

>

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#10

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

eliot d

>Elllis, Please allow me ask a question: let's say someone posts a PIC of something they have turned and my reaction is that it is a blatant knockoff of a well-known turner. Are you saying that it is not appropriate in this forum for me to comment on my reaction?

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#11

Ellis Walentine

Opinions, facts and civil discussions

Ellis Walentine

>All topics are fair game for discussion here, but everyone has to respect everyone else's right to their own opinions. That is the simple principle that has guided discussions on our messageboards since day one. Some hot-button issues (plagiarism, art v. craft, etc.) are more polarizing than others, so you need to be careful what you say. It is possible to state any opinion in non-threatening terms, but not everyone has the same verbal abilities, so out of frustration at not being able to win their point (which they can't win in any case), some people tend to raise their voice and/or become insulting or offensive to others. That is disrespectful and provocative behavior and has no place here.

When someone is being loud or abusive, you need to keep a cool head and calmly try to bring the discussion back to a rational level, not escalate the dispute by raising your own voice or flaming (making personal attacks on) the other person. As soon as anger enters the picture, the unspoken rules of civility go out the window, and we've all seen what that can lead to.

I hope that answers your question. Let me know if you need further clarification. The vitality and well-being of this forum relies on respect.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#12

Re: Opinions, facts and civil discussions

Bill Crommett

>Ellis: Thank you for the call, but it is my opinion that most turners on this forum have a good enough sense of humor to transcend most of the chaff and small sparks.

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#13

Ellis Walentine

Right, my sermons...

Ellis Walentine

>...are for the others. :-)

Onward,

Ellis

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#14

Re: Right, my sermons...

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>Sermons are always for "others," Ellis. LOL

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#15

Re: Right, my sermons...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Sermons are always for "others," Ellis. LOL

Ack, I didn't know that. Seems like every Sunday morning the preacher is talking directly to me!

JKJ

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#16

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I have had a computer on the fritz at home, and busy at work, and so have observed many of the contentious discussions after the fact.

I would like to point something out - every one of us has an email address on their posting. As such, I would suggest that as a matter of politeness, if you really want to confront someone about a post - EMAIL HIM/HER.

It is a little bit like pulling someone aside in private and discussing an issue, versus standing in a room full of people, pointing a finger and loudly confronting them.

I thank some members of this forum and the former Badger Pond Forum all the time for the kind private emails they sent me when I was first turning - very softly telling me some of my work was real crap.

Mark

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#17

Re: Right, my sermons...

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>You ARE the 'other,' John. We don't preach'em to ourselves! But then again, maybe we should. LOL

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

#18

Re: A humble request from the cockpit

eliot d

>Very smart way to handle such issues.