Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

A lesson learned and a point well missed

Posts

A lesson learned and a point well missed

#1

A lesson learned and a point well missed

russ Fairfield

>The 3-Evils of the Internet forums are - Inspiration, plagiarism (copying others), and whether what we do is art or craft. These are always circular arguments that end with hurt feelings, anger, people leaving the forum, and in the worst case people have been locked out of the forum.

As usual, the recent discussion of inspiration and copying occupied a lot of space and time over two or three days, but completely missed the point.

The point being that real artists DO NOT copy another artists because they DO NOT use another's art for their inspiration. The common trait of all of those we look up to as the true woodturning artists get their inspiration from the greater world outside of woodturning. The artist has the imagination to be inspired by their own dreams, nature, animals, plants, rocks, math symbols, microscope images, human activities, ancient art forms, other media, or something as simple and everyday as a road sign.

What they DO NOT do is copy each other, and neither should we.

The lesson learned is - turn wood, have fun, and don't worry about it. People looking at your work will tell you if it looks like you are copying someone else, and congratulate you on your originality if it doesn't.

There is a second lesson. A common argument is that the artist should expect his work to be copied when you have paid for a class or demonstration. If that is why you are in the audience, you are there for the wrong reasons. You should be there to learn a new technique or skill that you can use to make anything. You should not be there to learn how to make a specific something.

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#2

Steven Antonucci

Another point well missed

steve antonucci

>is that there is no right or wrong in the argument- only people's opinions and views. Whether you agree or disagree, you should be able to express your opinion without being attacked by an angry mob.

I know the internet gives a lot of people more voice than they would have in person, and I wonder how these conversations would play out if we were all sitting in the same room togther? My guess is they'd be very, very different.

Steve

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#3

It ain't what you say, it's how you say it.

russ Fairfield

>

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#4

Steven Antonucci

That's the problem

steve antonucci

>Nobody says anything on the internet. It's all typeface, which lacks tone, inflection, and the subtle nuances of face to face communication. It strips us of our human character, and makes the reader form his or her own view of what we are like without anything to base the judgement on.

To me, they're just words. I don't color them any way but what's there. If you didn't explicitly say something, I won't assume you did. If I ask you what you meant, it's because I'm truly interested. Nothing else.

Steve

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#5

If it where only true

Ron in Drums PA

>Do some research on the art movement called "Cubism" or "Pointillism". A person can easily feel that major artists had copied each over. In fact, that is how art movements get started.

This also holds true in the music world

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#6

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

eliot d

>Russ, As usual, you said it perfectly. I once asked my brother, an 83 year old art critic with 12 book in print, what should I turn to become a well-know wood turner. He didn't miss a beat and answered, "That's the wrong question."

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#7

a world without artists

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>....real artists DO NOT copy another artists

>because they DO NOT use another's art for their inspiration.

I think the first part of the statment is true but question the second. Inspiration comes from everywhere, even other art. Someone sensitive to being wrongly inspired might do well to live in isolation!

Pablo Picasso on inspiration, includes "a passing shape" but could have included "a wood turning":

"The artist is a receptacle for emotions that come from all over the place: from the sky, from the earth, from a scrap of paper, from a passing shape, from a spider's web." from "Conversation avec Picasso", in Cahiers d'Art, volume 10, number 10.

All the artists I know have looked at the works of others. Some actually enjoy this and look on purpose. It is impossible to look at anything, including another's work, without being influenced in some way. We all know this, the disagreement among pundits and critics being in the intent, of course, and the degree. Is it OK to be 2% inspired but not 98%? Who sets the cutoff point?

But if the end result is a "somewhat" similar work, is there a difference between being deliberately inspired from a work and being inspired "accidentally" by a work experienced in the past, perhaps due to the passing of time or poor memory?

A composer friend said her biggest fear was accidentally reproducing even a portion of some tune she heard elsewhere. She has several people review her work to try to catch these since by the time the work is complete, she cannot rely on her own mind to separate the current work from past memory.

JKJ

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#8

True intelligence includes ...

Ed Moore

>knowing when NOT to say something.

Having the last word is an over-valued phenomenon in petty arguments.

Ed

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#9

Re: True intelligence includes ...

Robert W - aka nailshooter

>Full point to Ed. This is nothing other than another thread on the same old topic, how one feels as a mistunderstood pariah.

Robert

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

keith tompkins

>Completely agree Russ! True art must come from within. I began to post something about copying when this thread started, but thought better of it and deleted it. You pretty much summed up what I was going to say.

Years ago, I asked my guitar teacher for the chords to a popular song.....Learn to play your instrument...you'll be able to play ANY song. Not so different.

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#11

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

eaglesc

>I have been accused of being an artist and apologise to anyone that IS artist.I have never claimed to be an artist,I don't own a beret and my "studio" has no natural light and was built to hold my riding lawn mower.

12x16, the lawn mower is outside.

Inpiration?

I have never been inspired, NEVER!

Curious yes but not inspired.

Since I have never been inspired I guess it is safe to say that I am not an artist.

Just curious and not afraid to fail.

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#12

An interesting quote along that line.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I've seen the following idea in several slightly different forms and attributed to both the Spanish artist Pablo Picasso and the Russian composer Igor Stravinsky. This particular wording was attributed to Picasso:

"Good artists copy, great artists steal."

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#13

I beg to differ, eagle

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>If I remember correctly, you do a lot of segmented pens. Well, where do your designs come from? Why do they look like they do? By answering those questions, you may discover that there is indeed a source of inspiration for your work, even though you don't recognize it.

keithz

Re: A lesson learned and a point well missed

#14

Re: I beg to differ, eagle

eaglesc

>"If I remember correctly, you do a lot of segmented pens. Well, where do your designs come from? Why do they look like they do?"

If you closely at the segments and inlays you will see I try not to "copy" anything unless a picture of a cross done entirely in wood that I asked my wife to draw from her head.

She can draw, I can't.I told her what I wanted and asked her to "tweak" it.

I have seen inlays done in woodwork,but not may done in pens.

I am always curious to try ideas I have but have not seen others do.

A wave becomes and X wave

an X-wave winds up in"woven wood"


img