Comparison ...
Tim GC
>Help please,
Wolverine grinding jig Vs Penn State grinding jig.
Cheap rip off clone? Quality item made under licence? Comparable quality with slight modifications?
Which is it???
TIA
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Comparison ...
Tim GC
>Help please,
Wolverine grinding jig Vs Penn State grinding jig.
Cheap rip off clone? Quality item made under licence? Comparable quality with slight modifications?
Which is it???
TIA
Re: Comparison ...
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>In general, you get what you pay for.
Re: Comparison ...
Dick Coers
>"Quality piece made under license", Tim you crack me up!!!!!!!!!!Yup, that's the way most business goes these days. Hardly anyone reverse engineers a good product overseas. Yikes, better watch the sarcasm. I've never seen the Penn State in person. I made my first one from wood and thought I could make it a lot closer tolerance than the Wolverine. Found out that the grit from the wheel vibrates into the clearance real tight like and almost locked my sliding wood bar in the base. I bought the Wolverine and love it.
Re: Comparison ...
john lucas
>Dick I built my first one out of metal. it worked OK but had little annoyances. I finally bought the Oneway. Like all their stuff, it works like it's supposed to.
I would assume the Penn state is a chinese knockoff. That doesn't mean that it's junk and some knockoffs are worth the money. I have my doubts that it's as good as the Oneway.
Re: Comparison ...
Tim GC
>Thank you all for your comments. Cost was not my first consideration as I am only too aware of 'get what you pay for' (which in 99.9% of the time is correct). Been there done that!!
Just wondered if the Penn State jig was the 0.1%
The Wolverine is on its way ...
Re: Comparison ...
Jerry Whitaker
>You got that right....I bought a 1/2 in. bowl gouge from Penn State "Benjamin's Best" and it is the worst thing I have ever bought. Right out of the package the handle was cracked from the ferrule for about 3 inches. The Chinese HSS is not as good as U.S. carbon steel. $17.95 taught me a good lesson. I have emailed them about it and I suspect that they will offer to let me send it back but with paying the return postage and all the hassle of re-packaging and going to the Post Office or UPS, I am not sure it is worth it. Might just keep it as a reminder.
Re: Comparison ...
Dennis Yoder
>Bought the Penn State, modified and modified and modified still wouldn't work, bought the Woverine, nuff said!!!!
Re: Comparison ...
eliot d
>Get the Wolverine. But you know, sometimes things do surprise you: even though I have way too may turning tools, I just couldn't resist buying still another cheap (something like $12) set of spindle turning tools from HF. Would you believe I use them all the time for small stuff? They work beautifully for me. I love to sharpen them on my JoolTool and hone them on a hard felt wheel.