Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

competition at a guild retail store

Posts

competition at a guild retail store

#1

competition at a guild retail store

Dick Coers

>I'm trying to get my head around a situation at our Art Guild retail store. Maybe I'm too sensitive about this. Maybe because it is a guild store, it's not like a real gallery. I would like to see what some of you think.

I've had pens, ornaments, square boxes, platters, and bowls at the Art Guild store for several years now. Another member of our AAW club recently joins the guild and now has bowls and turned boxes on the shelves.

Do you think this is a breach of courtesy, or just healthy competition? It's kinda got my shorts in a bunch, but to be honest, I have never sold a single bowl there. Lots of pens and a fair number of ornaments. It seems that in this town, I have competition from Pier 1 on my bowls anyway. Just would like to see what some others think or have you had this happen to you?

Re: competition at a guild retail store

#2

Steven Antonucci

Do you have a guarantee of exclusivity?

steve antonucci

>I'm guessing not, so I suspect that it's within reason to think that another turner could exhibit their work there as well. It sounds like the other person has different types of wares, so I guess it has offset some of the pain.

I'm guessing the Guild Store's primary objective is to sell the items displayed, and that they get a commission. Anything that they can do to make someone take out their wallet seems like a good business decision.

Steve

Re: competition at a guild retail store

#3

Re: competition at a guild retail store

Norm Smith

>Hi Dick,

I have my stuff in three Galleries and in each there is at least two other turners . I dont do bowls anylonger because they dont sell. I try to stick to enhansed turnings with stone inlay and natchural edge stuff. My turnings arent cheap but I outsell the others. If you produce unique quality products , it will sell.

Dont worry or be put off by the competition, its healthy.

Norm

Re: competition at a guild retail store

#4

At a guild retail store there are ...

Ed Moore

>different parameters from those at a regular store. I see such a place where each member is entitled to have some of what they do on display. If you all turn pens, then there will be lots of pens available. A guild store should promote the work of all its members. If the work is to be juried, then problems will arise. This was handled in one club by allowing each member to have at least one item in the club show. Other items could be juried in up to five items. No heartburn occurred that I know of relative to the process. The juror was not a club member.

Actually, some heartburn did occur for a different reason. A collector came through and remarked that one bowl looked like it came from K-Mart. The collector was absolutely correct, but the person who made it was NOT a happy camper.

My suggestion is to find a shop where your work fits in. Then, if you put things on consignment and another person comes along with the same items you have a legitimate beef with the store owner/manager.

Ed

Re: competition at a guild retail store

#5

Dick Hines

Re: At a guild retail store there are ...

Dick Hines

>We have a art show in my area and there was another turner judged in and I was one the people who helped get him in. He turns a lot of the same things I do, bowls hollow forms and the like. Having him in the show makes me a better turner. I know that I have to go the extra step to have a better product.

Oh by they way he and I are good friends and in the same turning club.

Re: competition at a guild retail store

#6

Re: competition at a guild retail store

eliot d

>The gallery I sell at has several other turners in there. In fact they were there first.At one point , this particular gallery had something like 30 wood turners. Now there are , perhaps half a dozen. Several of us are in several turning clubs together, and I know them well, There is not the slightest feeling of competition. We each respect each others' work. Actually, it's good that the gallery has a fair amount of turned stuff; it registers in buyers' minds that that 's the place to go to buy turned wood. I love to go in there to see the other work and am usually inspired by what I see. I wouldn't worry about other turners in the gallery you're in.

Re: competition at a guild retail store

#7

Re: competition at a guild retail store

Jim Swank

>It's a normal course of events. If the store won't support both of you, one will drop out. If it will, you can learn something each watching the other. I've never set out to "copy" somebody else's work - or worried whether something I did might be perceived as too close either. On a few occasions, somebody has pointed out that someone else was doing work similar to mine. My reaction has always been a shrug.

Re: competition at a guild retail store

#8

Ric Taylor

Re: competition at a guild retail store

Ric Taylor

>Dick,

Does your guild display the works of more than one oil painter, or more than one water-color artist? They probably do.

Each artist develops his or her own style, so the work of one oil painter is different than the work of another oil painter. The same is true of woodturners. Often you can guess who the turner is by looking at the turning on the table.

A customer may be attracted to the work or style of one turner, and not the style of another turner. No one will purchase your work just because you are the only turner in the gallery. They only purchase if they are truly attracted to your piece. Some customers will like your work, while other customers will like the work of another turner. You won't lose sales because there is another turner in the gallery. On the contrary, if there are several turners in the gallery, then those customers who like wood art will be more likely to go there.

Ric

Re: competition at a guild retail store

#9

Re: competition at a guild retail store

Dick Coers

>Thanks for the help guys. I suspect some of my anxiety comes from the fact that woodturning is a REALLY small piece of the pie at the Art Guild Store. I was thinking that now I would have 1/2 of that really small piece, argh! How small, I've made $57 in the past 7 months. I didn't mention that I had a call on my voice mail from the gallery manager that we haven't connected on yet. I stopped by and he wasn't in, but all my bowls, vessels, and a box were off the shelf and the new guys work was in. Guess I'll find out what is going on soon, but I guess this is really a not so subtle hint. Maybe I should switch to making jewelry, those are the artisans that do most of the sales. I made the observation again this year at the Guild Art Fair. Woodturner's booth; zero or 1 person looking, jewelry maker's booth; 6 women looking. The only place that did better than the jewelry was the pizza guy or the cinnamon bun guy. Sometimes I hate living in the Midwest! LOL Thanks for listening.