Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

A bigger man knows when he messed up...

Posts

A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#1

Steven Antonucci

A bigger man knows when he messed up...

steve antonucci

>I sent an apology to Ellis to let him know that I was sorry for being one of the folks that got involved in a little too heated debate. I'm not looking to make WC anything more than what it is, I have no agenda, but I am confused by what happened with Wally's post.

I've admired Wally's work for years. Every time I try to make a beaded vessel, it ends up being thinner because I cut the beads off. He's obviously a very talented turner.

I started a thread about what I thought could be copied and what I thought was public domain. I made my position very clear- I do NOT think that techniques like burning, coloring,etc are copyrights. I then very clearly said that as an extension of that position, that Wally's piece was not a copy of Molly's work. I'm unsure how, but this was twisted into me accusing Wally of copying Molly's work. Fur flew after that, which I could see if I had said it.

But I didn't.

I've been on trial for something I never said, which seems to be a recurring theme here. The person who actually accused Wally of copying hasn't heard a single bad word. How's that for irony?

Steve

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#2

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

jay in tx

>Steve,

Good point! As to the vessel that Wally attributed this discussion to; Jim Rinde was the "culprit" (no negative conotations here Jim, I promise) that made the statement below based on Wally's displayed work on the other site.

"When I saw the thumbnail picture of this HF I said the myself that Molly had posted another piece. You sure have got her style down pat. Nice HF."

Then Jim was lightly and properly chastised by Wally in the phrase below explicitly stating that it wasn't a 'Molly' piece, and inferring that all people should really consider if anything is really attributable to another 'artist', or if its a technique that has become synonymous with someone and they and/or you have placed possesion of that with them. (Okay so I'm inferring that).

"Thanks Jim. This piece is NOT a copy of any of Molly's work."

Then Jim, feeling a bit sheepish I'm sure, responded with, "Wally; I did not intent to imply you copied any of Molly work, but simply that I associate this look to Molly especially when seen as a thumbnail photo. I just have to adjust my thinking to when I see this style to I say to Myself the Molly or Wally has just posted another wonderful piece."

Well, matter resolved; well not really since it was brought up as an example over a year later...

Ahhh I'm sure you all really want to here my unbiased opinion on this topic. (Just as you're giving me the same look my wife does when I give my opinion instead of just blankly staring and nodding)

Does Molly have the market cornered on pyrography (even in the sub-field of woodturning), Nope (but she does a great job with it!) Does Keith Thompkins have the trademark on using a lathe to produce a cube, or using a carved linen fold as part of wooden object (sorry to drag you into this, but you know you love the attention), nope! (But he does both exceptionally well!) Does J. Paul Fennel have sole rights to be the only person allowable to make a pierced baseball bat for profit (okay, so I don't know the answer to that one; but I'd be more than happy to initiate that research and litiguous effort with someone else bankrolling the entire venture)

So, unless its just plain ole stealin' like that one guy tried to do with Mark Kauder's photos a little while back, I just try to get along by gettin' along (so to speak).

Y'all have a wonderful day! It's finally autumn here in Texas and I'm stuck inside trying to make a buck... (oh, and if I spelled something incorrectly, or used poor gramatics; please feel free to chastise me at irishsob@charter.net. Put "woodcentral" in the subject line or it might get thrown out with the junk mail.

Now really, y'all have a great day! I mean it! No, that's not an order... oh, phooey, just have a good day.

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#3

Steven Antonucci

Thanks- I agree 100%

steve antonucci

>and tried to make the exact point, but ended up at another destination.

Think happy thoughts...

Steve

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#4

Did you really mess up?

Robert W - aka nailshooter

>I don't know. I think this is sore subject with many as it touches on a lot of other issues in the periphery of turning. Namely, are good turners artists with work in a rarified place, or are they just good turners? Is their work proprietary and therefore protected, or should it be viewed in the spirit of which many woodturners started, just to have fun?

Since so many turners are past the 65 yr. old mark, it is the silliest thought imaginable to them that they cannot make piece or post a picture somewhere without giving proper attribution for it, send money to the original artist for his inspiration, or only make a "one off" that stays in your their house and cannot leave. They are completely confident that folks know when they post a picture that everyone knows the difference between Ray Allen and Frank Walachek. I know some pretty salty guys that are quite talented as turners that think the whole concept of being a protected artist for turning "wood art" is silly.

They readily embraced my thinking on this: Excepting the lost wood pieces and Mike Schwing's bugs and brains, what original forms do we see in woodturning? I defy anyone to show a shape or design that is turned on the lathe that hasn't come off a potter's wheel. Aren't some of the shape we see the classics of Navajo pottery (jeez... even down to the rawhide laces,inlays, and in some cases with stoppers) with the shapes and burned horse heards on the side? Does anyone pay to the Indian nations for stealing their designs? Is Wally's piece so original (easy now... I didn't say it wasn't beautiful) when compared to ancient Japanese pottery shapes and decorations? Isn't one of the turners shapes that are being rallyed around here simply an Egyptian style vase without the arms or the top, kind of like a skinny ginger jar? If they go to the local library and check out a book on classic pottery through the centuries and I think many will be quite surprised.

I live near Mexico, and we have a large community of pottery artists and have had them since I was a kiddo when moving here in the mid sixties. For these guys, the are carrying on a centuries old cultural tradition. >>Rest assured<<, they have made every shape and profile you have seen come from the lathe, including those that are pierced, painted, shaded, burned, carved (the three foot tall carved fire vase was popular by the front door fill with reeds for years), dyed, lidded, void-filled, embellished, aged, sealed, unsealed, decorated with metals, etc. Some even practice laying on hot glass, and the ancient art of raku (looks a little like airbrushing sometimes).

I personally subscribe to the Sam Maloof (are any turners in the Smithsonian >permanent< collection yet?) style of thinking. You spent many thousands to learn how to make his famous rockers. Now go make them! How many knockoffs and look alikes are there out there? Plenty! He even give you templates! And in his book he gives you his favorite formula for a renewable wood finish.

He says he is flattered by the fact that so many people like his designs, and that so many copy them. It is easily the most copied custom built rocker in the US today. BUT he is entirely confident that the discerning afficianado or purchaser know the difference between a signed Maloof and a non Maloof piece. By the way, at $40,000 and up for his chairs and has a 3 -4 year waiting list, he still chuckles at the fact some consider him an "artist".

This has been bandied about in our club, and certainly beat to pieces on the newsgroup I frequent. Imagine this subject in an unmoderated forum. Ouch! Talk about hurt feelings!

As always, just my 0.02.

Robert

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#5

John Jordan...

jay in tx

>has several pieces in the Smithsonian American Art Museum.

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#6

Re: John Jordan...

john lucas

>I was going to say that there are several turners in the smithsonian collection. I saw some of the work when I was there 3 or 4 years ago. I just don't remember who all it was.

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#7

Re: Did you really mess up?

eliot d

>Yes, yes. But did you see my post about the Thomas Moser saw suit? The judge said you can copy his designs all you want , but you can't set up shop and sell them. (And I don't think the ancients did Art Liestman puzzle vessels.)

Look, there aren't going to be many law suits. The whole point is that one should try to go in his own direction.

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#8

Steven Antonucci

When my kids fight, I punish them both

steve antonucci

>it doesn't matter what started it or who started it, just that they were both dumb enough to get into a fight.

Master Lee (9th degree Tae Kwon Do Master, there are no 10's) is my son's TKD instructor and has the best advice to avoid losing a fight- don't get into one.

And for my involvement in creating tension, I have apologized to Ellis. That's what I'm sorry about, nothing else.

Steve

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#9

Al Stirt...

jay in tx

>is in there too.

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#10

I am truly moved.....

Rick Davenport

>....by your deep remorse.

Re: A bigger man knows when he messed up...

#11

Re: I am truly moved.....

Tim GC

>Oh s**t here we go again!! Give it a rest folks ... feathers have been ruffled, noses put out of joint, now stop acting like kids and use the energy for something constructive and of benefit to WC, like turning or burning some wood!!