Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Original Thought

Posts

Original Thought

#1

Keith Tompkins

Original Thought

keith tompkins

>Steve Antonucci's post brings up a very important topic that just won't go away...whether we like it or not. The heart of the issue lies in the concept of original thought or intellectual property rights. I'll give an example NOT related to woodturning:

I buy a photograph of a famous building, say the Empire State Building. The artist who took the picture did not own the building, nor buildings surrounding it, nor the weather conditions that existed at the time the shot was taken.

Since it is now my photograph, I decide to use it in my business's advertising...after all, I bought and paid for the image, it is mine to do with as I please. I am shocked when I discover I'm being sued by the photographer in question for a large sum of money for violating his rights under U.S. copyright law. Even though I own the image, I DO NOT own the rights to the image....the photographer does until he legally signs them over to me. Even though he sold me the photo, he can legally reproduce that same image as many times as he wishes, and profit from it. I cannot.

Now, I write a new song, and include it in my new album. The melody sounds strangely familiar, but hey, there are only eight notes in the major scale, and they are all public domain. And, the words are all mine! Should I be surprised when I am again sued for a large sum because my song has the same melody as an old Beatles tune?

In both cases, I have violated someone's rights to their own intellectual property. Copyright laws protect these rights, whether the medium is art, photograhy, music, or poetry. Whether we believe it is true or not. And, these rights pass on to the artist's heirs for a period of 70 years.

Some people believe there is nothing new under the sun...U.S. patent law says otherwise. Violate someone's rights under the patent laws, and you may find yourself in serious trouble. So, how does this relate to turning....

There are many books available that deal with original thought and intellectual property rights as they pertain to the arts. Anyone seriously considering entering any art field should read this material. After all, not all craft fields are as open and sharing as turning...we are not YET involved in the lawsuits that are common in other fields.

A personal example: I worked in a furniture shop that produced chairs for the commercial market. While in their employ, I invented several tools and processes that the company patented. Their production of chairs doubled, to over 300 chairs a day. When I received an offer I couldn't refuse, and ended my employment there, I was forced to sign papers agreeing not to violate the company's patent rights, nor share their "trade secrets". I could not legally use MY OWN ideas.

I am not saying there is anything wrong with Keith's box or Steve's hollow form, but the vast majority of craft objects show influence of previous art. When I first spotted Steve's piece in question from a distance, the form and spalted wood was an easily recogniseable combination....most turners would easily recognize the style as similar to Ellsworth's. I would guess the turner who produced the piece studied with David. After speaking with Steve, I discovered he had indeed studied with him. I think the trick is to take what we learn, to take our influences, and approach our work from our own unique perspective. In the meantime, it doesn't hurt to recognize those who have helped or influenced us. If we can manage to do that, it may prevent us from suffering the same fate as other art forms.

I'm not taking a stand one way or the other, but we should be aware of the situation in other fields.

Re: Original Thought

#2

Re:The recent Dale Chihuly suits...

Jamie Donaldson

>... for infringment and derivitive works brought intellectual property rights in the arts to the attention of many other artists. We should always be mindful of the sources from which we learn, and attribute such influence when consideration is due. Any trial judge will tell you that ignorance of a law is not a valid defense for breaking one.

Re: Original Thought

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re:The recent Dale Chihuly suits...

keith tompkins

>Hey Jamie, BTW, I just watched the Portland critique DVD....congrats on having your piece critiqued!! I don't believe it was the first time either....was it Orlando as well? Well done!

Re: Original Thought

#4

The 70 year mess

Craig Daymon

>I think they relate the change in copyright laws to push out to 70 years as being attributed to Disney wanting copyright protection for Mickey. (They managed to lobby to get it changed just in time to keep Mickey locked away.) At the same time, Disney was releasing the fantasy film, "The League of Extaordinary Gentlemen". If the current copyright provisions had been in place all along, they wouldn't have been able to make that picture since it featured Tom Sawyer, Captain Nemo, Allen Quartermaine, Dr. Jeckle and the Invisible Man. All of these characters are, I believe, parts of fictional literature which would still be "protected" by a 70 year copyright.

Probably worse are the patent trolls. Companies collecting patents on many things that, due to prior art, should not even have patents and suing for massive dollar amounts. (Amazon's famous 1-click patent comes to mind, though I wouldn't classify Amazon as a patent troll.) Typically they are law firms set up for this specific purpose. Sort of a legalized extortion. And they get away with it because our patent office is so horrendously out of date/touch and under-manned.

-Craig

Re: Original Thought

#5

Steven Antonucci

I don't think that this applies here.

steve antonucci

>The law can not restrict something that requires so much of one's personal experience and development from being able to apply them to their art/craft.

There was a meesage on the main board about Auriou rasps going out of business because of labor issues. What is there to stop the folks from the factory from forming their own company and competing with Auriou- it's a "patentable" idea. The idea of copyright in woodturning doesn't make sense because there are so many varying processes to get to the end state that it would be hard to prove that someone "copied" your original art.

While it is well known that Ellsworth was a pioneer in the field of turning, I believe that he put his ideas in the public domain (by teaching, by selling his work, exhibiting...) His idea was to to hollow wood into well formed, but established shapes, to create wooden vessels. His methods were unique, but he chose to put it out there to expand a field for the better of the field. Might he have been granted on hollowing tools and methods? Maybe, but it would have remained his proprietary property and the field would have suffered.

Just as I give up rights to every picture I post on a "free website", I believe that we all contribute by repeating the classic forms and bettering the techniques. While I would never turn a rose and represent it as my idea (even though you told me how to do it), I wouldn't hesitate to represent it as my work. Among turners, I would feel obligated to mention your name since they might know you, but the common person probably won't. They'll just think it's a nice rose.

As far as where the lines are in the world of copying, I think if you have a doubt, then don't. I still don't view the piece I brought to the IG in Albany as an "Ellsworth", even though I studied with him. Most of the stuff I did that week ended up in the burn pile, and was much more squat than tall.

Unless I shoot a picture of a very specific piece, cut out a template, search the wood pile for a very similar piece of wood, and turn and finish in an identical manner, I don't think it's a copy.

I'm not sure why some people view this as a negative topic, but they do. I appreciate both sides of the argument.

Steve

Re: Original Thought

#6

Re: Original Thought

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>After I buy the photo of the Empire State Building, I can take it to New York and walk up and down the street until I see the same view as is in the copywrited photo and wait until the shadows are the same etc. and shoot my own photo and sell it anywhere I want and be perfectly legal since it is my photo.

Re: Original Thought

#7

Re: Part of the reason that many......

Jamie Donaldson

>.. avoid this subject is a lack of knowledge about the complexity involved. The first sentence in your post is not logical regarding what can be protected under copyright /patent/ trademark law. The amount of personal involvement is irrelevant when it comes to intellectual property rights.

Re: Original Thought

#8

Re: Gary- not necessarily true...

Jamie Donaldson

>.... because you may have created a derivitive work in the eyes of copyright law. You have merely created a "copy" of the original if you duplicate many of the attributes of the original work, and that can be interpreted as willful infringement, the worst kind of sin!

Re: Original Thought

#9

Steven Antonucci

Wikipedia definition:Copyright

steve antonucci

>Copyright law covers only the form or manner in which ideas or information have been manifested, the "form of material expression". It is not designed or intended to cover the actual idea, concepts, facts, styles, or techniques which may be embodied in or represented by the copyright work.

I interpret this to say that we are all allowed to copy the way things are done- i.e. hollowing through a small hole. David's copyright applies to the work he produces, not the ideas used to produce it. This is the basis of copyright law.

I guess I may have said it awkwardly, but I understand it. Now you do too.

Steve

Re: Original Thought

#10

Re: Original Thought

john lucas

>You certainly could take the same photo if in fact nothing changed. Then you would have learned what the other photographer tried to capture. Then I would walk around the building looking to see if I could find something different and possibly better. That's the exciting part about creating work of any kind.

We all want to learn new skills. The quickest way to learn and in fact the way that most people learn is to watch someone else and then try to copy the technique to learn the skills. Once you have mastered this skill you start to see other possibilities. Then you get to put some of yourself into the piece. That's what I enjoy and it totally eliminates the very complicated issue of copyright, copying, plagerism and all those other nasty words. In other words , I just have fun making what I want to make.

Re: Original Thought

#11

Steven Antonucci

More on copyright law:Derivative works

steve antonucci

>For example, the copyright which subsists in relation to a Mickey Mouse cartoon prohibits unauthorized parties from distributing copies of the cartoon or creating derivative works which copy or mimic Disney's particular anthropomorphic mouse, but does not prohibit the creation of artistic works about anthropomorphic mice in general, so long as they are sufficiently different to not be deemed imitative of the original. In some jurisdictions, copyright law provides scope for satirical or interpretive works which themselves may be copyrighted. Other laws may impose legal restrictions on reproduction or use where copyright does not - such as trademarks and patents.

Re: Original Thought

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: I don't think that this applies here.

keith tompkins

>Steve, this topic makes many people uncomfortable, I'm not sure why. If someone is a hobbyist, this subject really doesn't matter much. There is nothing wrong in making a piece after attending a Bihn Pho class, for example, and displaying it at shows or at home on a shelf.It only becomes a problem when the person decides to make pieces in that stlye and then begins to sell them.

We have something unique in the wood turning field. I frequently have the opportunity to spend time with artists in other fields; sometimes talking long into the night about such subjects as this. They do not share their methods or techniques as we do. If a potter develops a unique glaze, and it becomes a "signature" feature of their work, they won't share it with anyone. Period. They may teach you to throw a pot, fire and glaze it, but you won't get their "good" stuff.

I do agree with you about your piece not being an Ellsworth "copy". I didn't mean to suggest that it was....just that there seems to be an influence (I'm referring to the tall one) Your approach to the shoulders is different, and the mouth of the form is different as well. As we discussed, I dont think too many turners could successfully pull that form off.

Re: Original Thought

#13

Re: Steve- another wrong misconception...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. about copyright. Any work whose purpose is to convey information or ideas can be protected as "original works of authorship fixed in any tangible medium of expression, now known or later developed, from which they can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or devise" 17 U.S.C. para102(a).

Re: Original Thought

#14

What's a right misconception?

adrien

>

Re: Original Thought

#15

Re:It is difficult to discuss and .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... cuss about a very technical subject without using the specific terminology relating to that subject, aka "lawyer talk." This generalization without specific intent leads to misunderstandings and misinterpretations, and in the field of law that amounts to gossip.

Re: Original Thought

#16

Re: Adrien- oopps, you got me there!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Original Thought

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: More on copyright law:Derivative works

keith tompkins

>It's hard to say how a case will play out. "Cabbabe Patch Kids" was a huge commercial success. When Topps attempted to cash in with its "Garbage Pail Kids" bubble gum, it wound up costing them 7 million in court. In that case, the copyright violation was clear.

Re: Original Thought

#18

Re: Original Thought

Duane C.Leach

>What about an artist who takes money from us to show us and to teach us how he turns a certian bowl or hollow form. Even if the artists claims this is his signature piece, and we are copping it, we paid him to teach us how to make that same piece.In these casses I don't belive an artist has any right to complain about someone copying his art.

Duane

Re: Original Thought

#19

Re: Original Thought

eliot d

>Well, there was a notorious case having to do with the furniture maker, Thomas Moser. Moser wrote and had published a book of his furniture plans. Some guy bought the book, set up a shop, and began selling furniture based on the book designs. Moser sued.The other guy argued that Moser wrote the book and that he

(the guy being sued) paid good money for it. Who do you think won the case? Moser did. The judge said that you could buy his book and copy his furniture designs all you want; but you could not set up a business and sell the stuff.

Re: Original Thought

#20

Steven Antonucci

You'd think that wa covered under parody, no?

steve antonucci

>Guess who had the better lawyers?

Steve

Re: Original Thought

#21

Steven Antonucci

So what do you interpret that to mean?

steve antonucci

>In the case of David Ellsworth's hollowform vs. the turning world, when does someone cross the line into derivative work that violates his supposed copyright? I'm interested in hearing where you think that line is...

Steve

Re: Original Thought

#22

What about an "innocent original"?

Ruth Niles

>With the trillions of people on this planet, what about the truly innocent who happen to think of the same thing and have absolutely no idea someone else thought of it or is doing it?

A song, the same 8 notes in a row, some kid in Iceland just happens to think they sound great and gets a CD made. NEVER heard the original.

A picture; an Eskimo takes a great shot of a polar bear, some professional photographer travels and just happens to take that same picture. Who gets to sue? Does the professional knock on every igloo asking to see everyone's pictures of polar bears to cover himself? It's the guy who gets legal papers first, sorry to say.

A woodturning, can nature sue Ellsworth? He said he gets all his inspiration there? An upside down hornets nest. Who's representing those little hornets interests?

The Raffan type boxes with the domes, does Raffan own that, deserve attribution or does the Greek Orthodox church?

My point? Define "original", define "extent of inspiration". Naturally inventions of tools, machinery or processes never used before because of these need to be protected. But a box? an empty piece of wood? putting red and green together? putting little holes around the perimeter of a bowl?

Re: Original Thought

#23

Steven Antonucci

Well said. My original point exactly.

steve antonucci

>Where are the lines drawn? A bowl? A wooden bowl? A turned wooden bowl? A turned wooden bowl with a foot? A turned wooden bowl with a foot and leaves burned in it? A turned wooden bowl with leaves burned in it an colored? A turned wooden bowl with leaves burned in it, colored and cut and carved? All leaves? All types of wood? All colors?

I'll never turn a bowl like Andi's for sale, but it's not the first leaf bowl I've ever seen (not even in wood). The Hawaiian gift shops have been selling them for years in Maui and Oahu. Different leaves and made from monkeypod, but still a bowl in the shape of a leaf. Who do I attribute the original concept to? My answer is that the idea is "royalty free" and in the public domain.

Ellsworth also admits that he did a series on Southwestern Indian forms (Chaco pots). Molly has cave drawings. Nittman has basket forms. Warhol had soup cans (trademark and copyright protection). Lichtenstein had cartoon art (and was protected even though his work was a direct copy in many cases) I believe that all of these things have entered the public domain.

Where are the lines? If you have to ask, then you're probably standing on it.

Steve

Re: Original Thought

#24

Re: What about an "innocent original"?

Peter Hyde

>Well said Ruth.

I recently posted a scoop on WOW that as far as I know just came to me during an exploration session on the lathe with multi center turnings. I had a picture in my head of a cast metal ice cream scoop and based the idea on that image. Later doing a search on the internet I found Soren Berger's scoops and the similarity is extraordinary. Now I have to question my own memory and wonder if indeed I had not already seen that scoop at some time and passed it over as I was not interested in making a scoop.

No doubt a lawyer could resolve this issue either way depending on who had the biggest cheque.

Re: Original Thought

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: What about an "innocent original"?

keith tompkins

>Ruth, all I'm saying is we are governed by certain laws pertaining to art. It doesn't mean I agree, but we should be aware of this, especially considering the amount of turners wishing to sell their work. I can't recall any lawsuits in the turning world, but they are common in many other fields.

There are only 26 letters in the alphabet, but they can be arranged with unlimited possibilities. Just a few music notes can result in thousands of songs. The trick is HOW we arrange either.

Similarly, there are really only three basic shapes we can turn on a lathe. A cone, a cylinder, and a sphere. Everything else is a combination of those three shapes....the trick is HOW we combine them as well. To an artist, who has spent a lifetime persueing his craft, his art is just as important as a book is to an author, or an invention is to its inventor. A writer will sue you if you use any part of their book without permission, as will the inventor. Yet, somehow many think it's OK to "borrow" from the body of work of other turners. I think it's appropriate to mention influence when making a piece for oneself. If one is making pieces for the market, they should understand, and respect, the rules that have been in place for decades.

Imagine the effort you put into your stoppers, and the costs you've incurred in order to protect your investment. Imagine how devastating it would be to discover someone copying your stopper, yet selling it at half-price! Even worse, they claim they had the idea first! It's not that different from the plagiarism scenario.