Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Turning Political Correctness...

Posts

Turning Political Correctness...

#1

Steven Antonucci

Turning Political Correctness...

steve antonucci

>We haven't had a lively debate in a while, so I figured I'd see if this topic irked anyone else:

On the age old subject of copying/plagiarism- is anyone else IRKED by some of the attributions? Not picking on anyone in particular, but a few lines down, Keith Zimmerman attributes his inspiration for the box he made to Mike Stafford. Mike is the local box hero of record, but hardly the inventor of such. I know that Ron Sardo makes boxes, and posted a design from nearly 100 years ago for a box, so these things are commonplace.

Have we gotten so extreme to say that every little nit and detail has to be attributed to "someone" or is there still the idea that "public domain" exists in the world of woodturning?

I'm not suggesting that there aren't things so specific that attributing inspiration isn't a nice thing to do (e.g. Andi's burned leaves, Eagle's wave pen blanks...), but jeez, it's just a box!

Let's keep it civil...

Steve

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#2

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

Bruce Lane

>Oh oh.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#3

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Steve, I think it's just being courteous to let people know who may have inspired you. I don't think Keith wrote that because he made a box and Mike makes them too. Since we are all so close, Keith probably felt like Mike deserved some thanks for writing the article that then inspired him to make the box. I didn't get the impression that Keith was saying his box looked like one of Mike's? It would be the same as if I turned my first bowl after reading an article on how to make a bowl. I'd feel compelled to thank that person too.

Just my measly un-politically slanted thoughts :)

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#4

I thank Betty Crocker for any cupcakes I make.

Ruth Niles

>It's only right.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#5

JL

Re:What, no "scratch" cupcakes!!!

JL

>Most of my cakes are "scratch" cakes (thank goodness for White Lily and King Arthur Flour). Harvest spice pumpkin roll cake with cream cheese filling - just the thing for those who want their pumpkin, but not a pie.

I do admit to buying the Ghiradeli and BC brownie mix though :).

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#6

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

john lucas

>Jennifer I felt the same way. I make my own boxes but if I read Mike's article and then made one like it I would show it off and say this is one I made using Mike's instructions or possible inspired by Mike. I think it's just courtesy among friends.

I do think it's a line that you have to draw yourself. For example If I turn a nude form but have never studied under Lyle Jameison do I attribute the piece to Lyle even though nudes have been carved, drawn, etc since the beginning of time. Well maybe. I mean I've seen his work in print. So therefore I have to decide if the piece I make is a copy of Lyles work or something that comes out of my head (and you know how wierd that is) If I think it's close enough then I would give credit to Lyle for teaching us how. If I don't feel it's that close then there isn't any reason for credit. Again I think it's a courtesy for all those turners who have taken the time to share what they know.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#7

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I attribute all of my turning inspiration to things dredged up from the mediterranean sea. I'd credit the originators but I didn't catch their names. Anyway, I heard they were inspired by things found in tombs in the middle east.

JKJ

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#8

Steven Antonucci

I wasn't singling Keith out.

steve antonucci

>His was just the latest in what appears to be trend of people feeling like they needed to attribute/align work with prior work.

Keith Tompkins made a comment about one of my pieces at Totally Turning that it was a very difficult "Ellsworth" shape. I like Keith, and it wasn't like I was offended, but I found it strange that someone "owned" an organic shape-even if they did it first!

I think it's an overreaction to the idea of spontaneity and creativity being the most important thing. Part of the "art" in every piece is in "crafting" well designed and executed pieces- original or not. Composition of the wood grain, finish, attention to details, all make it very difficult to copy "public domain" shapes that other turners have produced.

And don't even get me started when it comes to turners copying potters, potters copying nature... Some things are just not "patentable", and a box, bowl, or shapes are among those things in my eyes...

Steve

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#9

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

Barry Elder

>In speaking of political correctness, BAH! Just another catchphrase. As far as inspiration, that is something that has been passed down thru the ages. The last original idea came from someplace where there were only two people, man and woman! Theoretically proving JKJ's point!

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#10

Mike Stafford

No attribution necessary....

Mike Stafford

>Steve, I don't think of myself as any kind of "box hero of record". I am just someone who enjoys turning boxes and tries to teach others to share my interest. It seems that there are very few people who actually turn boxes.

I interpreted Keith's post as a thank you for the simple tutorial I wrote to help people learn to turn boxes. I think that is all he meant by "Inspired by Mike Stafford". Perhaps he should have stated that he was inspired by the tutorial. In any event I am pleased that Keith found the tutorial useful and that it helped him turn a great looking box. Keith flatters me with his kind comments and I thank him for them. I hope he will continue turning boxes.

If anyone cares to read my tutorial it is clear in the introduction that I attribute everything I know about turning boxes to Richard Raffan so Keith should probably more accurately attribute his success to Mr. Raffan. I just presented what I learned from him in a simplified step wise manner that seems to help new turners.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#11

Steven Antonucci

It wasn't meant as a put down or a derogatory way

steve antonucci

>I merely meant that many consider you the "go to" guy on this site for making boxes.

My question came into play because I've seen dozens of these types of things, and they'r becoming more prevalent every day. I heard Johannes Michelsen make a very interesting comment about people "copying" his wooden hats- "It forced me to get better." I thought it was interesting that one side, here's a guy who innovated by making something from a new material who had originally view others copying him as bad now seeing it in a different way. No one saw the other side, which is that Johannes didn't invent the cowboy hat, so he can not "own the form".

Apologies to you if the way I said it sounded like I was directing anything towards you, but it just was a perfect illustration of a topic that I think the current climate goes to far to one side of the argument.

Steve

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#12

Re: No attribution necessary....

Ruth Harding

>Steve, I understand what it is you are trying to do here, however I think you have used words that don't fit. Inspiration can come from anything not just a person (I know you know :). I could say I saw one of your bowls and it 'inspired' me to make a bowl of similar dimensions. I could then post that you had inspired me to make such bowl. No problem with that. I could be inspired by a flower.

I suspect the word 'attribute' is the root of the issue. If I am trying to make a direct copy of 'your' bowl or following 'your' instructions to the letter, I see no issue with saying 'attributed to steve'. It's just the vernacular of the day and this is only a turning blog. If I was to attribute something or say I was inspired by someone and post it in a gallery, or claim it to be the truth in court, that may be a problem.

Have a look at the original Bauhaus furniture and tea pot/coffee pot, etc, designs and you will recognize core elements in much of the 'new' furniture and such today. But we still say 'I bought a sofa from Steve, it's one of his latest designs'.

It's really no big deal on this blog, we are 'just' people who have fun, and some make a living, from playing around with wood and sharing ideas.

If you really want a good topic for discussion how about something like: 'why are chucks and tools so expensive? are they priced on what the market will pay or is it the real cost of production and delivery' or significantly more controversial 'why are there so few turners of colour' (I am black BTW) Is it just a reflection of percentages of the populace, or are there lots of turners who are people of colour but they are not members of AAW or they don't post their pictures.

PLEASE NOTE THIS IS NOT A QUESTION OF RACISM. IT"S JUST SOMTHING I HAVE THOUGHT ABOUT BECAUSE I HAVE ONLY MET ONE OTHER BLACK TURNER.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#13

Re: No attribution necessary....

Don in Central Illinois

>Ruth you bring up a very interesting point. I am going to have to think on this one quite awhile before I post a respons. But this is something to really think about. Man, I love this forum.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#14

Possibly misconstrued, Steve.

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca.

>It could just been the wrong choice of a word.

On the few things that I turn I get inspired by many of the turners here. Everytime I work on something I imagine how you, John, Carole, Ruth, Jenn, Walt, etc. would do the cut or shape. When certain projects are shown, I go out there and try one to see if I can do it. I haven't tried any of the larger deep forms, but I'm sure someday I'll be "inspired" by the likes of Grumbine, TD, and Walt to name a few.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#15

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I posted that subject only because I followed Mike's article here on Wood Central and that is the only reason. Mike does not "own" the box-making process. He himself states in his article that he got most of his inspiration from Richard Raffan.

This is not my first box. I have done numerous boxes before this one and have my own process for doing them. I just wanted to practice with my new Hunter tools and thought I add an second challenge for myself by trying to follow Mike's article, just for the fun of it. When I finished the box, I liked it and wanted to share it and everything pertaining to it. I thought that since I followed Mike's article, I would let people know.

It is my opinion that Keith's comment about the shape of Steve's piece being "Ellsworth" was just meant to create a visual for everyone to see in their mind's eye. In the art world, it is very common for someone describing a piece of artwork to refer to a well-known artist in order for more people to be able to relate to the work.

keithz

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#16

Re: No attribution necessary....

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>The man that got me started turning higher end bottle stoppers is Charles Turnage (appropriate surname!)

One of the better local bowl and platter turners that I know, is Nate Favors. (Don't tell him that his wife Brenda bought a peppermill from me)

Both belong to AAW and are black, there's two to add to your list Ruth, now you know as many as I do ;^).

Having fun yet with that Stubby?

Mike

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#17

Re: No attribution necessary....

Ron in Drums PA

>I met Matt and Carl at TTS in Albany.

6 of us turners had a meal together.

Matt, Carl, Andy, Terry, Steve and myself.

Good Times.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#18

BTW, Steve, I took NO offense...

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I just happened to be handy for an illustration of your point.

keithz

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#19

ps

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>You said: 'why are chucks and tools so expensive? are they priced on what the market will pay or is it the real cost of production and delivery'

It's like the boating world, place the word marine in front of a product and the price at least doubles. It's assumed that having a boat means a person has money. Woodturning is expensive and I think that's part of the reason. Manufacturers/retailers charge what they think they can get. Heck, they come out with more silly, unneeded jigs, tools and variations of same and many turners rush to purchase them.

I looked at an ad the other day for bowl gouges, two offerings, one is the usual factory grind the other had a side grind, they appeared to be the same gouge, simply a different grind. The sidegrind is $30 more than the other. Why? Because rather than grind it him/herself, someone is willing to pay the price.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#20

Steven Antonucci

I was just going to say that!

steve antonucci

>Matt Clarke and Karl Ford.

Then there is Frank Williams (I think that's his name)- carousel horses on his thin walled pieces.

I don't know the answer to your question, but I appreciate you thinking about mine.

Steve

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#21

specialty pricing

Steven Kubien

>Mike, you are bang about adding words to products, like "marine", and the price being driven up. I used to work on the supply side of the dental industry and we sold "Dental Applicators, cotton, 1000pcs" for $25. Any guesses what they actually were?

.

.

.

.

.

Q-tips, and single ended at that!

I think I am going to go and market Eco-Friendly water...

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#22

Re: No attribution necessary....

Ruth Harding

>Thanks Mike, it sounds like there are more black turners/people of colour that I know....still nowhere near represented at the AAW I guess.

I haven't had any good turning time since I bought the stubby at the Portland show. I am going to spend the next couple of weeks playing as I am off work. When I went to turn yesterday I found I was having difficulty doing basic things I have done for a while, like turn a bowl! Now I know I need to keep at it with no long breaks.

Hope you are out of your back brace and able to turn. Have you checked out the new sit down oneway?

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#23

Don't forget one of the early "art" pioneers

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Frank E. Cummings III.

I loved some of his pieces and learned a lot from his Instant Gallery critique at one of the national symposiums (forgot which one). He also is/was an Associate Dean at California State University at Fullerton.

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#24

Steven Antonucci

That's his name!

steve antonucci

>couldn't think of it.

Thanks

Steve

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

#25

Re: Turning Political Correctness...

eliot d

>I don't believe one can own a process, like box making, or hollow form turning, to take just two examples -- or even the way Don Derry finishes his pieces. But I do believe there is something to not simply copying someone's signature form. I'm thinking of, say, Art Liestman's puzzle forms or Molly Winton's running horse cave-like designs. Obviously, there's no law against it; but, then, you should make the attribution and not try to sell these copies.