Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Big Leaf Maple Box

Posts

Big Leaf Maple Box

#1

Big Leaf Maple Box

Ed Moore

>A good friend selected some excellent Big Leaf Maple for me at Bow River, some of which is suitable for spindle turning. I decided to try a box for a piece with spectacular grain to see how it would look. Please give an honest appraisal.


img

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#2

Big Leaf Maple Box, open

Ed Moore

>Here is a shot of it open.

Fire away. ;^D

Ed


img

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#3

Salvo 1

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>My personal preference with spectacular grain is a very simple form that showcases the grain. More specifically, no beads, coves, finials or other fancy spindle work.

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#4

I agree!

Ed Moore

>And I hope that you are enjoying your Robust.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#5

Steven Antonucci

Agree with Brian

steve antonucci

>I think the beads (dark) compete with the curl (light). Curly maple needs almost nothing (except oil, to make the curl pop) to be spectacular. It's a nice box, but I think it has a few two many elements in a tiny space (beads, "finial", curl).

I would have liked to have seen it with 2 beads where the lid joins and a rounded top.

Steve

Who once beaded a box to death, and never showed the monstrosity on WC because you all warned me not to...

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#6

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

Allen Neighbors

>Fantastic wood grain! I like the shape, but think that the beads make it look pretty busy. It's still a keeper for sure!

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#7

Nice one Ed, looks great.

gil jones

>

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

Mike Stafford

>Ed, I have had the same problem with curly woods such as this. I almost always end up with the simplest form I can to display the wood to its best advantage. The use of beads, grooves and other details are sometimes necessary to disguise a poor grain match but if possible I try not to use them. It is still a great looking box and my wife would let me bring it into the house. That is the ultimate test here....

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#9

I wanted to see which ...

Ed Moore

>flaws would be noticed and which ones would not. As has been pointed out, the grain is powerful enough to make the beads and top knot unnecessary.

I wondered if anyone would notice that the line of the bottom tucks in a little below the beads instead of having a line that continues nicely and blends with the line of the top. It is subtle, but there, and I don't like it that way.

I thought that it would be instructive to see an imperfect piece made from beautiful wood.

Ed

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#10

A contrary point of view.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Normally I agree with not embellishing figured wood. However, in this case the figure is circling the box and the rings and finial complement the figure. If the rings were perpendicular to the figure then it would detract from the overall esthetics.

Dave Smith

Going in circles myself in Longview, WA.

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#11

Re: Ed- beads that are aligned .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... with the figure in the wood can enhance the appearance of the figure by breaking the line of the profile, adding another ripple to the straight vertical grain. Whether the beads are rounded or flat, this example works for me! I actually like the rather unusual and modern looking flat beads on this box- good show old man!

Re: Big Leaf Maple Box

#12

Thanks, Jamie! I wish ...

Ed Moore

>that I had more time to turn boxes. Getting ready for the holiday season always seems to distract from the direction in which I thought I was going.

At the moment I find myself turning bell ornaments out of catalpa for a friend who did me a big favor. The catalpa is from his farm, which is historically significant. It is possible to make the bells, but if the particular wood wasn't important to the project, it sure would not be catalpa.

Ed