Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

If i had a WC hat... *LINK*

Posts

If i had a WC hat... *LINK*

#1

If i had a WC hat... *LINK*

vince

>...I'd have taken a picture outside the PARADES exhibit at the Smithsonian's Freer Gallery today. A small exhibit of items "focusing wholly on color, form, pattern, and relationship" drawing from the Freer Gallery's collection of Chinese ceramics urns, bowls, bottles, etc.

I'm always struggle with form, but this was a good reminder to think beyond an individual piece.

Here's a link for those not within walking distance :)


http://www.asia.si.edu/exhibitions/current/Parades

Re: If i had a WC hat... *LINK*

#2

Re: If i had a WC hat...

Cyril Griesbach

>That's an interesting link, Vince. I've often looked at pottery and glass for ideas and looking at the work of Gwin Pigott within the link I again see the same thing. If most of these forms were presented on most of the turning forums the response would be nearly universal.

1. Feet too big on the footed bowls.

2. Base too big on the hollow forms (vase)

3. Too angular, lack of continuous curve etc.

I'm all for stepping out of the box and like to watch the evolution of the work of those who do. However, the many accomplished woodturners as well as most of the average turners posting their work here and on other forums are producing forms with balance and beauty that far surpass that of the aclaimed glass, ceramic and clay artists and they still don't get the recognition as artists they deserve. And lest I forget, our medium is far more intrinsically beautiful than their raw material. Some turners get criticism for embelishing nice wood yet the blowers and potters must do so, in many cases, to complete the piece.

Re: If i had a WC hat... *LINK*

#3

Yes, but...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I agree with your critique on the shapes, but... Those pieces are functional art, not decorative art (a Stephen Hogbin distinction). Functional pieces need larger bases to be stable and suitable for use. This is one of my pet peeves about woodturner's critiques.