Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

Posts

woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

#1

woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

ray

>I've been holding off jumping into the turning realm...that is until now. I'm about to spend some bucks and get the jet 12-20 at a local woodcraft. I saw on their ad that they have the wolverine jig and some beginner's turning tool set on sale. I was wondering if anyone had any thoughts about whether this would be a good route for someone brand new to turning. Oh, my goals for turning are basically to make turnings and an occasional bowl (nothing bigger than 10" or so.

5 piece beginner's turning set $99

http://woodcraft.com/family.aspx?familyid=5238&productid=145914

8 piece beginner's turning set $174

http://woodcraft.com/family.aspx?familyid=5238&productid=145914

Thanks and have a great weekend!

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

#2

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Both sets are made in China and are designed for spindle turning. I recommend buying individual tools rather than sets. Most sets will have tools that you seldom use. I suggest that you take a class in turning (Woodcraft has them). If there is a turning club in your area you can get lots of advice there on what to buy.

Wally

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

#3

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

Don in Central Illinois

>What Wally said. My wife bought me a 'set' from Sears and I seldom, use them. They are not for bowls or hollow forms. Also, most I've run across are cheaply made. Buy quality of what you need, when you need it.

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

#4

Steven Antonucci

You need a skew and a bowl gouge

steve antonucci

>and that's about it.

Everthing else is "helpful", but not necessary. As time goes on, you'll make/buy more tools as necessary, but learning those two first will get you going.

If the money is burning a hole in your pocket, buy a parting tool and a spindle gouge. Then take a class to learn how all four tools cut.

Steve

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

#5

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

Barry Irby

>I agree with the others. Buy the tools you need and get good ones rather than a set. The problem is knowing which ones you need. Most turners are tool hogs or junkies. Many of us believe we are one or two tools from greatness. Go to a couple of training sessions, perhaps at Woodcraft. Join a turning club and visit with other turners.

The exception to the "no sets" admonition might be the sets that come from Harbor Freight. I (and several others here) bought sets of something like eight tools form HF for less than $40. Not great tools but the will get you started and you can practice sharpening on them. They are supposed to be high speed steel but at that price I wonder and don't really care.

Many of us have thirty or forty or even fifty tools, but probably use about six regularly and seldom use over ten or twelve. This is especially true if you stick to one type of turning Spindle, bowl, or hollow forms or whatever. If you bounce back and fourth and do many different things, you will find your self switching "sets", but even then there is probably a core you will use often.

Many of make tools. That a subset of turners and you may find you would rather make them than buy them, but that is up to you.

One of our regulars (Doug Thompson) makes and sells fine tools. I personally do not own any of them, but Christmas is coming. I think he sells his tools unhandled, so you would need a few other tools to make your handles.

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

#6

I love cheap tools . . .

Dave Staeheli

>because you can make specialty grinds on them and feel good you only need them once a year. You know, that reverse, undercut for that candlestick platter you make sometimes. Weird stuff you wouldn't want to grind your good tool for. I've almost completely reground my entire Sears set into something else.

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

#7

If you were my neighbor...

Mike Jones

>...I'd give you MY "starter set"...(if I could find them!) And, if you were a neighbor, I'd show you how I cut bowls, boxes, platters, (etc., etc.) with a 3/8" bowl gouge and a parting tool.

A few good tools, and mastery of sharpening them are key elements to a good beginning.

Welcome to our obsession!

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy?

#8

Re: woodcraft beginner's turning set a good buy? *LINK*

Rick Urban

>I agree with what's already been said, but consider this... If you get hooked, as I did, you will want to experiment with tools, grinds, etc... No better place to start than with those you don't use from your beginner set. If you choose a package, don't throw them away, not even the skew, which you may learn to love (like Dr. Strangelove and the bomb)


img

Wood You Believe