Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Sharpening

Posts

Sharpening

#1

Sharpening

Ron McKinley

>A friend of mine is a retired machinist and he was over the other day to take a look at woodturning. We turned a few things and when we finished I gathered up all the tools we had used and took them to the grinder. He asked why I was sharpening now. I said so they would be ready for tomorrow. He said never sharpen a tool until you're ready to use it. Why I asked. Corrosion. He said corrosion is constant and your tool won't be as sharp tomorrow as it is right after sharpening.

What do you folks think? I have noticed that I get on a kick and sharpen all my pocket/hunting knives at one time and months later when I want to use them they're not really sharp. What say ye?

Ron

A turning a day keeps the doctor away.

Re: Sharpening

#2

Re: Sharpening

Carole Valentine

>Somehow I just don't think I would notice a difference when I picked up a tool that had been sharpened the day before at the end of working and one that was sharpened seconds before turning. On the other hand,I have planes that were sharpened before they were put away a year ago, and when I went to use one the other day it was rusty even though it had been sprayed with BoShield before storage. Guess it's all a matter of time and atmospheric conditions. My shop is not climate controlled and I live in the land of Salt Water.

Re: Sharpening

#3

Re: Sharpening

john lucas

>That's one of those theoretical things that although true, in practical use you won't tell any difference. In fact if that were true you would only get half a revolution of cutting before it's that dull in actual use. It certainly won't make any difference on a HSS tool sharpened to cut metal which makes his statement even more interesting. maybe on a scalpel you might see the difference. Still I love thinking about facts like that. You never know when one will actually affect the way you work so I read and consider them anyway.

Re: Sharpening

#4

I agree

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Razor blades stay sharp until you use them.

It is better to have a pre-sharpened tool ready to use then to have to stop and sharpen it right before you use it. I know I'd rather use it immediately, even if it isn't perfectly sharp.

Re: Sharpening

#5

JL

Re: Sharpening

JL

>Reality check time.

I can see that you might get corrosion in plane blades and a variety of other "straight" blades (one of the reasons I have a dehumidifier in my shop). You will get a surface layer of oxidation on certain steels. However, on turning tools I think that the first encounter with the spindle or bowl stock would "scrub" off any possible oxidation. It may be that the steel used in most modern turning tools resists oxidation more that the steel used in plane blades.

As for me, I usually hone my gouges, bedan and skew. The honing compound leaves a little coating on the tool. I haven't noticed any evidence of corrosion - but I also turn mostly kiln dried wood. I would also say that it's easier to clean and sharpen a tool before the sap or resin dries on it. My $0.02.

Re: Sharpening

#6

Re: Sharpening

Keith Newton

>There is a lot of crossive chemicals in some woods. Leaving a clod of moist wood crud stuck just behind the cuttinng edge will cause a corrosion pit if it is left for a few days. Don't ask how I know this.

Re: Sharpening

#7

Ric Taylor

I Think He Is Picking Nits......

Ric Taylor

>

Re: Sharpening

#8

Re: I Think He Is Picking Nits......

john lucas

>What, you mean you don't sharpen to the atomic level. :)

Re: Sharpening

#9

Re: Sharpening

Allen Neighbors

>I think he's probably right... and I also think he's picking nits (as someone else noted). I think the corrosion he's speaking about isn't as blatant as the word 'corrosion' seems in our minds. In other words, I don't think he means it'll rust overnight. But corrosion is constant, and therefore, as soon as it's sharpened, the corrosion begins to eat away... microscopically. It won't have that much affect on our normal woodturning tools.

I carry three knives all the time. One is a stainless steel blade in a Leatherman Tool. One is a Buck knife in a scabbard that I hope I don't have to use on someone's seatbelt. And the other is an Uncle Henry 3 bladed pocket knife. I get industrious sometimes, and re-sharpen all three knives. Invariably, when I try to cut something with the Leatherman blade it is dull, though I last sharpened it to shave. Which leads me to believe that on stainless steel, the corrosion moves along at a more rapid rate than on other metals.

The Uncle Henry was left in a light fixture I repaired, for almost a year. When I found it again, it was still razor sharp.

The Buck is always sharp... (even when dull).

I don't think the corrosion is bad enough to hurt us if we sharpen so we can be ready for the next day on the lathe.

Just my .02. :)

Re: Sharpening

#10

Re: I agree

charlie belden

>There may be a mental thing with sharpening just before turning. If I'm going to be doing some critical joinery I find that sharpening the cutting tools I will be using on japanese waterstones is beneficial. The process of the sharpening engages my motor skills and muscle memory and the concentration towards the end gets me focusing on the task at hand which, prior to that point might also have been engaged in other daily issues. By the end of the process / ritual my mind, eye and hands have shifted from everyday use to specific, dedicated use. The act of laying out the joint gets me thinking about the next steps, considering potential "challenges" and ways of overcoming them. By the time the actual cutting begins eye, hand and mind are working together and focused on the task with a clear idea of where I'm going and how I'm going to get there. It's sort of like stretching and warming up muscles prior to exerting them.

However, little of the ritual preparations are needed when using the DOMINO to cut mortises for floating tenon joints.

With turning, the ritual preparation can work similarly, preparing the tool, the eye, the hand and the mind for removing everything that doesn't add something to the piece to be turned.

On the other hand, it can be nice to have everything ready to go and just jump right in, with no specific results in mind and see where things take you.

charlie belden