Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

Posts

How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#1

Steven Antonucci

How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

steve antonucci

>So, I made a list of things to do when I got home from Totally Turning in Albany, and sloooowwwlllly, I'm knocking them down one by one...

1.) Regrind Skew to Alan Lacer's profile. Check.

2.) Cut holly blanks for Peter Exton style inside-out candlesticks. Check.

3.) Make a HOOK TOOL. As of tonight, CHECK!

If you've never tried a hook tool, and you have the opportunity to watch Andre Martel throw 1" wide by 1/16" thick shavings that are 20' long from a wet, end grain log, you will know the true joy of woodturning.

Let's make a hook tool.

Tonight, I took a 1/4" bar of O1 steel and heated the end to glowing yellow orange (MAPP torch). I pounded about an inch of it flat (1/16" +/-), and then went over to my belt grinder to get it flat on both sides and the top edge. This took 5 minutes.

I also ground the flat top to an edge, but not the final edge. It's just a lot easier when the steel is flat than after you've bent the hook. (The next one will probably start looking like a butterknife before bending.)

Back to the vise, where it's heated to glowing again and the hook is formed by gripping the tip with the vise and turning. I also used a pair of vise grips to coax the final shape. Andre Martel twists and recesses his a bit, so I followed his suit.

I heat the whole thing again glowing with a torch with the intent of hardening it in mineral oil. One quick dunk, and a small wire brush to get the scale off.

Over to the Tormek to try to sharpen. It's skating on the wheel, so I know that the steel is hard. I lightly touch the edges, and hone the inside with 600 grit used paper around a small drill bit, since I can't find my diamond hone. Finally, the tool is cut from the rest of the bar stock and set into my boring bar for a test.

Here's a picture. Keep reading...

Steven


img

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#2

Steven Antonucci

First cut...

steve antonucci

>So, many of you know me as a hollowform turner who likes to go through small holes. But I ain't crazy. No way I'm trying this thing on a hollowform (First, at least :-)

Here's a piece of bone dry box elder burl that I had laying around. I put it between centers and this is the cut I got first pass...

Keep reading...


img

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#3

Steven Antonucci

So maybe I am crazy enough?

steve antonucci

>Here is a holly hollowform with a 3/4" hole that's 13" long. I stuck the tool through the hole with my "don't you dare kick back death grip on" and held on for the mother of all bad ideas.

Never happened.

What did happen was a cutting action in end grain that was so fast, I had to shut the lathe off because the inside was full. Here's a picture (look closely, since the flash can't fill through that tiny hole...shavings!)


img

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#4

Steven Antonucci

and the form itself...

steve antonucci

>Is 13" long and I was at least 10" over the rest into the form. I freaking love this tool! Tomorrow, I might even make a better shaped hook!

If you don't own a hook tool and you hollow end grain, buy one. Never think about rapid stock removal with a gouge again!

Steve

P.S. Andy DiPietro brought me that big stick of holly you see here... I owe Andy a hook!


img

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#5

Re: and the form itself...

Ron in Drums PA

>And I bought a hook tool tip for $40. You told me to make my own!

Well done Steve

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#6

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

Cyril Griesbach

>Good job, Steve. We made hook tools in our club a few years ago and I never could get it to work for me. Gotta give it another chance I guess.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#7

Steven Antonucci

I'm going to guess that I'll refine it some

steve antonucci

>but that it will largely be very similar to what you have. I took "mental notes" and I've read a bit about them...

Just wait until you see my version of a lamp shade!

Steve

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#8

Steven Antonucci

That was a first pass with a Version1.0 hook...

steve antonucci

>I honestly think it's the fastest tool I've ever "learned"... I just put it to wood and it cuts.

Give it another try.

Steve

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#9

you must have nailed it just right

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I am no expert, but I watched Alan Lacer make one and use it and it just did not look as easy as you make out. Good on you for getting it right immediately. But inside a 13" HF? Not ready, thanks.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#10

Re: and the form itself...

john lucas

>Steve sounds like you had a really good time, and you still are. I've made a few hook tools and after watching Robin woods video I'm going to change the design a little and make another one.

Of course the hook tool design is why I like the Hunter tools so much. You get the same benefits with a tool that doesn't get dull.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#11

Hook Tool vs Hunter Tool

Ron in Drums PA

>No comparison John.

The Hook Tool is way better, the open design is perfect for chip removal.

The Hunter tool is a wanabe. The only advantage the Hunter Tool has iover a Hook Tool s no sharpening and you pay for this by having a tool that performs just ok.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#12

What about tempering?

James McClure

>I'm not an expert on hardening steel, but I thought after heating the O1 and quenching it that there was a tempering process that is recommended. Is it not necessary in this application?

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#13

Re: That was a first pass with a Version1.0 hook..

Don Orr

>That's great Steve, nice work on the hook and vessel. You make it sound so easy maybe even I could do it. It was quite a sight to see Andre make those huge curls fly. I've seen quite a few demos but his was most impressive. Have you tried the "upper cut" he showed us? I have been sick all week so have not had a chance to get in the shop. Hope I remember enough to not get in trouble.

Thanks for all the great feedback on the event, very helpful.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#14

Re: What about tempering?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I think if Steve hadn't tempered the tool, it would have surely snapped off inside the vessel. He probably forgot to mention that step in his excitement ;)

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#15

Steven Antonucci

Actually, I haven't tempered it

steve antonucci

>I know that it's important to temper to remove the brittleness, but to be honest, I've never tempered a single piece of steel for a cutter or this hook.

The first flat that I made snapped when I tried to cold bend it, so I know that it's very hard but it's so small that I think it would take an enormous catch on an embedded nail or something similar to snap it. It's still almost an 1/8" at the bottom, and the inside radius is less than 1/4".

If I feel better (stomach virus) later today, I'll grind and hone the inner radius and properly sharpen the cutting edge. I'll probably break if I try to make it perfect :-)

Steve

P.S. Not trying to say that it shouldn't be tempered, just that I won't bother...

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#16

Alan Lacer hook tool *LINK*

Sue McLam in Orange, VT

>I was one of the lucky few who got to attend an Alan Lacer class last month here in VT. We all made our own hook tool. We were lucky enough for Alan to do the initial grinding/sharpening of it too! We did go through the tempering process. Unfortunately I haven't had a chance to make a handle for mine yet so it's just collecting dust right now.

Alan's site has an article on how he makes his hook tools.


http://www.alanlacer.com/handouts/ho-hooktool.html

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#17

Re: Hook Tool vs Hunter Tool

john lucas

>Ron I've had absolutely zero problems with chip removeal on the Hunter tools so for me that isn't a fair comparison. The chips simply slide over the top and fly out. That is the reason prefer a hook tool to the ring tool. Some of the boring bar tools with the depth of cut guard over the top have chip clogging problems as well.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#18

The upper cut can hurt you if you're not careful!

James McClure

>Don't ask how I know this. :-(

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#19

Re: Actually, I haven't tempered it

john lucas

>Steve In reality it's probably hard for us amateur blacksmiths to achieve the perfect hardness because we don't really "nail" the correct temperature. You obviously got it hard because you described the wheel not cutting it, but you may not have gotten it as hard and brittle as it can be.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#20

Andy DiPietro

Re: and the form itself...

Andy DiPietro

>Hi Steve,

I am glad to see you are using the holly I gave you and making a hook tool. You may want to make your hook tool a little smaller for hollowing. I considered purchasing one from Andre but I was concerned that the curls would get to large inside a hollow form. But once you get it all figured out I would like one. Sounds like you are having a lot of fun since TT 2007.

Thanks

Andy DiPietro

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#21

Re: Hook Tool vs Hunter Tool

Ron in Drums PA

>I guess I'm a little more aggressive

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#22

Re: Actually, For an agressive cutting hollowing

Keith Newton

>tool, I think it may be a pretty good idea to have one which would snap off before it seized the tool and took it away from you.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#23

Re: Hook Tool vs Hunter Tool

john lucas

>Not to dispute you but I don't see how it's possible for the Hunter tool to clog. I've really hogged away some with with each size tool to see how they do and there isn't any way you can clog one. There isn't anything there to clog up. To top of the tool only has a small screw that the shaving fly over. There isn't any lip, cover, or backside to clog like some of the boring bar cutters have or the ring tool.

With a properly designed hook tool you might be able to remove a larger shaving. That I don't doubt at all.

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#24

Steven Antonucci

Curls are cut with the long grain across the curl

steve antonucci

>so the break into a million 1" pieces. I blow them out with a compressor. The tool and the airflow snap them without even trying.

The only reason I'd make a smaller one would be to go through a smaller hole. I'm going to probably make a really big one to be like Andre :-) Clenaing streamers out of my flatstock.

Steve

Re: How could I have not done this sooner!??!!@!

#25

Re: Hook Tool vs Hunter Tool

Ron in Drums PA

>I don't know how to better describe it when the bit just skates along the wood as if it was clogged. No matter which way I turn the bit, it doesn't cut.