Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Lathe warranties

Posts

Lathe warranties

#1

Lathe warranties

Robert D. Macgregor

>I'm in long-term shopping mode for when I can afford a lathe upgrade. Although we always expect everything to work flawlessly right out of the box, it is nice to have a good warranty as back-up. I noticed that a lot of (most?) the 16" to 20" lathes have 5-yr warranties, but seem to exclude the motor (eg, Oneway) or have a shorter warranty on the motor(Nova). Of all the lathe component failures that I can imagine, failure of the motor seems about the most expensive, so why exclude, or shorten, coverage of this critical component? (or did I just answer my own question?)

BOB

Re: Lathe warranties

#2

Re: Lathe warranties

Bruce Forrest

>The motor controller, which runs the on/off, variable speed, forward reverse etc can also be pretty pricey. You can probably guess how I know this.

Re: Lathe warranties

#3

Re: Lathe warranties

john lucas

>That's the only reason I don't like the Nova DVR. It's a great lathe but if that motor goes bad and you can't get a new one from Nova what are you going to do. On all the other lathes you can replace the motor, motor controller, or bearings with off brand parts if necessary. You could probably even have a new spindle turned if necessary although that might get really expensive.

I look at a lathe as a very long term investment, probably more than 5 years. Even thought I really enjoy my variable speed I miss the lathes like the early Vicmarcs and Woodfast. There wasn't anything on those lathes that could go bad that you couldn't replace.

Re: Lathe warranties

#4

Re: Lathe warranties

Rick Allen

>The lathe manufactures make most all of the parts of the lathe. They don't make the motor or controller. The warranty offered for those components is usually what is passed on from the manufacture of those components.

The best warranty is the one you never have to use. The next best warranty is the one where you don't have to explain yourself to get service.

Oneway tends to do the best at these types of warranties. I have heard of Oneway replacing a motor that failed beyond the lathe warranty.

I suspect that other lathes manufactures will provide good service. Service from a manufacture that is out of business is difficult to get.

Woodfast

Polewood

Serious Lathe

Nichols Lathes

Conover

Some manufactures have a less than ideal service record. Some that come to mind are:

General

Vicmark

Some manufactures don't have a very long history of service or of just being around.

Robust

Some lathes have a history of failures.

Delta

Good luck with your quest.

Re: Lathe warranties

#5

Re: Lathe warranties

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Most lathe manufacturers buy their motors from a motor manufacturer. The production volume just isn't large enough to justify producing their own motors - the motor manufacturers have the dual advantages of in-house expertise and the economies of volume. The motor should be warranted by the motor manufacturer, and that warranty is usually based on normal commercial usage. Manufacturing defects normally show up within that time period. After that, a quality motor from a top quality manufacturer can be expected to perform for a decade or more in an commercial environment. For typical lathe usage, the life expectancy would be multiple decades. Cheap motors are a different story, but expensive lathes don't use cheap motors.

Re: Lathe warranties

#6

Re: Lathe warranties

Phil Powell

>Robust may not the longest history in the lathe world but it does have the best warranty

in the business. Check their web site. www.turnrobust.com

Re: Lathe warranties

#7

That's exactly why I dropped it from my list!

Bill Howatt

>

Re: Lathe warranties

#8

Re: Lathe warranties

john lucas

>What's interesting is that most of the lathe failures that I hear about on the net are switch related. Sometimes there are problems with a certain lathe in one line, like the Jet mini's having brocken tool rests, the Delta 46-715 having bad pulleys, and the Nova 3000 having brocken motor shafts, the Craftsman having all sorts of problems etc. All in all our lathes seem to be running pretty good especially when you figure the AAW has 10,000 +members many who own more than one lathe. Then I think they estimate that there are at least 2 to 3 times that many turners who are not AAW members. That's a lot of lathes.

Re: Lathe warranties

#9

Not really...

Peter Teubel

>Excluding the Nova DVR with its proprietary motor/headstock, all other lathe manufacturers use off-the-shelf electric motors. A replacement 3hp motor for my Oneway would be around $300. I bought a brand new GE TEFC 2hp for my previous lathe for around $200 delivered. Remember, an AC motor for an electronic variable speed lathe is 3-phase (regardless of input voltage)....which are cheaper than single phase motors. DC motors are a little more expensive.

It's the electronic drive that is the real expensive part.

Re: Lathe warranties

#10

Re: Not really...

Bruce Forrest

>Tell me about it!!!

Re: Lathe warranties

#11

Re: Lathe warranties

Robert D. Macgregor

>Thanks for all the responses. It's good to get viewpoints from more experienced folks. It sounds to me like reputation of the lathe and its manufacturer is a lot more important than the actual details of the warranty wording. That's not a surprise, but it still leaves me with too broad a range of choices (and mostly at or above my price range...maybe I'll just save up for another year...)