Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Keeping holly white

Posts

Keeping holly white

#1

Keeping holly white

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Hi all. I'm working with some beautiful holly on two non turned pieces. I'm posting here as turners have more experience with the stuff than flat workers.

I know there is no such thing as a finish that will impart NO effect on a piece of wood. I also know that lacquers, particularly some of the water based ones, produce a dramatically clear finish, but they still change the appearance of the wood.

The absolute best appearance of this holly is when it is unfinished, but it is extremely susceptible to discoloration from body oils and other sources. One touch with an oily palm/finger will make that spot yellow.

Given all of the above, what would you do with these pieces of holly to keep them white and protect them from contaminants that would discolor them? They will be handled for sure. Thanks!

Re: Keeping holly white

#2

Re: Keeping holly white

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thin water base poly. See discussion below.

Re: Keeping holly white

#3

Re: Keeping holly white

john lucas

>Mike The finish that I have found that affects wood the least is Krylon Fixatif. It does change the color of some wood but on many woods it doesn't appear that you have applied any finish whatsoever. I don't think I've tried it on Holly but I don't think it will change it much if at all.

Re: Keeping holly white

#4

Re: Keeping holly white

john lucas

>Mike I just planed a piece of dry holly and sprayed a section. It yellows very slightly. I don't have any water based finish right now so I can't try that.

Re: Keeping holly white

#5

Re: Keeping holly white *LINK*

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I use Hydrocote Resisthane on wood that I don't want to change color. I spray it with a HVLP conversion gun. I get it in gloss. If I want it satin I just rub it out with abralon pads. It is water born, so I raise the grain with water and sand of the raised grain before I spray it. Here is a link to the product at Highland Hardware.


Hydrocote

Re: Keeping holly white

#6

Re: Keeping holly white

eliot d

>I find that just bleaching with Klean Strip two- part bleach leaves a beautiful satin look. I suppose you could then simply spray with a fixitive.

Re: Keeping holly white

#7

Andy DiPietro

Re: Keeping holly white

Andy DiPietro

>Thanks for posting.

Since this finish is water based can I spray it in a basement workshop with minimal odor? What HVLP conversion gun system do you use and about how much does it cost?

Thanks

Andy DiPietro

Re: Keeping holly white

#8

Re: Keeping holly white

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I don't know about this one in particular but I have sprayed Fuhr water based pre-cat lacquer in a basement workshop. It has absolutely no volatile compounds and zero odor. My wife loves it, and it is really, really clear, too. I don't prefer it to nc based lacquers as there is no burn in of previous coats, and it takes longer to dry between coats. However, it is a great alternative for producing flawless finishes under constraints such as yours.

Re: Keeping holly white

#9

Re: Mike- last year(?) Fine Woodworking...

Jamie Donaldson

>... did a test of finishes and top rated General Finishes High Performance water based Top Coat. I have been using it on light colored woods like maple and it imparts no color change at all, and dries to a wonderfully hard poly finish. I really appreciate the improvements made in water based finishes since I use a kerosene radient heater in my "studio" during cold weather!

Re: Keeping holly white

#10

Re: Keeping holly white *LINK*

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Yes, you could use it in the basement. I plan on making a spray booth with a fan and a furnace filter to pick up the over spray. I saw plans for it somewhere, but can't remember where. I use the Wagner Gun. It works well for me. I don't have enough spray gun experience to compare it to anything else, except my old Sears conventional gun. I threw that out after using this one. Much less overspray! I've used it for turnings, and for spraying shutters, porch posts, an aluminum porch roof, and spraying deck finish on the lattice around the bottom of my deck. I figure it saved me at least 4 hours work over painting the lattice by hand. I've done it both ways. I have had no problems with it. Here is the link. Gleem Paint gave me good service. I bought mine in Oct. of 2003. The price is still the same $129. Someone with more spray experience may like something else better, but this works for me.

Tom


Wagner HVLP

Re: Keeping holly white

#11

Andy DiPietro

Re: Mike- last year(?) Fine Woodworking... *LINK*

Andy DiPietro

>Hi Jamie,

It was in Nov/Dec 2006 issue of Fine Woodworking. I will read the article tonight. According to the enclosed data sheet you can brush this finish on. Do you brush it on or spray it?

I turn mostly hollow forms from green wood. Is there any issue with the first coat cracking as the wet hollow form dries oval? This sounds like a good choice for spalted woods and box elder.

If you use it on curly and figured maple do you loose the pop that an oil would give?

Thanks

Andy DiPietro


http://www.generalfinishes.com/msds-data/GF-High-P

Re: Keeping holly white

#12

Re: Keeping holly white

russ Fairfield

>There is nothing you can do to keep Holly white. It will naturally age to an "old ivory" light amber coloring, and there is nothing you can do to stop that. You can slow it down with UV inhibitors, but they will deteriorate with age, the inhibitors will themselves turn an orange color, and the wood under it will continue the process of turning into amber. The only sure way to keep Holly white is to keep it in the dark and away from exposure to the atmosphere. Anything else, and it will age towards looking like old ivory.

The best you can do is use one of the suggested finishes that will stay clear, not discolor, and not add to the natural coloring of the wood for a "reasonable" period of time, and let the wood naturally age under it.

We have to personally determine the definition of a "reasonable time" because there is no such thing as a clear finish that will stay clear forever. Everything we can put on a piece of wood will age towards an orange color. The only difference is that some take longer than others for this to happen. A "Reasonable time" can be tomorrow, next week, next year, or 10 years from now. I am looking at finishes that are over 50 years old, and believe me when I say that NONE of them are still colorless.

The "Fixitif" that John mentions will impart the least color to the wood, will be the closest to adding no more color than wetting the wood with water, and it will last the longest, however, it too will start to yellow in 5 to 10 years, depending on exposure to sunlight. There may be newer finishes with a more durable clarity, but we will have to take the word of the manufacturers and rely on the short-term experience of others, neither of which have been reliable in the past.

Re: Keeping holly white

#13

Re:Andy- I wipe most of my ......

Jamie Donaldson

>...finishes on with a small square of yellow carpet pad foam- cheap(often free!) and disposable. I don't then wipe as much back off as with an oil finish, and have seldom applied more than 2 coats. I haven't notices much raising of the grain at all, unusual with a water based finish? No muss, no fuss, just the way I like a finish to perform!

Re: Keeping holly white

#14

Re: Mike- last year(?) Fine Woodworking...

russ Fairfield

>The answer to this one would seem to be obvious. This accenting of the wood grain that we often call "popping the grain" depends on the difference in absorbancy of the finish between end grain and flat grain, and the resulting differences in coloring of the wood. Any finish that produces the least wetted appearance to the surface and/or the least color change should also have the least "popping" of the wood grain.

In the past, it has always been true that the waterborne finishes produce the least color change to the wood, and oil finishes the most, it follows that the oil will give the greater accent or "popping" to the grain.

However, this is no longer true. Many of the new waterborne finishes use water soluble oils that do add color to the wood and do produce a good "popping" of the grain without leaving a rancid bacon grease appearance to the wood surface. I am most familiar with the one called "Enduro" that was recently purchased and is now marketed by General Finishes. It is available at Woodcraft stores that I know of. Enduro does an excellent job of accenting the wood grain, and it can be built up to a clear high gloss surface that will further accent that grain for the maximum effect and beauty. If this sounds like an advertisement, it is because I have found it to be the best of the bunch when it comes to waterborne finishes, and the equal of most oil finishes when it comes to "popping" the wood grain.

Re: Keeping holly white

#15

Thanks all!

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I'll post a pic of the sanded, ready to finish piece(s) and then with a finish, too, so we can see exactly what it has done.

Re: Keeping holly white

#16

Enduro?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Russ how much color does Enduro add? As much as blonde shellac? or maybe as much as Linseed Oil? or as much as nitro cellulose lacquer? Can it be sprayed? I am leaning more toward using finishes with low VOC's. Didn't some of the water born finishes give off formaldehyde fumes? I developed asthma last year and I'm trying to keep the lungs from being irritated. I think the asthma is allergy induced. I wear the Trend Airsheild more now, but that is only good for dust. I have a half mask respirator, but only wear that when I need to keep out fumes. I'm still not used to the asthma problem. I'm trying to work out how I can keep working with wood and not have trouble breathing. Actually cutting the grass and being around the dogs seems to irritate the lungs more than the shop.

Thanks

Tom

Re: Keeping holly white

#17

Re: Enduro?

russ Fairfield

>I know this is a subjective observation, but to me, the Enduro adds no more color to the wood surface than wetting it with water; and it doesn't yellow with age for as long as I have used it (4-years).

It was developed by Compliance Systems for use in their HVLP sprayers, but I have never used it for anything other than brush and wipe-on applications.

Re: Keeping holly white

#18

Re: Keeping holly white

eaglesc

>After reading the application procedure for Enduro I tried Unaxol from Mobey Dick supplies.

A monkey could apply it blindfolded in a dark room.(with one arm tied behind his back.)

It is fool proof.

Being a fool I still love it.:>)

Re: Keeping holly white

#19

thanks Russ

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>