Questions about holly-
steve antonucci
>Don't tell my wife I asked about her ;-)
1.) Does holly move a lot during drying?
2.) Can it be DNA soaked without messing up the color?
3.) If the color changes with DNA, can it be bleached out?
Thanks
Steve
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Questions about holly-
steve antonucci
>Don't tell my wife I asked about her ;-)
1.) Does holly move a lot during drying?
2.) Can it be DNA soaked without messing up the color?
3.) If the color changes with DNA, can it be bleached out?
Thanks
Steve
Re: Questions about holly-
Don Evans
>Steve:
I cannot answer you directly as I've never soaked any.
However I can tell you that I've turned a lot of Holly and the best secret I can pass on is that it must be dried (kiln) asap in order to maintain the white color.
Cutting to turning blank and wax sealing then drying has never caused any problem with cracking for me, but I do have a small kiln that I built just for this purpose.
When I say must be done quickly I mean you pretty much got to process it the day you cut it down or it will immediately begin to blue stain.
Lot of turners don't like the blue stain but bleaching can be done on this wood if you want too.
The logic here is that like all wood, moisture is the enemy so the quicker you can get it dry the better. Cracking isn't a real problem but I dry with slow process, kiln at 90 deg as opposed to 150.
I've had good luck with it but my latest piece I wasn't able to follow my own advise so it will be interesting to see what I end up with.
Don
Holly loves to crack
Charles R. Smith from Victoria
>Steve,
I've turned holly for bowls, lamp stands, decorative snowmen and other things. I love turning the stuff, as it cuts beautifully and takes a gorgeous finish. I sand it to 1500 grit before applying the final coats of tung oil or wipe-on poly (depending on the item). I have also turned spalted holly, and the black lines are a wonderful contrast to its white wood.
Holly does crack badly. With some freshly-felled holly, I dried a number of rough-turned bowls using DNA, and still had a fairly high rate of cracking. By boiling it for two hours (in a pot on the side burner of my barbeque), it substantially reduced the cracking rate, from 100% down to about 40% with most of those cracks being small and easily managed. The boiling did not affect the subtleties of its final colour/grain patterns.
I also tried using both alcohol after boiling, to speed the drying process, and that worked well with no appreciable increase in cracking. I found that I had to boil and dry the holly in fresh water/alcohol, or it would take up the colour left behind by other bowls (e.g., cherry, plum). In the end, I set aside a container of isopropyl alcohol for use with holly only, to prevent colour contamination by the other types of wood.
In the spalted holly, which was already cracked and dried when I received it, I used coffe grounds with CA glue to fill the cracks. The dark colour of the coffee grounds mimicked the appearance of the spalting, such that the cracks weren't a visual problem.
I have a 40 foot holly tree in my back yard, and am waiting for the day that it blows down in a storm. If it should fall, I won't be disappointed.
Charles (whose chainsaw is stored dangerously close to the holly tree)
Re: Questions about holly-
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I acquired a bunch of holly about 10 years ago, two days after the tree was cut down. I finish-turned it green and let it move. It moved a lot. One crotch section was marbled with green. The green color is essentially unchanged after 10 years (I still have that piece). I didn't have any trouble with blue stain, but I processed that batch fairly quickly.
I've also had holly that I didn't get to for a while and... between the bugs and cracking... I got a couple of vases with a lot of character and the rest was firewood.
Re: Questions about holly-
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Last summer I was given a very large holly log. I roughed out the bowls I wanted right away and soaked in denatured alcohol hoping to avoid blue stain. It worked for me. Holly is the only wood I use poly on. It has been my experience that a water base poly will not change the color.
I seldom have had trouble with holly cracking or warping excessively except the time I tried to dry it in the microwave.
Re: Questions about holly-
JohnKJordan in East TN
>I got a quantity of holly last year. I processed it right away into blocks primarily for spindle turning and boxes, coated the end grain, and let it air dry. All of it stayed white. I dried some in the microwave oven but no DNA. I see no end grain checks. I didn't face turn any but it seems quite stable when spindle turned.
It's a joy to turn and finishes nicely. With a shellac-based friction polish (Mylands) on spindles more than one person has said it looks like ivory.
JKJ
Re: Questions about holly-
keith tompkins
>Hey Steve, I try to rough turn my holly the minute I get it...soaking wet. I haven't lost any that way.
I believe by the time you see cracks in the end grain, damage has occurred far beyond what's visible...that explains why a cracked piece keeps cracking along the same line as the original tiny split. I don't waste my time turning anything visibly cracked (any species)...it's going to get worse.
Wet turned holly stays white for me. I just bag it.
Re: Questions about holly-
Ed Karch
>I turned a small ring box wet and hand threaded the lid and got away with it. It started to warp then turned around and straightened as it dried. One of a very few experiments that succeeded.
Re: Questions about holly-
eliot d
>My experience with holly is that it can develop an ugly grayish color. So I bleach it with those two part bleaches. It turns to a beautiful white, that I like so much that I don't finish it. Just leave it alone.
Re: OT: Sorry for the hijack
Allen Neighbors
>Ed, I purely enjoyed getting to visit with you when we went to SWAT.
How about starting another thread to tell us about your experience at the Canyon School? I've been wondering how it went. I know you enjoyed yourself while there, and I didn't want to put you on the spot, but I'm curious about the school.
Re: Questions about holly-
Gary Evans Tallassee, TN
>Hi Keith,
No offense, but you could be throwing away some usable wood. The way it was explained to me is this:
Take a piece of printer paper by two adjacent corners and try to pull it in two by pulling the corners away from each other. Note the force it takes to cause the paper to tear and that it will probably just tear loose next to where you've grasped it, rather than tearing down the center.
Now take a similar piece of paper and make a small tear in the edge near the center. Now when you exert some force, the small tear becomes a much bigger one with a relatively small amount of force on the two corners.
Wood acts similarly. Once it starts to crack, which occurs because the forces generated by shrinking cells pushing against unshrunken ones behind them become greater than the bonds between the adjacent cells, the cracks will perpetuate, just like the torn paper.
I have had good results with cutting back cracked pieces till there are no more cracks in the cut-off section. Once you get past the fracture plane, there is no reason for the crack to resume, unless you once again get an imbalance in the moisture content between the outer layers and inner layers of cells.
Now that's not to say that there aren't instances where the bonds between cells are especially weak, as in ring shake. In cases like that, your crack would probably reappear as many times as you cut it off. With drying stress cracks (checking,) however, you can cut the bad part out and still have solid wood.
FWIW,
Gary
Re: Questions about holly-
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>Elliot, if I am turning Holly ornaments or something else I know the buyer will not be putting things in I just buff and wax. When a person is given or buys a bowl there is always the chance they will put something in it. In the case of Holly, a raspberry salad dressing would really make a mess of it. The poly ends up being flat not gloss and there is not much figure that can be obscured so thus the poly.
checking checks
JohnKJordan in East TN
>>I have had good results with cutting back cracked
>pieces till there are no more cracks in the cut-off section.
To expound on this for those who may not know, there is a simple method to insure an invisible end grain crack does not remain in the wood. Cut off some amount of end grain, then take an additional thin slice, perhaps 1/8" thick or less. Bend this slice and any remaining crack will be obvious. Repeat until none of the crack reamains in the thin slice.
I've done this with seriously checked end grain and while some is ruined deep into the center, some cracks are surprisingly shallow. I processed a bunch of spalted/burled/crotch white oak yesterday that had been sitting out in the sun all of this hot, dry summer. (I was splitting fire wood when I opened some pieces I just HAD to save!) Some ends were seriously checked to start. However, most cracks extended no deeper than 1-2".
JKJ
Re: checking checks
john lucas
>I've been doing what John suggests for several years now with fabulous results. I trim a think section off the log, usually 3/8 or thicker because I'm not that skilled with the chainsaw. Then I flex this. If it breaks I trim another one. When they no longer break I have a sound end to measure from for my bowls etc.
Re: Questions about holly-
eliot d
>Barbara, thanks for the tip. My stuff is just to look at, so I don't worry too much about stains. What kind of wax do you use? Does it yellow the holly any?
Re: checking checks
JohnKJordan in East TN
>>I trim a think section off the log, usually 3/8 or
>thicker because I'm not that skilled with the chainsaw
Lest there be a misunderstanding, I cut my 1/8" and smaller slices in the shop with the bandsaw, not at the woodpile with the chainsaw! A 3/8" slice sounds like pretty skilled chainsaw handling to me.
JKJ