Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

QC Criteria - Customers or Critics? *LINK*

Posts

QC Criteria - Customers or Critics? *LINK*

#1

QC Criteria - Customers or Critics? *LINK*

charlie belden

>I posted this to rec.crafts.woodturning but there are probably folks here who don't have usenet access who have opinions on the subject.

(Note: I�m using the positive connotation of the word �critics� - as in critique / constructive criticism - rather than its negative nit picking egotistical attacks connotation)

One of the many advantages of being a member of a turners club is the opportunity to see day long demonstrations by well known turners. I had the pleasure of spending a Sunday watching Cindy Drozda demonstrate her method of turning three types of boxes, two with her signature beautiful finialed (is there such a word?) tops. She�s a great teacher in addition to being a very accomplished turner and artist. Her love of, and passion for, turning is infectous. Attached is a link to her web site. Photos can only give you an idea of what this turner does.

The first piece she created was an elegant little lidded holly box with a padouk inlaid �rim� and foot. At maybe 2 1/2� diameter and perhaps 3 1/2� tall - including the long delicate finial - there was a lot of very precise turning packed into a very small and beautiful package.

The piece required two critical fits - the inlayed padouk to the box rim and the finialed lid to the inlay rimmed box. The blending of all three to form a continuous whole isn�t trivial either - but I want to focus on the issue of �fit�.

If you�ve made a �turned lidded box� you know how tricky it can be to get a nice fit. Even when you sneak up on it, it can be a Too Big, Still Too Big, Just A Little Too Big - TOO SMALL! Thing.

Now if you�re turning a lidded box to show off your turning skills to other turners, a good fit means a �click� or �pop� fit. Anything less is too loose or too tight. BUT - if you want to impress a non-turner - say a potential purchaser of your turned lidded box, a nice snug �click� or �pop� fit might work against you, especially if the lid has a delicate finial. If, however, the top lifts off easily, revealing the inside of the box, and let�s not forget the underside of the lid, well the potential for a sale goes up noticably. And even if the person doesn�t buy a piece, the look on their face as they examine, and appreciate the piece can be a pay off that money can�t buy.

�Lid Fit� is just one example of the question - how much of what we shoot for when turning is critical to the piece and how much is just �I can - so I do�? Is a uniform 1/16ht inch wall thickness really that significant to the piece? Sure, for Christmas Tree Ornaments, where weight is an important factor, really thin wall are desirable. But on a foot tall, 8 inch diameter piece, is there really any need for uniform thin walls? Other than the challenge of hollowing through a seemingly impossibly small opening in the top, why not hollow through a larger opening in the bottom and �plug� it when th hollowing is complete? Is the non-turner really going to notice, less alone appreciate, a surface right off the perfect continuous finish cut as opposed to one that was sanded smooth then given a film finish?

Do you turn to the limits of your skills, and maybe just beyond what you think you can do, or do you turn to make your idea into a tangible object - that may or may not be appreciated by anyone else on the planet?

charlie belden


Cindy Drozda's Turning Site

Re: QC Criteria - Customers or Critics? *LINK*

#2

Re: QC Criteria - Customers or Critics? *LINK*

russ Fairfield

>The answer to your questions is who we see as our "customer", and who we are trying to please. If we see our customer as other woodturners, and their praise as our payment, we have one set of criteria. We have a different criteria when we see our customer as the person on the other side of the counter with their money in their hand. They are totally different customers with different demands of our art or craft.

Most of the time our critics and critiquers of our art are other woodturners because they tell us what we want to hear. We are usually upset when non-woodturners or artists in other mediums critique what we do. They see our art differently, and they tell us things we don't want to hear. We complain that they don't understand wood as an art medium, and we go back to having the critiques by other woodturners.

Snap lids are no different from thin walls. Other woodturners demand them in a box or a vessel because they are a sign of skill and quality. The buying public coundn't care less about the thickness of the wall (most will prefer thicker and heavier), and they definitely see a snapping lid as a defect.

This conflict between art and the marketplace is not new. It is really just another form of the "Art vs. craft" argument, but down at a level where the money is being exchanged for our work. I prefer to view it as the difference between something that is useable and something that is there just to look at. Few woodturners are willing to accept that the larger general public sees what we make as being useful, and most woodturners are insulted by the often asked question, "What is it used for?"

Sections 3 and 4 of the link will further explain my view on this topic.


http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/russ1.shtml

Re: QC Criteria - Customers or Critics? *LINK*

#3

Re: QC Criteria - Customers or Critics?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I don't sell, so my primary customer is me. I turn things that interest me. Friends and relatives like the things I make and give to them, but that is hardly a good source for feedback.

I've solicited comments and critiques on some of my more recent endeavors from two different sources: 1) non-woodturning artists who would critique the work as objects and 2) the local woodturning club where our president will critique show-and-tell items if you request it. The results were very interesting. Both sets of critiques hit exactly the same shape/form points and differed only in areas of personal taste.

The caveat is that I was turning unusual/non-standard forms that don't have a set of woodturner's "technical excellence" standards like snap-fit lids, etc.

Re: QC Criteria - Customers or Critics? *LINK*

#4

Re: QC Criteria - Customers or Critics?

Rick Davenport

>It's a wonderful feeling when someone falls in love with a piece of your work.

Often they can't tell you why they like it.

They just do.

And those that can explain have criteria that differs from individual to individual.

And try as I might, I can't spot a trend.

As I continue grow in skill, I am confident that more pieces will please more people.

In the meantime, I'll just keep making pieces that please me.

Rick

Re: QC Criteria - Customers or Critics? *LINK*

#5

Re: QC Criteria - Customers or Critics?

Barry Elder

>At the request of several ladies, I no longer turn boxes with a suction-fit lid. They didn't like them because it took two hands to open. OK. Beautiful weather out there today! Have a GREAT DAY!