Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

Posts

Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#1

Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

john lucas

>I finally had time to work on a hollow vessel today and play with the #1 hunter tool. I switched back and forth between the Hunter tool and the HSS tool in both 1/2" and 3/4" bars. It is interesting. It seems to cut easier so less pressure is needed. In the 1/2" bar you can extend the bar a little deeper before it starts to chatter. Same was true for the 3/4" but it was less noticeable.

What's different. I have a habit of cutting in both directions when hollowing. I'll squeeze my hand and make a cut to the left then I'll cut back toward the middle. I do this in increments making steps so that I can feel them as I go into the vessel. With the Hunter tool I can still cut to the left and it's quite aggressive if you want. However when you try to cut back to the right it sort of bounces. Still I don't think this is a bad thing since it cuts more aggressively you still get done in the same amount of time.

I have my boring bars indexed with a flat area so when I am using a captured bar or when using the arm brace the tool is always oriented in the same way. With the Hunter tool I like to rotate the tool to different angles for different cuts. I can't do that with my arm brace or the captured bar. I might be able to do that with John Jordan's handle. (oh goody I get to buy another tool) I have also found that I can get rid of the center nub very easily with the Hunter tool if I rotate it to the right at about 35 or 45 degrees and then cut from the left to right. This cleans up the the nub and the bottom rather nicely. That would be impossible with my indexed bars.

So at first I would have called it a draw but I realized that I usually sharpen the HSS after each vessel. Sooner if it's a hard wood. The Hunter just keeps on cutting.

I should say that I drilled out the middle so I didn't have to work on the center nub on this vessel. I prefer to do that when ever I can. It saves time and eliminates the center nub problem.

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#2

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

Karen F.

>John, Thanks for the information. I have been looking at Hunter Tools after reading so much here and I think I'm going to order one soon. Do you have a favorite set? Number 3 or 4 or 1(is this a different size set)now? I have a Stewart System I use and like and a captured system I can't figure out how to set up correctly:(

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#3

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

Allen Neighbors

>Good report, John! Mike had one of the small (3/16) cutters in a 1/4" round mount for me when I arrived at SWAT. I've used it a little, but it was enough to know that I have never seen any of my other tools cut like the Hunter! Smooth as silk! I'm glad I bought it, and wish I'd bought one of the larger ones, also.

Which size would you recommend, if you were only going to get one more?

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#4

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

john lucas

>Karen Let me first say that I don't think the Hunter tool is a gauranteed problem solver. In fact a brand new turner will still have the same basic problems and that is learning the feel of a tool. If you are already using a tool like the John Jordan tool and are happy with it I wouldn't change. However if you do a lot of hollowing it it might be a good tool to add to your asenal. For hollow vessels it's only marginally better in that it holds an edge longer and might let you go another inch deeper before chatter. So it's kind of a wash for the beginner but the advanced turner will find it useful.

What I do think the Hunter tool is good for is hollowing vases and boxes. Once you've gotten passed the learning curve the cuts are extremely smooth and require less sanding and it may just be a personal thing but I think it takes less effort to cut with this tool so when you are doing production runs it's less tiring. It does take some practice to not get little waves. It doesn't have the wide edge of a scraper and even though your rubbing the bevel, the bevel is short and the cut is controlled by rolling and sliding the tool which makes it harder to get a long perfectly smooth arc with no ripples. Like any tool practice makes it better.

Which tool to buy is fairly easy. If you only do vessels up to about 6" deep then the #3 tool is a good one. It's small enough to get through a fairly small hole and the shank is big enough to go this deep.

If you do deeper vessels like vases then I would go with the #4. The #1 and #2 are for use in boring bars for really deep work. They fit in the bars that take 1/4" hole or 3/16 square accessories. The John Jordan bars will take either one. The Jamieson bar I believe takes 3/16 square. I'm not familiar with the other brands.

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#5

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

john lucas

>Allen I like the #4 in a handle. It seems to be very versatile. The #3 in a handle is also great for smaller work. I mounted my #3 in a 3/4 boring bar and it's pretty good but gets a little vibration when going more than 6" deep. For that the #1 or #2 is better.

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#6

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>John, thanks for your description here. I have built my own #3 and #4 tools and I can say that they work, right out of the box, so to speak. I am now in the process of working out the process. Working with your and your tools at Indyfest helped me to be able to make ribbons of wood come out of a very dry piece cedar as soon as I put the #3 together.

keith

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

Mike Stafford

>There is a learning curve associated with these tools but once you get the angles of presentation correct they will slice hard end grain like butter. I say angles of presentation because you have to tilt the tool downward like a scraper and tilt/roll to the left until you find the "sweet spot". Once you get it right the shaving come off like those you might see when using a microtome to slice a frozen tissue sample. Truly the cut is remarkably clean. The surface of these dense hardwoods looks almost burnished. I have had slightly different results with the less dense woods. It also helps to use the tool at higher RPM's. I found that the quality of my cuts improved by increasing the RPM's from 1400 to 1800. I think what RPM you should use should be determined by experience, the material being cut and by familiarity with the tool.

At present I have only used the #1 and #3 mounted on 3/8" shafts. The #1 is mounted on a 3/8" shaft that has been thinned down near the point where the cutter is mounted. The #1 is a finesse tool and is easier to catch because it can quickly cut itself into a catch. It takes little pressure to move the tool too deep while cutting.

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#8

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

john lucas

>Mike I picture you on an episode of CSI with your Microtome slicing away and solving the latest mystery. You may be a star any minute.

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter #1 vs 3/16 HSS cutter

Mike Stafford

>If I ever use a microtome it will probably be to slice thinner slices of roast beef but at least you understood the analogy....LOL