Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

It Blowed Up! For Sale Cheap

Posts

It Blowed Up! For Sale Cheap

#1

It Blowed Up! For Sale Cheap

Jim MIiles-Charlotte, NC

>Oh, it was going to be a beauty!! A new concept, segmented& staved creation, that is until it Blew up and wound up all over the shop floor. For sale cheap: One do it your self segmented bowl kit, slightly used , only a few parts missing.


img

Re: It Blowed Up! For Sale Cheap

#2

Re: It Blowed Up! For Sale Cheap

Dennis Daudelin

>Wow, lots of little parts!! I hope that you had your face shield on and were not hurt in this explosion!

What kind of glue did you use?? Seldom have it seen the parts separate like this!

Also, does the grain of the regular sections go horizontal and the grain on the vertical pieces go up and down (like staves)??

If so, this might be a big part of why it didn't hold together??

If you read any of the segmented books today, you will find that they don't (ever) recommend mixing the direction of the grain. The normal movement of the wood due mostly to moisture will separate these joints and make them weak.

Malcolm Tibbetts, in his book has a great section on "Understanding Wood". He lists and then describes in detail the reasons that joints may not hold. Number 1 is high wood moisture content and Number 2 is incompatible wood grain orientation. It's worth the cost of the book!!

If this was not the reason, then I'm baffled and hopefully you weren't hurt in the explosion!!

I hope this helps you and others reading and hoping to do segmented work!!

Dennis

Re: It Blowed Up! For Sale Cheap

#3

Re: It Blowed Up! For Sale Cheap

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>Yes, I had face shield on, nothing hurt but my pride.

Use Titebond III - not the problem

The joint between the bottom ( in center of Pic ) and the main body failed as I was hollowing out the inside. The main body came apart with the impact. The joint failed because I had not flattened adequetaly the botton segmented piece. Looking at the joint I found out it only had 2 spots about one square inch holding top to bottom, I've done a 100 of these & I still don't know how I could have done that.

AS for the grain orientation. The body was an experimental piece and pushing the limits and ingoring all the glue theories. Sometimes you gotta break the rules in order to reach new ground!