Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Ethical Question?

Posts

Ethical Question?

#1

Ethical Question?

Keith Newton

>I have a show coming up too soon, and I need to stay out in the shop instead of being in here typing, but I was pondering something , and thought I would seek your input.

I have always felt and used inspirations from nature in my work, but as of late, some of my work is so closely mimicking nature, that I am wondering, how close can you get and still claim credit for the design? Ha

I will post some photos pretty soon showing what I have been doing, and seeing if you like it, and or whether I get to claim any credits or not.

Oh, I have read so much environmental stuff back through the years, that I don't remember where I read it, but there was an opening paragraph to something that I read a long time ago which started out something like this.

"There is so much to learn from nature, that some of the information that you gain from studying it , can be life changing. That is, that after you learn, or find something, it will set your life on a new path, that without it, you would not take". Thus, this information is a part of your complete self, and or that it is a part of your self that you have yet to find ~

without it you would be someone else, yet less. It should instill an eagerness to pay attention and learn what we can from that which is all around us.

Does this ring a bell with any of you? It reminds me of Emerson, but I can't seem to find this paragraph in the book that I have of his lectures, and the last time I googled it, I didn't find what I was looking for.

Re: Ethical Question?

#2

Re: A senior judge during a copyright .....

Jamie Donaldson

>...infringement trial stated that God's creations are considered as being in public domain, so copy on!

Re: Ethical Question?

#3

Re: Ethical Question?

tm

>That is a really interesting question.

It makes me curious about your work and hopeful that I will see

some of it. I think if one recognises the connections and gives credit ( or perhaps an homage ) to the muse, whatever or whomever it may be then there is nothing unethical. At my level of skill and experience I don't presume to call myself an artist, but lots of artists,craft workers, writers, etc., prepare statements and manifestos.

I get ideas about what I might say if I was to write one but never get around to it.

One of many things I like about turning is that it gives me time

to think.

John

Re: Ethical Question?

#4

Re: Ethical Question?

eliot d

>I don't think there is the slightest problem with imitating Nature. There are certainly problems if you work at imitating certain signature pieces associated with some of the better-known turners who have come before us. But it's a difficult issue. For example, most of us don't have any problem with trying to turn Ellsworth-style thin hollow forms through a small opening. This type of vessel seems to have gone into the public domain. But I , for one, would be very self conscious , say, about imitating Molly Winton's running horses -- or trying to duplicate an Art Liestman puzzle form.