Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Skew Honing

Posts

Skew Honing

#1

Skew Honing

Vince

>Because we have been talking about skews the last two days I have to ask a question. Understand that I like my tools very sharp and I sharpen often. I have a DMT card that I hone my skew with many times before grinding as people have mentioned before in a previous thread. I hear about people going through multiple steps (often up to three different steps) that sounds time consuming when they sharpen their skew. Grinder, honing card of some sort then often a leather belt or strop which will leave a superb edge! Please hear me clearly in no way am I knocking anyones sharpening processes! I appreciate and want a superb edge on all my tools. However, it seems within a short period of time (perhaps even seconds) a superb fine edge will often be lost after introducing the skew to your work. My question is if you go through multiple steps to hone one's skew does it keep an edge any longer then simply touching the shew up with a DMT honing card? If not what is the advantage of multiple skew sharpening steps other then having a superb edge for detail or finial cuts? Thanks.

Re: Skew Honing

#2

Re: Skew Honing

Bill Howatt

>My opinion is that extra fiddling around for sharpening turning tools is a waste of time except perhaps for that final cut. I just don't believe micro-edges last that long to make them worth the bother. Of course, if you are having trouble with a particular nasty bit of grain and some special sharpening helps, regardless of how many times you have to do it, then fine. You can't argue with success.

Bill

Re: Skew Honing

#3

Re: Skew Honing

john lucas

>Well I'm not really disagreeing but mine seem to hold an edge for a pretty good while. I sharpen with the DmT and go from blue to green and then to red and then strop. It takes so little time after you get the burr raised from the blue one that I just go through all the steps.

Then after a project or two depending on size, I'll just hone with the ultra fine and sometimes the strop depending on the project. I can do this quite a few times before having to drop down to the fine hone, then ultra fine etc. When I find it necessary to go to the medium hone it's getting to the point that I need to go back to the grinder. I can sharpen it with the medium on up for quite a few times but each time it takes longer because the flat areas are getting larger.

I can tell a difference in the cut after I sharpen each time so it must be doing some good. I can't really tell the difference in the cut going from the strop but it only takes about 4 strokes on each side to make it shave hair so why not. I've already stopped to use the diamond hone anyway.

The difference I see is how easy the cut goes. This lets me relax so my cuts flow better, the cuts are shaped better and I'm less tired. Therefore I've convinced myself it's worth it. Is it really. Don't know for sure but if it makes me feel good I do it.

Re: Skew Honing

#4

Re: Skew Honing

Carole Valentine

>Vince, I use hard leather (glued to a piece of MDF) with green compound on it for touch-ups. I have also used just MDF with the compound on it. I find it easier to swipe the cutting edge on that without mangling it as I do sometimes on a diamond. Most of the time I am only using my skew to make fine detail cuts that cannot be sanded. I touch up often - I am lazy, but I cannot abide a dull skew.

Re: Skew Honing

#5

Garden rake *LINK*

Jerry Hall

>I have come to feel that a skew ground with a 60g wheel is a bit like a garden rake. The whole idea of a skew is crisp, sanding free, polished, precise cuts. The article below is useful to understand and appreciate the principles of sharpening and honing. Honing can be accomplished lots of ways: Toramk, mdf wheels, stones, strops, felt pads. But it should be used appropriately. It is especially so for a skew, and for your finer work. alanlacer .com also has a great article on honing skews.


http://www.fholder.com/Woodturning/sharpen.pdf

Re: Skew Honing

#6

So then, would using the scary sharp system under

Don Henthorn

>water be better than using it dry? (G)

Re: Skew Honing

#7

Re: Sharpening can become another .....

Jamie Donaldson

>...hobby all by itself to some people, or should I use the term anal obsession? There comes a time where tuning the quality of the edge is more important than the actual usage of the tool, so learn to recognize the difference! I sometimes find myself in that catagory of obsessed sharpeners, and can waste a whole day sharpening every cutting tool in the area, including kitchen knives. I long years ago paid some of my lab fees as a pre-med student at Ohio State by sharpening scalpels and other fine edged tools, so I do have a well founded appreciation of a keen edge, but for a specific use. ;-)))

Re: Skew Honing

#8

Re: Garden rake

Carole Valentine

>Maybe it's just me but I feel like a 60 grit wheel turns any tool into a garden rake! I don't even own one. I have an 80 and a 120. When I do put the skew to the grinder, I use the 120.

Re: Skew Honing

#9

Re: Skew Honing

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I'm away from home for a week so I can't accurately quote my source, but I've read that polishing an edge will make it last longer.

Straight from the grinder, you have the burr which, soon after you start cutting, will break off leaving a ragged edge.

Honing removes the burr, and refines the edge.

Polishing refines the edge further, making the point of the edge more "pointy-er." There is also less resistance between the metal and wood, which translates to not only a smoother cut surface but less wear on the cutting edge.

The book I'm pulling this info from (by memory) is by Tubal Cain, part of the Workshop Practice series titled "Hardening, Tempering, and Heat Treating" or something similar. Cain writes about ornamental turners who still use high-carbon steel over HSS for cutting intricate designs where the toolbit has to cut the whole design in one setting without removing the bit. The tool finish is IT, no sanding, and it has to be uniform throughout the process.

I'm not obsessed with having a polished edge, but I do polish my skews for the finish cuts, especially on interupted cuts such as natural edges or inside-out turnings. My polisher is an MDF wheel chucked in a cheap tabletop drillpress and I use the upper face of the wheel charged with white diamond compound. I'm not a production turner so an extra minute of my time doesn't bother me--and using a polished edge is pretty fun actually!

Re: Skew Honing

#10

Re: Skew Honing

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>I've read that polishing an edge will make it last longer.

Tormek makes that claim. It's difficult to test the difference but my subjective feeling is that polishing helps.

JKJ