Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

What would your do......?

Posts

What would your do......?

#1

What would your do......?

joaz

>...if you saw this ring shake in the bottom? This is a very nice piece of maple burl. Roughed down to about an inch thick. As soon as I saw the problem, I hit it with CA and put it aside. I pulled it out the other day and wondered if it would end up on my face shield.

My plan is to keep flooding with CA as I turn and hope for the best.

What would the collective mind out there do??

TIA


img

Re: What would your do......?

#2

Re: What would your do......?

joaz

>second pic.


img

Re: What would your do......?

#3

Re: What would your do......?

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>I would toss it. Too much good lumber in this world to worry about using defective stuff. Just one guy's opinion..

Re: What would your do......?

#4

Re: What would your do......?

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Hi Joaz

My wife still has the bowl I made from the great piece of wood you sent me.

Kind of looks like a face getter to me. Unles it is a special piece of wood winter is comming.

It looks like end grain work with unstable wood. If this be the case the next set of rings will also turn loose.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: What would your do......?

#5

Ric Taylor

Re: What would your do......?

Ric Taylor

>joaz,

I can't help you with the structural strength.

But if it was me, I would brush on a 50/50 coat of lacquer and lacquer thinner all around the crack and let it dry before applying any CA. That will seal the wood and prevent the CA from staining the wood.

Ric

Re: What would your do......?

#6

I'd put it in the burn barrel.

Carole Valentine

>

Re: What would your do......?

#7

Re: What would your do......?

Marvin Ewing

>I have a teeshirt from John Jordan that says on the back "Life's too short to turn crappy wood". I try to live by that - just burn it in the fireplace. That may not be what you want to do but that's what I would do.

Re: What would your do......?

#8

Richard Allen

Re: What would your do......?

Richard Allen

>In the past I have used epoxy to "fix" defects like that. Usually the end result is okay but no where near a satisfying as turning wood without defects. For a couple of year now I tend to toss wood like that. But I learned a lot about epoxy which I might not have learned if I didn't "fix" those defects.

Re: What would your do......?

#9

Re: What would your do......?

Stuart Johnson

>If it is a piece of wood you want to save for some special reason I have had good results using epoxy. If there is nothing special about it the BBQ barrel is a good place.

Re: What would your do......?

#10

Toss it my way

Mike Nelson

>

Re: What would your do......?

#11

Re: What would your do......?

robo hippy

>I gave up repairing pieces like that a few years ago. As a production turner, they aren't worth the effort and the extra time that it takes to repair them. When selling them people notice and want to know if it will hold up, and given the choice, will almost always take a bowl that hasn't been repaired. I really don't know how they will hold up, and would rather sell solid bowls.

robo hippy

Re: What would your do......?

#12

Burn, baby, burn!

Bruce Forrest

>

Re: What would your do......?

#13

"Life's Too Short to Turn Crappy Wood" : )

Ruth Niles

>

Re: What would your do......?

#14

Re: What would your do......?

joaz

>Hi all, being a guy who lives on the edge, I decided to go for it.

Here is the result. Sanded to 120 with mineral spirits. It appears to be a spalt line, not a ring shake.

In the past I think I have burnt pieced to fast and had regrets later. Living in a conifer forest on an island, when I do find some nice burl I really have to look at it three or four times before making the decision to either chuck in the stove or chuck it on the lathe. I'm glad I saved this one.

Thanks all for your input.

Joaz


img

Re: What would your do......?

#15

Re: What would your do......?

Mike Jones

>If I had put all the turned pieces that had defects into the burn pile, I could have heated my shop winter over winter!

I believe that repairing and salvaging work that has defects (either the natural ones or the "other" ones) has taught me many valuable lessons. Not being a production turner, and prone to turning forms other than bowls, biases me to completing what I start, requires some creative thinking, and teaches me how to repair/salvage when the time comes that it is really important.

I think that you are doing the right thing.

Re: What would your do......?

#16

Re: What would your do......?

joaz

>Thanks Mike, I agree. Lucky for me it worked out this time,(see new post with saved bowl.) I try to save as much as I can.

thanks


img

Re: What would your do......?

#17

George Balock

Re: "Life's Too Short to Turn Crappy Wood" : )

George Balock

>Ditto

Re: What would your do......?

#18

Re: What would you do......?

Rick Davenport

>Life may be too short to turn crappy wood, but burl is too beautiful to burn.

Give it a shot and try to save it.

I have found that if there is a story behind a piece, often it has MORE value.

And besides, what's one hour more to find out if you have a piece of wood you can enjoy and be proud of?

Go for it!

(and wear your mask!!!)

R

Re: What would your do......?

#19

Not worth the price of the CA!!!

The MountainMan

>no text