Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

Posts

Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#1

Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

Ron in Drums PA

>Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools are not that special or is it me?

I purchased a #3 and tried it out on 2 boxes.

I found the "sweet spot" while I was cutting the inside on the lid. I was not at all pleased with the cut. I needed to clean it up with my bowl gouge.

I then moved over to the bottom, I had my doubts with the short length and wimpy diameter, but I figured I had nothing to lose at this point. I started out by using a forstner bit to remove most of the waste. Then grabbed the hunter to clean up the sides and bottom. It didn't take long to figure out this was not the right tool for the job. Darn thing started chattering like crazy. I wound up using a half round scraper to clean up the insides and bottom.

I thought it might be me so I tried it on a second box, same results.

Anybody want to buy a slightly used hunter tool?

Complete with wrench, handled, along with extra cutter - both for $75 (thats 25% less than I paid for them)

Shipping included, US Priority Mail (Now how can you beat that!)

USA only (sorry friends)

I accept Visa and MasterCard

email me if interested

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#2

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

john lucas

>Ron Your welcome down for a lesson. There is a learning curve. I use the tool much steeper than Mike shows in the brochure. I get a finish off the tool that is better than I can get with a fresh scraper or bowl gouge in shear scrape. It does take some time to learn the cuts without getting ridges or slight waves. This is because it's cutting and riding the bevel but you it's kind of like a pull cut with the bowl gouge so it's harder to control the smoothness of the cut.

It will also chatter quite a bit if held too flat. Don't give up on it yet. Use it like a hook tool with the edge going from about 1 to 7 oclock.

Most people I've introduced the tool to either cut to fast or have the cutting edge too flat to the work. Once I rotate the tool for them they start getting very good shavings and thier eyes light up.

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#3

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

Carole Valentine

>Ron, I tried a #3 on a very dry, very gnarly and figured piece of walnut at Barb Gill's this week. I was so impressed that I stopped at Woodcraft and bought one on the way home. Last time I visited Barb, we fought with a piece of that same walnut forever and finally resorted to the 60 grit gouge. The hunter left a great finish. However - the one I got does not seem to be nearly as sharp as Barb's, even when I touch the edge with my finger. That's a bit of a puzzlement to me. I am going to fool with it tonight a bit and see if it maybe has a slightly different sweet spot.

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#4

No, not entirely.............

Jake Niedling

>I have had your experience on some dry wood in regards to the vibration. I did change the angle, but just could not find the sweet spot. I have wondered the same as Carol about the sharpness of my tool. I have not tried to rotate the cutter yet. On the demo one I tried at John Lucas's house several months ago was on dry hickory end grain. I was impressed enough after trying it to purchase it. So I have not mastered my Hunter tool yet on dry wood. But don't plan to give up on it yet eiter.

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#5

Ric Taylor

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

Ric Taylor

>Ron,

Don't give up so easily. I'm betting that you just haven't really found the sweet spot yet. Try moving the handle up or down slightly, if you have already tried changing the rotation of the cutting angle.

I turn dry wood almost exclusively, and once I figured it out, haven't had any problems.

Ric

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#6

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

George Van

>There is good advice given above Ron,nothing I could add for use. I have had similar good results.

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#7

Ok, Ok.....

Ron in Drums PA

>I'l give it a try again today.

Since I have a second tip I'll try exchanging them and see what happens.

To Be Continued...

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#8

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

Ron in Drums PA

>I may take you up on that John, thanks.

I my wife has some relatives in your town. They have been asking us down for a visit for some time.

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#9

Re: Ok, Ok.....

john lucas

>One thing I've noticed while playing with them. They feel really sharp right out of the box. After using them you can tell a difference (with your finger anyway) from the unused side and the used side. I rotated one once to see if the cut improves and really couldn't tell any difference. In fact if I take the oldest one I have and run a cut and then try a new on I don't see any quality difference. I think I might feel a little less drag on the new tool but that's really subjective and might just be me wanting it to be sharper.

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#10

Question.

Ron in Drums PA

>How would you compare the #3 to the #4 for inside of boxes?

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#11

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I tried some of John's tools at Indyfest and was impressed enough to decide to make my own #3 and #4. Hopefully, I will have them completed soon and will be able to start using them. John, standing right next to me, was a big help in figuring out the presentation necessary to get a good finish.

keithz

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#12

Are the Hunter cutters available ...

Ed Moore

>from an industrial source? I have the impression that the cutters are available and that they could be purchased from MSC, Enco, or some such place.

If so, what would they be called? And who carries them?

Ed

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#13

Your welcome anytime. Just let me know in advance

john lucas

>

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#14

Re: Question.

john lucas

>The only difference between the #3 and #4 for all practical purposes is the size of the shank. For boxes up to 4" deep the #3 is fine. Much deeper and I would look at the #4. Not for the size of the cutter but for the size and lack of vibration of the shank.

I've used the #1 cutter on a homemade tool shank that is 3/8" and can cut down to 3" or possibly more, without vibration.

The size of the cut will have some affect on all of this. If you tend to hog off wood you are using more of the cutting edge than if you take small bites. This affects not only the cut quality but the vibration in the tool as well. I tend to be aggressive until I get close to the final dimensions. then I slow down and let the tool do the cutting.

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#15

Re: Are the Hunter cutters available ...

john lucas

>Ed I have not seen these cutters in any of my metal catalogs. The ones I've tried do not have the keeness of edge of the hunter tools. The shape is similar but apparently the carbide structure is different and they don't get as sharp. Mike sells the cutters for a very reasonable price considering how long they last. I'm still fairly new using his tools but I think I could easily get several years or more out of the cutters. They hold an edge extraordinarily long. I haven't dulled the first one yet.

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#16

Re: Are the Hunter cutters available ...

Jerry from Lapel In.

>Try http://www.kennametal.com/en/e-catalog/ProductDisplay.jhtml?XMLArg=5934.xml&id=5934&level=&pid=9854467&navAction=push&item=category%3A5934

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#17

Thanks John

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#18

Mike Stafford

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

Mike Stafford

>I have been trying out some Hunter Tools and have turned several boxes and orts bowls. At first I was having some trouble finding the sweet spot, the best angle of attack and how to approach the wood from the bottom center. When I was cutting properly I was getting very good results but the next time I picked up the tool I was unable to immediately start off with good cutting results.

However, the more I have used it, the better my results have become. I have turned boxes in curly maple, shedua, cocobolo, lacewood, chechen and also orts bowls in bocote and walnut. Each piece has gotten much better results as I became more practiced with the tool and I no longer have the starting problems in the center of the bottom.

The Hunter Tools do seem to prefer denser hardwoods over the lighter woods such as walnut and lacewood in my limited experience with the tool. The carbide cutter cuts the wood just fine but seems to cut it a little more unevenly when it is less dense. Again, that may be due to my inexperience with this type of cutter. Until I tried the Hunter Tools I had not ever used a hook type cutter or any other tool similar to this.

I fully intend to make the Hunter Tool one of my "go to" tools.

I like 'em!!!

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#19

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

Jim Terry

>Mike, See you made it home. I brought the Hunter cutter and the shaft I made for it to use in the Elbo this morning to show Bruce.

I used it on the inside of a small hollow form and got ribbons out instead of dust and chips. It did a great job on the end grain. Need to experiment more with it but think it is going to do a great job.

Jim Terry

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#20

My Experience with Hunter Tools....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Some time ago I got a #3 Hunter and used it in my Stewart Omni Pistol. Worked okay but I determined that it wasn't really sharp as advertised. I called Mike Hunter and explained the problem. Mike said that a few cutters had come in not sharp. He very kindly sent me two new cutters along with a 3/16 bit with a #1 cutter for use in my Stewart arm brace tool. The new cutter worked much better, bringing nice curls from the wood. I've found that you do have to experiment with cutting angles etc. to get most out of it. I haven't done much more than play with the #1 cutter, but it certainly makes some smooth cuts in the bottom of a piece. I recently bought a #4 tool and installed a long handle. Haven't used it much yet. Right now I'm turning a cherry hollow form and I'm turning the walls 1/16th in. because I'm going to used my piercing tool on it. I'm going to carefully use the #4 in the bottom to try to get a nice smooth cut. Not much wood left to make any mistakes on. Trouble with using it in a small opening HF is that you can't see what's happening.

I really want to commend Mike Hunter for the great service. Couldn't have been nicer.

Wally

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#21

Thanks, John and Jerry, ...

Ed Moore

>my reasoning was that the cutters from some manufacturers may be sharper than from others.

It is also possible that the cutters need to be sufficiently sharp and don't need to be "scary sharp", as Alan Lacer is wont to say.

I have been using a #4 Hunter to clean up platters. From there I go to a rubber sanding block and the results have been gratifying.

Ed

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools...

#22

Re: Am I the only one who thinks the hunter tools.

Nelson

>Guess the answer to your question is yes!