Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT: Any amateur astronomers?

Posts

OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT: Any amateur astronomers?

steve antonucci

>Ever want to look up at the sky and see what's out there? Me too.

We have an ancient telescope with a wooden tripod (that's how old it is...) that's completely worthless for looking up at the heavens.

I'm wondering how much money you need to spend on a telescope if you want to look up? How about if you want to take pictures? How big does it need to be? I'd like to get a decent sized one, but not one that mounted on the car or weighed a ton.

Any of you stargazers?

Steve

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#2

What's the budget?

Ralph

>You can go cheap, like a good pair of binocs, or.... much more then you spent on the lathe.

I have a 4" MC (Celestron) and a good tripod. Portable with some light gathering power

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#3

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

Clay Foster

>I can make you a heck of a deal on a 12" Cave Astrola if you can come get it.


img

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#4

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

John Kyler

>Sam's club has a nice one for viewing with tripod and tracker for $200.

But to take pictures you will need to roll out more.

I would say $2000 to get started. But that might be a little high as with the new digital cameras for atro use, it might be better now.

Find a good store with good staff and ask questions.

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#5

You want a Dobsonian "Light Bucket"

Ron in Drums PA

>Easy to make.

Google for parts and plans

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Way more than I am looking for -thanks :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#7

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

Andi Wolfe

>Steve, your choices are "refractor" vs "reflector" for telescopes. The optics of a good refractor scope (e.g., Televue) can't be beat for photography, but refractor scopes are much more expensive than reflector scopes. The reflector scopes with large mirrors gather a lot of light and can be useful for good photography if you have a sturdy mount and a way to track accurately. You have to do the mirror and eyepiece alignment correctly for optimal performance. I'd recommend that you look for your local astronomy club and see what used equipment can be purchased. They're usually a helpful bunch of enthusiasts as well. If you're serious (not Sirius. . . ), avoid the department store scopes like the plague. Astromart is an online swap meet and you can often find some great bargains there.

We have a couple of excellent refractor scopes and a Port-a-ball scope with an 8 inch mirror. Our kids are good at using the port-a-ball, so it's an easy one for a starter scope, plus it's very easy to transport and set up.

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#8

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

Rick Allen

>There are sky watchers clubs all over the US. Find one in your local area (usually associated with a college) and go to one or two star gazing outings. You will see a wide variety of telescopes, get great advice and help.

For astrophotography you need an equatorial telescope mount with clock drive.

For viewing a LARGE mirror with a low power eyepiece provides a very comfortable experience for examining the heavens.

Light pollution is the biggest issue for star gazing. We used to be able to see the milky way on most Summer nights in the 50s and 60s. In the 70s we had to go someplace "dark" to see the milky way. In the 80s the milky way became a fairly rare experience. That all has to do with darkness. If you can see the milky way you can use a 10" mirror. Likely as not a 4" mirror and a small aperture eyepiece will resolve as much detail as you can expect to see. A 6" mirror and an slightly larger aperture eyepiece will resolve the same detail but with less eye fatigue. With a larger mirror and a large eyepiece you can examine more of the heavens with a single view, but not more detail. For detail you need dark, can't see your hand in front of your face dark. For that kind of dark a huge mirror and small aperture eyepiece will resolve detail that goes back hundreds of millions of years.

For viewing, not pictures, a Dobson style telescope is a low cost way to see into the past.

Good Luck

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#9

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

Mike Brazeau

>Steve - I have a Russian made 6" Newtonian Reflector complete with heavy duty clock drive mount and three eyepieces. Had lots of fun with it. My son picked it out for me about 8 or 9 years ago and at the time I think it was about $800 Cdn. I made a simple Dobsonian mount for the tube to make it more portable. Even turned an adapter to fit my Coolpix 995 on the eyepiece. Haven't done much lately, but looking forward to getting out for my grandsons in the next few years. Tons of info on the net. Nothing like contemplating the universe on a summer evening with the sound of crickets and tree frogs in the background. Here is a shot of the moon taken 5 years ago with the Coolpix mounted.


img

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#10

Steven Antonucci

Nice picture

steve antonucci

>Is this the type of resolution I should expect from a Dobsonian? It looks pretty good. How about other items in the solar system? I'm guessing the further away, the smaller and harder to resolve?

Steve

P.S. Thanks for the pic and the response...

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#11

Re: Nice picture

Ron in Drums PA

>A Dobsonian telescope is a variation of the Newtonian telescope, so the answer would be yes.

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#12

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

Scott Hogsten

>I have a 12.5 f8 Optical Craftsman that looks really similar to that scope !

Scott

Note: I have more telescopes than chucks and I have a lot of chucks

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#13

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

Scott Hogsten

>Steve I would start here

http://www.skyandtelescope.com/community/organizations

Go visit a local club and spend sometime looking through other peoples scopes first this will hopefully give you a good feel for what you want to do. Like most things in life the price of astronomy can go from cheap to really expensive.

Random thoughts

- Good binoculars are a great start

- Steer clear of the dept store scopes and any scopes advertised by their power.

- Be careful of getting caught in the bigger is better loop,

- The best scope is the one you can setup and use quickly if it takes you two hours to setup it gets old fast.

- You don't need all of the high end gadgets to observe - Simple dobsonians are great

- A small scope of better quality is going to be better than a large scope of mediocre quality.

- Don't over estimate the size of your backseat or the strength of your back

- Remember you can make a very large scope (dobsonian) fit in a small space but where do you carry the ladder

- Be careful or you can end up with one of these in your backyard http://users.adelphia.net/~shogsten/observatory.jpg

That said feel free to pm me and I'm always willing to talk telescopes

Scott

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#14

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Steve,

Caveat: my info is a few years old.

One thing to help decide is to ask the question what do you expect to do the most with a telescope. A good refractor, for example, excels in viewing bright planetary objects. A huge reflector is best for deep space viewing but can be so tall observers often have to stand on a ladder to get to the eyepiece. A schmidt-cassegrain (SC) scope is compact but heavy and is a good compromise for casual-to-semi-serious viewing. A motorized drive is essential for most photography. Even a cheap scope with a good motor drive and a piggyback camera mount is outstanding at comet photography. Do you need portability for travel to dark sky, will you set up on a whim on the back deck, or do you plan to build an observatory in your back yard? If you only view occasionally and have to drive a long way to dark sky, hauling a large scope on a trailer or spending an hour on alignment each time might not be as much an issue. The carrying case for my 8" SC fits nicely in most car trunks.

I recommend Sky & Telescope magazine to get up to speed on what's available and what might best fit your needs. You might find back issues at a library and current stuff on their website.

As for cost, one thing you can do is check the going prices for used scopes on eBay. An older scope might be a great buy.

I've been thinking of selling my 8" Meade Schmidt-Cassegrain. It has a good motor drive and many accessories such as solar filter, camera counterbalence, off-axis guider, Nikon camera body, and other photo gear. It has electronic adjustment, but not the computer controlled alignment and positioning you get in many of today's scopes. I used to do a lot of comet photography, carried my scope to schools for solar eclipse events, and conducted educational nighttime sessions for kids groups. I loaned it to one son a few years ago so I haven't used it lately.

One advantage of a SC scope is it's relatively small size and increased portability compared to a reflector. A motor drive is both an advantage and disadvantage - a very inexpensive non-motorized dobsonian mount, for example, can be quickly slewed by hand to browse around the sky while a motor drive, while more difficult to align precisely, is essential for most photography and makes group viewing easier (set it up and let the kids stand in line for a look)

As for size, the bigger the telescope, the more light you get to your eye letting you see dimmer things. In addition, once you get more light you can start using the color-sensitive cones of your eyes so you can actually see color in things like nebulae. An 8" scope, BTW, is not large enough to see colors - for that you need at least 12", more is better. A 24" scope is a dream to view through. Even a small scope is sufficient for solar viewing (always with a good PRIMARY filter - please don't use an eyepiece filter).

Don't be fooled by competitive claims of high power. My best eyepiece is a low power widefield - brighter, clearer, easier to find things. I mount three eyepieces on a turret so I can switch quickly.

There are two basic ways to take pictures with a telescope. The easiest is to mount a camera "piggyback" on a motorized drive telescope and take pictures through the camera lens. This method easy and quite forgiving but limited to the lens on your camera. Great for huge things like comets. The much more difficult way is to shoot through the telescope lens. This will give you extreme magnification needed for deep space objects and planets but at the expense of increased difficulty in getting sharp pictures. Even focus is an issue in dim light - I installed a special focusing screen in my Nikon body and added a special waist-level viewfinder just for astro photos. In addition, the telescope lens restricts the light of already dim objects such that very long exposures are needed. Even with a motor drive, the entire exposure must be guided by hand or with electronics. A one-hour manually guided exposure from the top of a windy mountain at 3am in the dead of winter can be a challenge for even serious astro buffs. Then you run into things like flim reciprocity failure and thermal noise in digital cameras. The "modern" way to do this is with extremely sensitive CCD cameras guided electronically (and cooled to minimize thermal noise) but that may require a significant budget.

And don't knock a wooden tripod - some astronomers and photographers prefer them. They are much warmer to the hands on cold winter nights (the best viewing), dampen vibration nicely, and don't act as antennas under high-tension power lines! I mention the last due to an experience viewing from a clear-cut powerline strip out in the boonies once. My metal tripod legs felt "funny" to my hands and I noticed tiny sparks between my hands and the metal! The powerlines were inducing enough electrical potential in the vertical legs to make these sparks between the tripod on insulated feet and my grounded body.

JKJ

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#15

Steven Antonucci

Thanks all- you got to love this group!

steve antonucci

>Seems like no matter what the topic, we've got expertise...

From what I can tell, my "casual" use doesn't require too much capital to see what I want to see. I'm going to price out building one and if I do, I'll post it on the turning forum (I'll turn the knobs and stuff...)

I own a truck, so I'll always have a platform and I might even have some "design enhancements" based upon what I've seen on the internet...

Steven

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#16

Brad Vietje

Jorge Castaneda

>Steve,

Brad is quite an astronomer, hope he chimes in, he would know what to reccomend, and if you decide to make your own, he knows that too.

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#17

I'm betting...

GaryG in MD

>...you saw that PBS show a week ago. If you didn't, check with your PBS people, because you'll want to. ...Gary

Re: OT: Any amateur astronomers?

#18

Steven Antonucci

You lose... :-)

steve antonucci

>I actually didn't see the PBS show. What drove this round of interest was the proximity of Mars.

Our family started "stargazing" this summer when the Perseids came through, but throughout the years, we've always gone out for the big events (Haley, Hale Bopp, etc...)

I read an article online that mentioned Mars was going to be in Gemini and pretty easy to pick out. Last night, we were on the deck from 10 to 11:30PM, and we're lucky enough to catch some of the Draconid meteor showers as an added bonus. Around 11:30, I spotted Mars, and desperately wished I had some way of getting a better look.

The Milky Way was obvious about us as we looked up, and I thought "These are the days that my kids will talk about with their kids when they grow up". It is a great way to foster an interest in science and learning without making it feel like a lesson. If I had a telescope, we would have spent hours more searching the skies...

Steven

As always,