Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

the inside of the bowl

Posts

the inside of the bowl

#1

the inside of the bowl

robo hippy

>This is driving me crazy (well, more so than normal), but after turning several thousnad bowls over almost 10 years, my finish cuts on the outside of the bowl are a lot better than the inside cuts. I am stumped. I can use my left hand as a steady rest so that I can make a cut from the rim to the bottom of the bowl. I can get it fairly bumpless. I get little or no tearout. I round off the sharp edge of the bottom of the grind on my gouges. I use a freshly ground gouge for the finish cut. I use my right hand for all the pressure of the cut, and the the left hand does only minimal guiding (thanks to Soren Berger). However, I still get some concentric rings, and the overall end product just isn't as good as the outside cuts. Once in a great while, I get a surface that needs only minimal sanding, but this is the exception, not the rule. Some one help me please!!!!!

robo hippy

Re: the inside of the bowl

#2

Can't help, and I want to know too. Thanks

Barry Irby

>

Re: the inside of the bowl

#3

Re: the inside of the bowl

john lucas

>Sounds like you do everything I do. I find that I get the inside better than the outside. �fter watching Stewart Batty turn I've been paying more attention to letting the wood dictate how fast I feed the cut and it's really paid off in the quality of the finish. The only thing I can figure on why the inside looks better than the outside is my body movement. I can usually make one long smooth pass on the inside as a final cut. At least on thicker bowls. I'll be interested to see what others think on this.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#4

Steven Antonucci

I think it's more than body movement, John

steve antonucci

>I agree that we probably move more freely on the outside than the inside, but I think the biggest challenge is twofold.

One: I turn "lefty", i.e left hand on the toolrest. On the inside, I often am forced to switch hands to "righty" to avoid having my hand/arm contact the spinning bowl.

Two: I am also often somewhat constrained by the handle of the gouge being able to make the turn at the bottom without hitting the bowl.

Obviously, both of these things depend on your bowls shape, but the more undercut the rim is, the bigger I find this problem to be. I typically end up cutting from the middle outward and cleaning up the transition with a scraper.

Steven

Steve

Re: the inside of the bowl

#5

I don't have your problem but....

Cyril Griesbach

>I wish I did.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#6

Re: the inside of the bowl

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>There is a bowl gouge cut that few turners seem to know about. It works very well, especially if you're turning a deep piece and you want to avoid coming in contact with the rim. Start your cut down the side as you as you normally do. When you reach a certain point, experience will tell you when, but it's before the handle of the gouge has passed over the lathe bed, drop the handle a bit and push the tool away from you, with the handle leading. Cut in a rainbow arc to the center of the bowl. It's a very controlled cut and results in a very smooth surface. It's not as difficult as it might sound, but some practice on a scrap piece of wood will help. This cut is helpful when turning on a mini lathe with with only a 10 inch swing. The handle of the gouge never passes over the lathe bed.

Clear as mud?

Wally

Re: the inside of the bowl

#7

Re: the inside of the bowl

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The flute should be up at about 1 o'clock for this cut, and cutting near the nose. Just so the bevel is riding well.

Wally

Re: the inside of the bowl

#8

Re: the inside of the bowl

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>There is another cut that is used only for a final cut. It results in a very smooth surface. I works best if the gouge is ground nearly straight across in a modified fingernail grind. The flute is started straight up, then roll it a bit counter-clockwise so the the bevel is rubbing on the left side near the nose. If you roll it too far, the bevel is unsupported and will dig in. Requires a little practice. I have a 3/8 gouge ground just for this cut.

Wally

Re: the inside of the bowl

#9

Re: I know the solution to this .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... problem! Those concentric rings are compression rings from the heel of your gouge, and they show up after most of the sanding and finishing are done. Grind off or round over the heel of the bevel, leaving only about an 1/8" flat bevel to the cutting edge and the tool will go around the radius of the curve without dragging and crushing the fibers. I have a seperate 3/8" gouge for such finish cut occasions, and I actually grind a secondary bevel on all my gouges to reduce the chances of this occurring. Another example of O'Tool's Law!

Re: the inside of the bowl

#10

Re: I know the solution to this .....

john lucas

>Jamie That's what I thought at first but he says he grinds the sharp edge of the bottom of the bevel. I don't really grind a secondary bevel, it's more of a random grind that softens the edge. Some people recommend putting a block in the Oneway jig to form the second bevel but I find this just creates 2 sharp edges. My method is to just hit it by eye. This produces a random shaped soft shoulder that eliminates the compression rings that Jamie is talking about.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#11

Re: the inside of the bowl

gary s clarke

>try the tool called the eliminator, works well for me. Maybe you could borrow one to try it out before you purchase one.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#12

Dick Hines

Re: the inside of the bowl

Dick Hines

>I alwasy make a sheer cut with the left flute of the bowl gouge starting at the bottom all the way rim. It need to be a very light cut because it the bowl sides are thin you will get a lot of chatter. This cut will get most of the rings and unevenest out.

Is unevenest a word?

Re: the inside of the bowl

#13

Re: the inside of the bowl

eliot d

>This is the method taught by David Ellsworth. But one has to be careful with it. One fellow in the class blew up two bowls.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#14

Steven Antonucci

Ellsworth called it the Raffan Upper Cut

steve antonucci

>

Re: the inside of the bowl

#15

Re: the inside of the bowl

Tommy Holmes

>Sure, unevenest is a word and so is alwasy. ;)

Re: the inside of the bowl

#16

Re: the inside of the bowl

don lewonczyk

>Wize Giy! DonL

Re: the inside of the bowl

#17

Re: Ellsworth called it the Raffan Upper Cut

john lucas

>Mark Baker and I discussed a cut we have played with that is the same cutting edge orientation. We used the rough out gouge upside down with the left flute cutting like a skew. On the inside of the bowl that is. This isn't as scary as it sounds but probably not for the beginner

It's really similar to what I now use with the stewart Batty grind. I'm cutting with the tip and it's ground at 40 degrees. Since the tip is gently rounded it cuts with just about the same action of the wood passing almost vertical across the cutting edge. This is an extremely smooth cut but you have to learn to let the wood tell you how fast to cut. If you push too hard you loose the clean cut.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#18

Re: Beware the Raffin Upper Cut- it....

Jamie Donaldson

>...should not be attempted by mere mortals! Ya' ain't seen a real catch til' ya' seen one a these!! And don't ask me how I learned this lesson!! :-O

Re: the inside of the bowl

#19

Re: the inside of the bowl

russ Fairfield

>We all have the same problem. The only difference is that it is worse for some of us than others. Why should expect to be any different??

Re: the inside of the bowl

#20

Re:Seriously

russ Fairfield

>Go back to the basics. It's called riding the bevel, and having the bevel on the wood right behind the cutting edge. The problem is that we are usually riding on the heel of the bevel somewhere behind the cutting edge, and not AT the cutting edge.

The case can be made for using a convex profile for the bevel on a gouge that is used on the inside of the bowl because the curve matches that of the inside of the bowl and it is easy to keep the bevel supporting the wood AT the cut and not somewhere behind it.

Regardless of how we grind the bevel, I could make a case for using more than one gouge with different angles as we go down the side, through the transition, and across the bottom of the bowl. Each tool can be ground so it is possible to always keep the bevel immediately behind the cutting edge on the wood.

Our problem is that we have an obsession to do everything with only one bowl gouge, and we end up using a tool that is a compromise. This one-tool-fits-all will be best suited for only one area of the bowl, and sometimes not well suited for any area of the bowl; and we have to take what we get on the wood surface. Have you ever noticed that many of the famous bowl turners use a set of gouges to turn a bowl, and not just one gouge for everything??

And, then there will always be the piece of wood that cannot be cut well with any tool.

We

Re: the inside of the bowl

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: I know the solution to this .....

keith tompkins

>I agree Jamie...also, the heel will rub, and tend to lift the cutting edge away from the cut, acting like a lever.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#22

Continental grind?

Mike Brazeau

>Wally - is this was the Brits refer to as the Continental Grind? Last year I heard at least three demonstrators mention use of that grind and now have a couple of gouges ground that way. Makes a great finishing cut and allows a nice sweep around the bottom curve into the center of the bowl. Tried to find an image but no luck. Much like the factory grind out of Sheffield plants, but wings pared back somewhat? Has a very short bevel.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#23

Re: Continental grind?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Mike, I haven't heard of the grind being called a continental grind. Sounds like a good grind to make that cut though. Some of the turners in the UK still use a bowl gouge ground square across. When the bowl gouge first came out in the US in the early 80's they were all ground square across like a roughing gouge. That was the way everybody used them until someone came up with the idea of a fingernail grind. The side grind didn't show up until later when Ellsworth and Liam O'Neil pioneered it.

Wally

Re: the inside of the bowl

#24

Re:Seriously

Bill Neddow

>Well said, Russ.

Re: the inside of the bowl

#25

Re: the inside of the bowl

RonZ

>I'm sure you know about fluid body movement so I'll leave that out. I use two ways depending on my patience and the wood. The first way is with a heavy duty bowl scraper with the handle droppped down. This can be seen by Del Stubbs in his vidio on bowl turning. The other method I use is a 1/4" bowl gouge grpund at about 45deg with a second bevel to allow movement. This can be seen by Jimmy Clewes in his video 'Turn it on'.

There is nothing new under the sun. =o)