Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

Posts

Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#1

Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Am I crazy to buy a big lathe as my first lathe? I've always wanted to get into turning, but I'm not particularly interested in bowls. My primary interest is furniture building, so I'd probably mostly do spindle turning, pens, parts for furniture, etc. I'd like to have a lathe with an indexing head.

Anyway, I've got an opportunity to buy a General 260-20 VS with a bunch of faceplates, a nova or oneway chuck (I'm not sure which), two tool-rests, a half-dozen gouges, and a bunch of wood blanks for $2500 CDN. That's a lot of money for me. The thing is in great shape and is available at 50% of the new cost.

I know that a stretched mini lathe would do the job for 90% of what I want to do (at half the cost), but that big General lathe has always caught my eye. I'm tight for room in my shop and the big General will take a lot of room. Is it possible to do pen work on a big lathe like this?

I've searched the archives, and for the most part people seem to recommend going for the bigger lathe since you'll probably upgrade later anyway. It's a lot of money and a lot of room.

Any advice you can share?

Thanks,

Steven

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#2

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

Bill McWhirter

>"Quality remains long after price is forgotten."

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#3

You're asking us?????

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca.

>I'm an advanced beginner turner (how's that for padding my turning resume?) and I purchased a used PM 3250 a few months ago. So far I've only turned a few magic wands and a small walnut box on it. I have some larger pieces of wood to turn, but let's just say that some (2) of my critical body parts haven't grown in proportion to the size required for the task.

I believe getting the larger lathe is a wise decision as they are truely better to use than making do with an underpowered, cramped lathe. I like the fact that I have more room to move the lathe tool handles without bumping into the bed. The electronic VS feature is great.

Good luck with your decision.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#4

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

john lucas

>There is one major difference between the General and the Jet mini. You can turn big things on the General if necessary. I think you'll also find the lack of vibration on the big machine will make it much more enjoyable to turn even moderate sized pieces. There are only a few negatives to a big lathe vs a small lathe. One of course is size and space needed to set the machine. The other is moving the tool rest and tailstock. I find the mini lathe much more pleasant for small items just because moving the tool rest and tailstock is so much easier. This is a small thing and I still turn most of my work on the Big Powermatic.

I think you'll like the General.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#5

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

Don in Central Illinois

>I read on this forum sometime ago that you can always turn small stuff on a big lathe but you can't turn big stuff on a small lathe.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#6

Ab-so-looootly

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>But, then most all of us are nuts (shoving razor sharp steel into spinning pieces of tree trunks? Ya Think??).

At that price, if you don't like it, you'll be able to sell the rig for at least as much (if not more) than you paid for it.

Warning. Once you allow Ol' Charybdis the slightest taste of your toe, there's no telling what you'll "want" to do, but resistance will, by that time, be futile.

Buy the lathe, find a local mentor/teacher to get you started properly, and then start thinking about which tools you're going to sell. A table saw still makes a good countertop.

|;-}}}

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#7

Re: Starting with a quality lathe....

Jamie Donaldson

>....like the General saves the inevitable and expensive evolution upward from a Jet mini. A good lathe does help you become a better turner, so jump on that deal ASAP!

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#8

Only a little.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I'm currently waiting for my fourth lathe, a Robust 25" which will replace my Conover (16"). I've turned a lot of small stuff on my Conover, but don't turn any large stuff on my Jet Mini.

A bigger lathe is much more versatile than a small lathe. A big lathe is also much more stable.

That sounds like a bargain. If you can afford it, I'd go for it.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#9

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

Binen

>If you can afford the General 260-20 VS then by all means buy it. With good care it should hold its value for many years to come. At worst you will find you do not enjoy or need it and sell it for what you paid.

Binen

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#10

Now wait a minute...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>You still need flat-work tools to build those essential support items like:

Turning tool holders

Storage for chucks and chuck jaw sets

Sandpaper dispensers

Drying racks for green wood

Display shelves / cabinets

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#11

You would be crazy not to buy a big lathe?

russ Fairfield

>But that's a personal opinion.

You can always turn small things on a big lathe, but you can never turn big things on a small lathe. Besides that the larger lathe will make your spindle turning easier because the weight and rigidity will result in less vibration. It can be done, but a 30" long table leg is a big load for a Mini lathe with extentions, and an experience you will not want to repeat; but the General will handle it with ease.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#12

Steven Antonucci

I know a lot of turners that used to do flatwork

steve antonucci

>but no flatworkers that used to be turners...

As others have said, buy the lathe.

Steven

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#13

I knew I shouldn't have asked here

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I knew that there would be little chance of getting dissenting opinions - preaching from the converted etc., etc.,....or is it rationalizing your own addiction?

I went and took a look at a new General to remind myself of the size. It actually consumes less footprint that I expected.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#14

No Problem

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Just gotta remember to clear the stuff off the TS before using it to cut wood. I did say it makes a handy storage space, right? It's also good for segmenting, and, with and extension table installed, seats 6 nicely for those impromptue shop dinners when friends drop by.

|;-}}}}

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#15

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Lots of people, including myself, first bought a small/inexpensive lathe then had to get a better one. I wish I'd had the foresight to but the better one to start. JKJ

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#16

Re: I knew I shouldn't have asked here

Atwerz

>See, you are already talking yourself into buying it.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#17

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

Bill Howatt

>Steven,

Is it mechanical VS or electronic variable-speed?

I have the 260-20 with electronic variable speed. wonderful smooth piece of equipment. I never turned a pen until I got the General and it works beautifully - pen looks a little silly mounted on it though :).

The other thing that is nice about a large lathe is that you can mount a large blank on it and most likely still have plenty of room under the blank to mount a steady or slide the banjo underneath it if desired.

I'm only a hobby turner but I consider it money well spent. Now my usual story to rationalize the money:

When I was moving it into my basement shop with the help of my friend, I said it sure was a lot of money for a hobby. I paid a lot closer to the list than you did. He said that the cost was nothing compared to his last new snowmobile and trailer and they would be reduced to little value in a few years. Think about the cost of golf club memberships, a 2-week cruise and the lathe; given its life and resale value is a bargain. It also is very likely enough lathe to last you forever.

Good luck,

Bill

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#18

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

eaglesc

>I am going to take a line from your original post.

" I've always wanted to get into turning, but I'm not particularly interested in bowls."

I have been using a lathe for better than 3 years.

I started with a Jet mini and now still use that plus two Rikons.

I too have never been interested in turning bowls.

Nothing wrong with them just have no interest.

I would rather have a fourth mini lathe than a larger one.

Based on the expense both money and footprint, I wouldn't let anyone talk me into buying more tool than I need just because they think it is a tool I MAY may eventually want.

Your money, your shop, your footprint.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#19

Steve Kubien

Go for it because...

Steve Kubien

>...you will likely want to upgrade soon anyway. That General has got all of the power you could want so that if you choose to do large pedestal tables (8" plus in diameter), you're covered. Try doing that on an extended mini lathe but be sure to video tape it because it will be funny if no one gets hurt.

I kept my mini lathe after getting a larger Nova because I figured I would use it eventually for smaller stuff. I MUCH prefer doing pens and such on the big lathe.

Have fun

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#20

Go for it

Mike Brazeau

>Sounds like the General would be a good lathe for you and price sounds not bad. It is a standard for wood shops and well suited to hobbiest too. With a big lathe, big or small, you can turn them all.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#21

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Steve, I have the same General lathe and love it. I started with a mini lathe and learned how to turn on it...well sort of learned. Then I wanted to make larger stuff (bowls) and decided to buy a bigger lathe. I wanted one that wouldn't leave me wanting more or something different in a couple of years. I did a lot of research on many different lathes and found that the General fit my turning and my budget and I've never been sorry for buying it. I love it 6 years later. It's been sort of a love affair with the General you could say :)

Buy the lathe and all the goodies and then come back and do a maximous gloat to all of us! That is a great deal on a fantastic lathe.

Jennifer

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

keith tompkins

>I've got the same General as well. After four years of continuous duty, I like it as much as the day I got it. It's actually easier to turn small items on a big lathe than a small one. I have a Rikon mini that I use for demonstration purposes, otherwise it sits idle.

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#23

Re: Somebody shoot this guy! ....

Allen Neighbors

>Just kidding... :o)

Truly, I've turned more the last two months on my little Vicmarc VL100 than I have on my Oneway 1640. But... I sure am glad I have the Oneway for the big stuff!!! :-)

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#24

Just has to be a responsible, sensible, mature,

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca.

>Guy in the bunch....sigh. Uh, did I mention fantastic heirloom penturner too?

Re: Am I crazy to buy a big lathe?

#25

Re: I know that's true!! :)

Allen Neighbors

>I love you're pens, too, eagle!!