Re: Rental Videos
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>I've got two videos that are in the middle of this whole thing, and I was in the big email exchange between a lot of the video makers. I have several thoughts on the issue.
First, what Smartflix is doing is legal. It is legal in the US to buy copies and rent those copies out for private viewing. I do not know about copying - i.e. I do not know if they are copying the videos. I would suspect they are not. All it would take would be one person to turn them over to the law to create more trouble than it would be worth.
Second, I do know there are people out there who bootleg my videos as well as those of others. I knew that would happen before I made them, but I made the choice to go ahead and make them anyway. I am glad that I did. If someone thinks that people aren't making illegal copies, just look at the attitudes displayed here on the web, from those who seem to think it is somehow shameful or dishonest to charge for information of any kind. I was slammed on another forum because I was in the filthy business of charging for my work - like somehow the guy deserved it for free, and I should be making and distributing these things for the fun of it. This might be a good time to poke a hole in that nonsensical perception that all turners are good and true people who would never do anything wrong or deceitful. Really? Turners are people just like everyone else.
Some of the big names really got their panties in a bunch about the loss of revenue. One guy lamented that he really enjoyed "sharing", but if someone else was going to cut into his profits, he might not be inclined to "share" anymore. Hint: this is not sharing, it is selling. Sharing is when you do it for free. I happen to do a lot of that, here, in my shop, when I am on the road, etc. But making and selling videos is business. I have made the business decision that it is going to be profitable for me to make and sell these things. So far it is working.
I have had enough people write or call me to ask about lessons as a result of watching the videos to know that there is as much entertainment in them as there is knowledge. What do I mean by that? Simply this. While knowledge is presented, there is no feedback available, and as good as a video might be, it does not even come close to that one on one interaction. So while people gain some of my knowledge, they do not gain my feedback unless we get together one way or another, and that is a very attractive secondary benefit to these things.
When it comes to AAW chapters and my interactions with the various groups, overall my experience has been very good. I don't have a lot of patience with those with their hands out for free or discounted videos. After all, they are obtaining them to lend them for free to their members. Admittedly it may be an avenue for more sales, and I know of a few cases where it was, but in most cases people are happy to borrow and return it. Again, I am sure in at least a few cases people are even happier to copy it for their own use. It is illegal and immoral, but it is the way life is. Those people have bigger problems with their lives than I have with losing a few bucks on a sale. But when I appear at a club, I have a fistful of videos with me, and in almost every case I go home with a lot less than I brought.
To conclude, while it may not be an ideal situation, it is the situation with which we have to deal. It could be worse. I am very grateful for those who have purchased my videos, and I spend many hours every week talking on the phone or exchanging emails with those who have. Maybe even one or two copiers have gotten some more free advice out of me, but it has not diminished the quality of my own life. People continue to buy mine, enough so that there is a good chance there will be a third. When that happens, I suppose Smartflix will want copies of it too. There is a review on Smartflix's own website of my video where the person rented it and liked it enough to buy their own. That kind of copying is something I would be glad to see!
Bill