Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Rental Videos *LINK*

Posts

Rental Videos *LINK*

#1

Rental Videos *LINK*

Tommy Holmes

>Thought I'd let those who do not know that a lot of turning videos are available for rent at smartflix. In addition to turning vidoes they have videos on a wide range of arts, crafts and hobbies. I have been happy with their selection and service although I have not found every video that I've looked for.

I'm sure the "stars" of these videos are paid royalties so there should not be a moral conflict.

Just a satisfied customer.......


Rental Turning Videos

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#2

Compensation is an unresolved problem

russ Fairfield

>None of the "stars" are getting anything in the way of royalties or anything else from Smartflix. They buy their videos on the open market and offer them for rent without any contract or compensation to the author.

There was a recent lengthy e-mail exchange among the authors of woodturning videos. Many of them weren't aware their videos were being rented until a link to Smartflix was posted on another Internet woodturning forum, or they received the initial e-mail. The concensus was that Smartflix was acting in an unethical manner in the least, at the worst they were or had been making copies in violation of copyright issues, that none of us could affort copying protection on our videos, and that Smartflix had a cavalier "so sue me" attitude about it all. Everyone suspects that it is hurting their video sales, but nobody has a fix on the numbers, and several said they will no longer be making videos because of it.

Nobody is happy, and the issue remains unresolved. There was a concensus that there isn't enough money involved to make it worth persuing the legal issues, but nobody knows for sure, and I suspect that somebody is investigating the issue. We haven't heard the last of this.

The most flagrant copiers of videos have always been the members of AAW Chapters, and other individuals who buy one copy and then make several copies for their friends. Some of them have the audacity to complain when their copy of a copy they got from a friend has a glitch, and they expect me to send them a new replacement DVD.

This copying issue was a concern before I made my first video, but I accept it as a part of the landscape and that the market of honest people was big enough to make the videos worthwhile. The copiers will always be there, but Smarflix has made it easier and less expensive for them.

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#3

I didn't know this.

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca.

>My wife rented a SmartFlix video and we thought that it was a good idea and neat service. Now that I find out that you guys, and the other craftspeople, aren't getting anything from it we won't continue renting from them.

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#4

Re: Compensation is an unresolved problem

Tommy Holmes

>Russ, I have to apologize to you and all the other authors of these videos for renting from Smartflix and especially now for advertising for them. I am gullible enough to believe that as open and visible as Smartflix is that it was legal and ethical and that compensation would have been being paid to all of you.

I have rented these videos because I admire and respect the turners teaching on them and certainly think you deserve compensation for your years of learning, willingness and ability to teach and expense of making the videos.

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#5

Re:This is an interesting problem....

Jamie Donaldson

>... which I had no knowledge of until today, and I have just emailed my copyright attorney for his evaluation of the practice. I am a big advocate of intellectual property rights, especially where artists are concerned. The deep pockets defense shouldn't prevail!

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#6

Afraid I'm Guilty Too..

Ron McKinley

>I've rented DVDs from them twice and realized that the ones I rented were only available on VHS in the open market so I assumed they had obtained the rights to reformat them to DVD. Nope. No more. Thanks for bringing that to our attention......Ron

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#7

Steven Antonucci

Is this any worse than a club buying them?

steve antonucci

>I think everyone agrees that the practice of making illegal copies for distribution is bad, but we all rent videos legally. Most of the T&C's are around private viewing in a home, and I'm guessing these guys are compliant with standard business practices. For the same reason I rented "RoboCop II" (it wasn't good enough to buy), I might want to rent a video first. If it's as good as "Star Wars", I'd add it to my collection.

I know that every club buys a video library for rent to the membership, which cuts into the sales to individuals (or does it?). Is the practice of renting these woodturning videos what people are upset over or is it the fact that Smartflix receives payment that doesn't trickle down?

Forgetting the copyright issues they might have (which they should be prosecuted for to the fullest extent for any violations they may have). They aren't doing anything different than your local club or your woodworking friends that lend you a tape or DVD except making a profit, and I'm unaware of that being illegal in this case.

If people want to change the way DVD's are licensed (to an individual, not the possessor of the media) then that's another issue, but that's not how it works. Expect to buy every DVD from now on if you think it's fair.

Steven

Who sees nothing at all wrong with renting DVD's, but has never rented one on woodturning from Smartflix

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#8

Re: Steve- that "except making....

Jamie Donaldson

>...a profit" is the big deal. If the holders of intellectual property rights are not compensated for their work, ask yourself how you could continue working without a paycheck.

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#9

Steven Antonucci

So no one cares about the opportunity loss?

steve antonucci

>Sharing isn't the issue then, it's the fact that they charge for the video.

You don't see an issue with clubs buying the videos and distributing them for free to prospective customers and limiting sales opportunities for the video maker? Seems to me that is even worse than someone renting it where there is a degree of separation from the perpetrator.

At least the Smartflix guys are "capitalists" with probably very little interest in the woodturning community. The club libraries seem to me to be a case of the pot calling the kettle black. Charge for membership to the club, get free access to our videos...

If you want to make something of value (like a DVD) and expect people to be honorable and pay you for your expertise if they watch your video, you're sadly mistaken. A basic tenet is to start with a Terms of Use clause to be included and prominently displayed. From there, let's talk about copy protection next-even though it's easily defeatable. Both of these things show commitment to making a product.

In today's day and age, it's probably a much better idea to distribute content via a secure server and streaming technology like on the Woodworking Channel. You can control the login, validate IP's to make sure people aren't sharing passwords in a club, prevent copying altogether because there is no DVD.

Sharing digital content is no different than if your library had the video. Someone is always charging something for something. People will share unless you do something preventative. Copying is wrong, but how many of the folks here have pirated software running that they "borrowed from the office"?

Smartflix ain't the source of the problem...

Steven

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#10

Question......................

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>Russ, how does the compensation issue work when I check out a tape/DVD from a library? I have our library to buy woodturning DVDs and books (and they have complied)for the patrons to check out.

Gil

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#11

The way I see it, for what it's worth

Robert Henderson

>1. The value of video (in any format) of woodworking experts showing us how to do things cannot be overestimated - to us and to future generations.

2. These videos are not produced in such numbers that we will ever see them in the discount bin at Walmart. That means that there is not a lot of profit being made by the creators of such videos.

Therefore, copyright law and ethics aside, it behooves us to avoid doing anything that might discourage future production.

Yes, it is sometimes hard to judge the quality of a video without seeing it. Read a review here or elsewhere, watch it at a friends, ask the staff at Rockler to throw it in their machine so you can take a look. There are ways to get a fairly good idea of the content and production values before you buy. But, for your own future sake as well as ours, do BUY and don't COPY and don't patronize those that do copy.

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#12

Re: Rental Videos

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I've got two videos that are in the middle of this whole thing, and I was in the big email exchange between a lot of the video makers. I have several thoughts on the issue.

First, what Smartflix is doing is legal. It is legal in the US to buy copies and rent those copies out for private viewing. I do not know about copying - i.e. I do not know if they are copying the videos. I would suspect they are not. All it would take would be one person to turn them over to the law to create more trouble than it would be worth.

Second, I do know there are people out there who bootleg my videos as well as those of others. I knew that would happen before I made them, but I made the choice to go ahead and make them anyway. I am glad that I did. If someone thinks that people aren't making illegal copies, just look at the attitudes displayed here on the web, from those who seem to think it is somehow shameful or dishonest to charge for information of any kind. I was slammed on another forum because I was in the filthy business of charging for my work - like somehow the guy deserved it for free, and I should be making and distributing these things for the fun of it. This might be a good time to poke a hole in that nonsensical perception that all turners are good and true people who would never do anything wrong or deceitful. Really? Turners are people just like everyone else.

Some of the big names really got their panties in a bunch about the loss of revenue. One guy lamented that he really enjoyed "sharing", but if someone else was going to cut into his profits, he might not be inclined to "share" anymore. Hint: this is not sharing, it is selling. Sharing is when you do it for free. I happen to do a lot of that, here, in my shop, when I am on the road, etc. But making and selling videos is business. I have made the business decision that it is going to be profitable for me to make and sell these things. So far it is working.

I have had enough people write or call me to ask about lessons as a result of watching the videos to know that there is as much entertainment in them as there is knowledge. What do I mean by that? Simply this. While knowledge is presented, there is no feedback available, and as good as a video might be, it does not even come close to that one on one interaction. So while people gain some of my knowledge, they do not gain my feedback unless we get together one way or another, and that is a very attractive secondary benefit to these things.

When it comes to AAW chapters and my interactions with the various groups, overall my experience has been very good. I don't have a lot of patience with those with their hands out for free or discounted videos. After all, they are obtaining them to lend them for free to their members. Admittedly it may be an avenue for more sales, and I know of a few cases where it was, but in most cases people are happy to borrow and return it. Again, I am sure in at least a few cases people are even happier to copy it for their own use. It is illegal and immoral, but it is the way life is. Those people have bigger problems with their lives than I have with losing a few bucks on a sale. But when I appear at a club, I have a fistful of videos with me, and in almost every case I go home with a lot less than I brought.

To conclude, while it may not be an ideal situation, it is the situation with which we have to deal. It could be worse. I am very grateful for those who have purchased my videos, and I spend many hours every week talking on the phone or exchanging emails with those who have. Maybe even one or two copiers have gotten some more free advice out of me, but it has not diminished the quality of my own life. People continue to buy mine, enough so that there is a good chance there will be a third. When that happens, I suppose Smartflix will want copies of it too. There is a review on Smartflix's own website of my video where the person rented it and liked it enough to buy their own. That kind of copying is something I would be glad to see!

Bill

Re: Rental Videos *LINK*

#13

Steven Antonucci

Very well said.

steve antonucci

>From my early days in IT, there was always a mentality that copying software was a victimless crime. Microsoft didn't need the money, and you would never pay $700 for a copy of Office, so it was ok to copy it. Back then, there were fewer and fewer authors of digital content.

It's great to see attitudes changing towards the subject, interspersed with a dose of reality. People ARE people, and until it is common belief that copying is immoral, it will go on.

Thanks for the sanity, Bill.

Steve