Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

help please - Iles vs Taylor

Posts

help please - Iles vs Taylor

#1

ebd

help please - Iles vs Taylor

ebd

>Anyone who has used both - which is your preference?

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#2

May I suggest the next level *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>of tools?

The A-11 steel tool made locally in Ohio. The unhandled Thompson Tools.

They are made with the same technology as the original Jerry Glaser tools which cost 3 to 4 times more.

http://www.cuttingedgetools.com/Onlinecat.htm/WebCatalog/GlaserHiTec.htm

Gordon

No relationship other than one of the growing satisfied customers.


Thompson Tools

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#3

I agree!

GaryG in MD

>My go-to bowl gouge is a Doug Thompson 5/8". I have it in a (green) Bosch handle weighted with steel shot. Shweet. I love it. ...Gary

...just another happy customer...

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#4

Re: I agree!

john lucas

>I just spent the whole day turning in my shop and except for the skew and parting tool I used nothing but the Thompson bowl and detail gouges. I'm getting to the point that my other tools just sit there. I don't have any Ashly Iles tools but have several Henry Taylor. Now that I have the Thompson bowl gouger my HT gouge is just used as backup.

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#5

Re: I agree!

Allen Neighbors

>My Thompsons are the ones I grab first. Now I want one of his skews!

Can't get any better gouges... anywhere. JMEO. :-)

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#6

Re: May I suggest the next level

Fog Tanner

>I have to agree with Gordon. I have a number of the Thompson tools, including several of the 5/8" and 1/2" bowl gouges, sveral of the spindle gouges - both the "regular" and detail varity in 1/2" and 3/8". Along with that I have the 3/8", 1/2" and 3/4" skew chisels. Along with that I have multiples (at least 2-4 of each) of all those in the Henry Taylor line. The only one of the Taylors I use these days are those tools which have a specialized grind on them and for which I have not gotten a Thompson tool to replace them with.

And the price of the Thompson tools is in some/most cases lower than the same one from Taylor. Our club has bought quite a few of the Thompson tools so far. Most for personal use, but some went to our club retreat raffel. No one has had a bad expereince with these tools, I would have known as I was the one that handled the club orders. That really is the cheapest way to go, as it saves on shipping on both ends and knocks a few bucks off the price of each tool when you split the cost.

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#7

I AGREE

Curt Stivison

>

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#8

All of you are to good

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Over the past 8 months I'm still in awe over the comments from everyone... I have to thank each and everyone!

I have the same offer for everyone, use it and if you don't like it for any reason I'll buy it back (except if the flute is to short) Find someone else to give you the offer... no company will. I don't do this for a living thank goodness and it's a enjoyable thing to do.

Sorry I didn't mean to highjack your post.

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#9

Dick Hines

Re: All of you are to good

Dick Hines

>I have 5 of Doug's tools and he is not getting a single one back.

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#10

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

Karen F.

>I agree too. Go for the Thompson Tools. I have two that I use with Oneway Handles. Now I need a skew next:)

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#11

Bill Blasic

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

Bill Blasic

>I have five of Dougs tools and will be getting at least three more in Cincinnati at Turning 2007, leaving in nine days, can't wait! Kinda funny as I was just telling Bill Noce the other day that I'm going to get rid of all the non Thompson tools because I find myself going to just these tools anymore, they are that good! (I won't be getting rid of any tools - Tool Junkie:>)

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#12

Re: May I suggest the next level

Bill Neddow

>I do about 90 per cent of my turning with a 9/8 inch bowl gouge and have a "stable" of them -- at least one of just about every brand out there. I sharpen them in batches, and then turn until they are all dull.

A few months ago I broke down and bought another gouge -- the Thompson 5/8 inch bowl gouge (as if I need another!) Big mistake. I reach for it first every time. The edge really lasts. I am never going to wear out all the other brands because I do not use them. In fact, I plan on getting a couple more of Doug's bowl gouges plus a detail gouge when I see him at Turning 2007 in a few weeks.

I have had a personal frustration and made a few public "rants" about tool companies in the past. One thing I could never understand is why they insisted in taking inferior steel (M2 or less), cryo treating it and trying to sell it as the greatest thing that was ever invented. I guess marketing and cost cutting overcomes logic. What Doug has done is the logical thing -- take the BEST steel and cryo treat it. And BOY, does this combination ever work!

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#13

ebd

Iles vs Taylor - should have been more specific

ebd

>First - THANK YOU ALL for such quick responses!

Second - Sorry. I should have included some information behind my request for comments. I've had a Taylor Diamic 1 1/4" forged/continental gouge for some time and I love it. It is massivly thick (perhaps 3/8"). It is getting a little shorter and I want to buy a backup but in to see if there might be other options I came across Iles tools. They are the only toolmaker that looks to have something similar. Sorby has continental gouges, but only up to 1" and they appear to be way thin compared to the Taylor. Maybe the Ills are too, I'd have to check. Anyway, Thompson Tools doesn't make a forged gouge. Unfortunatly for me.

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#14

Re: Iles vs Taylor - should have been more specifi

Fog Tanner

>Doug in fact does make a 1" "forged" style gouge. It is great for removing a lot of wood. It is milled from bar stock, but has a shallow flute much like the forged gouges. It holds an edge the same as the rest of his gouges. It has a 3/4" shank, so it will fit in my Kelton 17" steel handel. It would be worth contacting Doug to see if he has any of these left.

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#15

Re: Iles vs Taylor - should have been more specifi

Gordon Seto

>I can't remember when was the last time so many times I was agreed on, definitely not in my house. LOL!

Is this gouge you are referring to? It was on a Kelton Ultimate handle. You will have to live long enough to wear out this tool.

Gordon


img

Re: help please - Iles vs Taylor

#16

Re: Iles vs Taylor - should have been more specifi

Fog Tanner

>Gordon,

That looks like it, except for the handle - mine is just the straight steel handle that came with my McNaughton tools. It was intimidating at first, but it is a joy to use on large bowls.

Fog