Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

opinions please -- tool handles

Posts

opinions please -- tool handles

#1

opinions please -- tool handles

GaryG in MD

>Background first -- I'm just an amateur -- I make stuff to keep or give away to "lucky" people as gifts. No pretentions, galleries, etc. Just for fun, but, hopefully, quality work that I can be proud of.

I got more wood than I could deal with this spring when some itinerant tree whackers came through the neighborhood. I wasn't able to get to it all in a timely manner, and some of it got the dreaded black mold (or whatever you call it). Other than that, the wood is sound. I roughed a piece (silver maple) into an 11+ inch bowl with the result in the photo. The sap wood is mostly gray, as I expected it would be. The piece has some spalt on the outside and a funky branch inclusion on the inside. I would like to save it.

My question is, how bad is that -- to the average non-turner and to you as a turner? If I finish it normally with, say, Watco, the gray areas will be -- gray. One could say that's just more "nature"; after all, we accept things like worm holes and spalt, so why not mold? Others, I'm sure, will turn up their noses and say "yuk; dirty; unacceptable". I've been going back and forth and can't decide -- hence this post. I would like to get a feeling about where the balance of opinions is. On a scale from "who cares?" to "trash it!", where does that fit on your personal scale?

I know I can Chlorox it and make a lot of it go away, but I'm not sure I want to do that.

I can dye it blue -- then the gray will just be a different shade of blue. That's a possibility, but I want to consider a normal oil finish first. So what do you all think? Thanks.

...Gary


img

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#2

wrong title -- should be "o. p. -- rot or not"

GaryG in MD

>

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#3

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

Allen Neighbors

>Gary, my opinion is that the gray is just some of the spalting. I've turned several pieces that had this gray color. Save it, Turn it, finish it. Just my suggestions. Strong enough for tool handles? Don't know for sure. I'd try it if I wanted it.

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#4

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

john pickett

>Well, I think it is beautiful!

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#5

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

john pickett

>of course, if you were looking to get rid of some of it ....

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#6

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>I would finish it and just see who likes it. That is the person who should own it. Personaly, I don't turn maple unless it is ambrosia, spalted, or burl. That's the way I like it.

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#7

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

George Van

>Gary, in my experience people don't mind the gray and some think it's an enhancement to go with the spalting however the gray was balanced in the bowls. I have found it in soft maple up here. I have had it under satin and gloss, both well accepted.

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#8

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

Ed Karch

>Gary

the grey is not mold it is blue stain a fungus same a spalting is cause by another fungus but slower acting. Blue stain spores attack fresh cut wood. The sooner you turn it the less likely to get blue stain. Limon juice will lighten it quite a bit and may completely bleach it out. Nice bowl leave it like it is. I sell lots of blue stain mixed with spalting. It is hard to get spalting without some blue stain.

I wont be at the next meeting as I will be a SWAT for a day then Canyon Studios for a week. See you in Nov hopefully with the mistery wood solved.

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#9

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

robo hippy

>The one thing that I don't like about silver maple is the dull grey stain that it gets. It looks nice to me, but it is in a color spectrum that just doesn't sell too well. Other than that, turn it, sand it, and finish it. It is a nice wood, and seems to be plentiful. Here in Oregon, a 50 year old tree is 50 inches in diameter, but they seldom live that long, they grow too fast, then fall apart because they have grown too big too fast.

robo hippy

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#10

unfortunately...

GaryG in MD

>...what I have left is starting to crack too -- the useful pieces are getting smaller and smaller. Otherwise, I'd send you some. Thanks for your comment. ...Gary

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#11

Ed, thanks...

GaryG in MD

>...for the ID (I was hoping my comment would elicit the true name) and for the comment. Have fun out west -- there's a nice writeup on Canyon Studios on pages 66-67 of the current (Fall 2007) issue of Woodturning Design. Looks great. See you in November. ...Gary

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#12

I'm pleased...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks everyone for all the positive remarks and information. (I'm frankly surprised that there weren't more negative comments.) I feel better about it now. After re-turning, I'll go ahead and finish it up with Watco and let nature have its way. Here's a pic of the "surprise" branch inclusion I found in the bottom. ...Gary


img

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#13

oh yeah, ...

GaryG in MD

>...and thanks for the reminder about the lemon juice. I knew that but had forgotten. That's a good tip for everyone to remember -- much better than using Chlorox. ...Gary

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#14

Re: I'm pleased...

Greg Deavers

>Hi Gary,

Personally, I am never offended by the staining you see in silver maple wood. So I consider it a 'natural' occurance to see it in bowls and turned objects. If you don't like the pattern it presents, try to minimize it within your design.

Keep in mind that Silver Maple is a very soft wood compared to sugar, and rock maples. For handles I would not use it for something you swing, or impact. Maybe good for small handles without impact loading or high moment forces. Not for hammers, etc. May be perfectly fine for light chisel handles without spalting.

Nice bowl Too!

Re: opinions please -- tool handles

#15

Yes...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks for the comment, Greg.

The "handle" thing in the "subject" line was totally bogus -- a computer glitch. This is obviously a bowl. I had posted that handle "subject" in the past, and my browser remembered it and stuck it in there without my noticing it. Don't you just hate it when computers start thinking for you?

I'm happy about the positive comments about the blue stain being OK, because I've got more of it. In fact, I think I'll go out and take a whack at some right now! Cheers, Gary