Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Posts

Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#1

Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Bill Clark

>I recently turned two medium sized salad bowls, one of soft maple and the other of chinese elm. Because these bowls will be used and I wanted an easily renewable finish, I applied a generous coating of pure walnut oil. The bowls absorbed most of the oil and I wiped off the excess after a couple of days. I then left them indoors to dry. I have read that walnut oil will eventually harden. So far that has not been the case. It�s been a month and both bowls still have an oily residue on the surface. I�ve wiped the surface with paper towels twice but the residue returns. Because of the closed grain of the maple bowl it is dryer than the open grain elm but both will leave an oil spot on any paper or cloth they sit upon.

How long will it take for the walnut oil to finally harden? Is there any food safe solvent I can wipe on the surface to remove the untried oil? I�m open to suggestions.

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#2

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Allen Neighbors

>Bill, I don't know what kind of Walnut Oil you have, but I do know that some Walnut Oil that won't polymerize. You may have that type.

As far as the solvent is concerned, If it were mine, I'd try a wash with some Mineral Spirits, and then Wipe it well, and check it the next day. If that didn't do the trick, I'd use Lacquer Thinner. Then I'd put some Danish Oil on it. DO will polymerize. Also, after DO cures, it's food safe.

This may not be the right way, but it'd be my way unless someone chimes in with a sure cure for the stickies. :)

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#3

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Mike Jones

>I bought a pint of Mahoney's pure Walnut Oil. The catalog described it as "quick curing"...but I find that to be a very subjective description. The container states that the oil requires UV light to cure it, however, even our sunny California days were not enough to cure it dry after a week in the sun.

I wound up overcoating it with tung oil and got a hard finish, but Mike Mahoney (later) told me personally that this was not a good move. He said that the walnut oil is now encapsulated within the walls of the piece and that it was subject to rot.

With all the other choices for a good food-safe finish, I'll not use walnut oil again. If you find something that works, I'd be interested to hear about it.

Mike

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#4

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>I also bought some Mahoney oil and mine would not cure either. I waited 3 or 4 months and still not cured. I quit using it.

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#5

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Bill Clark

>Thanks everyone for the quick response. I'll try to remove the excess oil with a light rub of solvent a few times and let it dry a little longer and see if it's going to harden. I used a grocery store pure walnut oil so it was not treated in any way. I've used it on cutting boards before and it did dry so maybe the bowls will eventually dry. If it does not I'll try a heavy rub of solvent and danish oil.

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#6

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

russ Fairfield

>The problem may be as basic as the oil you are using. There are two types of Walnut Oil, one that will cure eventually and one that will never cure. One is for finishing and the other is for cooking, and the difference is in how they are processed.

Why not just forget about it, and use the bowl. An uncured Walnut Oil on a bowl is no different from using a bowl that was soaked in Mineral Oil.

If you really want a hard oil finish, and you know that yours is a finishing oil, you can do 3 things. One is to add a drying agent into the finish, the other is to force the cure with heat, and the 3rd is to set it aside until this time next year.

You can add a drying agent to the finish by wiping on a liberal coat of Japan Dryer and Mineral Spirits and repeating as it soaks into the wood. in the wood. It doesn't work all of the time, but enough of the time that it is worth trying.

You can heat the bowl by placing it the attic of your house in the summertime, or heating it in an oven set at 120F. A slower heating can be done by placing the bowl under a box with a 60-watt incandescent light bulb for heat. Heat and time will either force the finish to harden or it will drive it deep enough into the wood that it doesn't matter.

If none of these are appealing, you can set in in the warmest and dryest place in your house and forget about it for a year.

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#7

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Bill Clark

>Thanks for the tips Russ. I'm sure now that the oil I have, because it came from the grocery store, is not intended for finishing and probably will not dry as I want. I don't mind using the bowls because I know the oil is food safe. The small residue of oil they leave on any surface I put them on is the real problem. I may try the japan dryer tip to see if I can remove enough of the surface oil and then artificially dry them in a warm place or use the light bulb technique. I live in the central valley of Calif. where it gets very hot in the summer but that season is rapidly fading so I need to find another way to "sweat" out the excess oil. Thanks again for the ideas.

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#8

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Curt Fuller

>Hi Bill,

I use the walnut cooking oil whenever I want a finish that I expect someone to be eating from and have good luck with it. It doesn't give any kind of shine but will buff up pretty nice. I've never used the 'walnut oil finish' but I wonder if the wood you're finishing may still be holding a little moisture that's not letting the cooking oil soak in. Because the oil never truly dries and if it can't soak into the wood, it would seem to stay oily. But using solvents and other chemically altered oils would defeat the intent of using the cooking oil finish. I prefer the walnut cooking oil over some of the other cooking oils because I've never been able to detect any signs of it becoming rancid over time. And mineral oil is just a highly refined petroleum product.

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#9

Caution using metallics on usable work *LINK*

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>Do your own research on this, but the Japan driers I have used in the past contained liquid metallics, such as cobalt, to speed drying time. I would be wary of using any such metallic compounds in/on work that will, or could, hold food. At least until the health safety of the compounds are determined.

Also, this is an interesting site concerning oils. http://www.navaching.com/shaku/oil.html

Gil


http://www.navaching.com/shaku/oil.html

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#10

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>I had the same issue with Mahoney walnut oil. After about 3 months, I wiped it with mineral spirits, resanded it, and finished it with Watco. I won't use walnut oil again, either.

Scott

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#11

Thanks Curt and Gil

Bill Clark

>I've held off on the japan dryer for now. The linked article was very interesting. The oil hardening chart was very informative. It appears about 3 months are necessary for the walnut oil to harden per the author. I've only waited 1 month. I think I will try a little heat in the oven to accelerate the process. As far as moisture in the turned bowls, I doubt there was much there. Both were very dry when I turned them after the inital rough turn and drying process.

Re: Slow Drying Walnut Oil Finish - Help!

#12

Heat the oil before applying

Mike Brazeau

>I recently had the FWW Book on Faceplate turning out of the library for the umpteenth time for some nostalgia reading. (If you have never seen it and want to follow the development of turning in the 70's and early 80's it is worth reading )There was a reference in it by a Frenchman that said to heat walnut oil before applying. Leonard Lee, founder of Lee Valley also started a printing company which reprints old books. One available through LV at quite low cost is the Handbook of Turning, originally published in 1846. It also includes a reference to heating the walnut oil or actually heating the work and then applying the oil. To quote "Old walnut wood is very beautiful; to improve its colour it may be put in the oven, and when worked, polish it with its very own oil, very hot." I recently finished a hard maple salad bowl using the technique and it definitely improved the drying or what really appears to be better penetration of the oil into the wood. I was using Walnut Oil from LV, since it is easier for me to get my hands on. I heated perhaps 25-50 ml. in a coffee can in my electric frypan of melted parafin wax at about 250 F and applied liberally with a brush while hot. Overnight it had the appearance of being dry. I then applied a beeswax/mineral oil mixture several times over the next few days. I learned from the Thomas Moser website and his book on Shaker Furniture about heating Boiled Linseed Oil and always do that on cherry if using BLO. It dries up beautifully and hard.