Re: how to avoid this?........
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>Mike, the list of reasons as to why a tenon can snap off is as long as the list of people who usually post here on this forum, and maybe longer. It could be one of many, or even a combination. Looking at the piece, I would tend to think that the culprit might be leverage coupled with a flaw in the wood.
I have personally snapped off more tenons than I can remember. Often it is from cutting too fast and hard on a piece of wood. Sometimes it happens when I am coring a bowl. Almost always it has to do with pushing the process faster than that particular piece of wood can handle. I have seen the 40% rule, and had it quoted to me by a "world famous turner" very recently at a demo. I have never seen that to be the case, either in hollowing a bowl or coring it. While a tenon can be too small, and I avoid that, I almost never make them as big as 40%. In fact, when I am making a bowl, the tenon often ends up somewhere between 25% and 30%, figuring on the way I make my bowls and observing the 1/3 rule for top to bottom ratio.
If it were me, I would examine the wood closely to see if there are flaws apparent. I would also examine my technique to see if it was a catch that did the deed, or perhaps just too much too fast in the way of stock removal. Depending on how high the bowl is compared to its width affects that. Of course, cutting close to the center on a narrow bowl blank of any height requires a slower feed rate than on a wider bowl because the surface speed of the wood is much slower. A feed rate that works for a wider bowl further out towards the edge just can't quite, uhhh, cut it, for one that is narrower. Something has to give, and in a lot of cases, it is the tenon.
Good luck with your diagnosis.
Bill