Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

how to avoid this?........

Posts

how to avoid this?........

#1

how to avoid this?........

Mike Hamilton

>Had a round of walnut that'd been sitting around for a while. The sapwood looked pretty so I thought I'd try NE (without the bark). Turned the outside and tenon, put it in the chuck and started to hollow. Suddenly a wobble as the tenon broke on a grain line. Was I silly to try this dry? Needed a larger tenon? Other thoughts?

Last weekend it was a 'dry' mulberry blank that cracked beyond saving while I was turning the outside, now this. I have two bushels of shavings and a bottle stopper to show for two weekends at the lathe!

Regards,

Mike Hamilton

Plainfield, IN


img

Re: how to avoid this?........

#2

Re: how to avoid this?........

GaryG in MD

>Mike,

I can't see the crack in your photo (i.e., if it goes deeper than where the other half of the tenon was) but, in general, that's a very easy fix. If the wood is sound, just saw off the half tenon, put it between centers, and turn a new one on it. There's nothing wrong with dry wood in general. If there is a shallow crack remaining, put some CA on it for now -- you'll eventually turn that away anyway. If you think this piece is structurally unsound, then you should trash it. If it's just a little weak, you might throw it in some wood hardener (there are a number on the market), or you could soak it in 50/50 water and white glue. You have lots of options.

...Gary

Re: how to avoid this?........

#3

Re: how to avoid this?........

Andi Wolfe

>The tenon does look pretty small for holding a blank for hollowing. You didn't say what approach you were using for hollowing this deep, narrow vessel so it's a little hard to give you advice. Please elaborate. . .

You can turn another tenon if you didn't get all the way to the bottom.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#4

Re: how to avoid this?........

Phil in NJ

>That's a pretty small tenon... many people say 40% of the diameter is an appropriate size.

Were you gripping the tenon with the jaw shoulders butted up against the main piece? Or just gripping the end of the tenon? The grip will be most secure when the jaws are butted against the main piece.

-Phil

Re: how to avoid this?........

#5

Re: how to avoid this?........

Paul Zerjay

>I think the dia of the tenon is too small and the length of the tenon is too long for the side grain orientation of the blank. Try turning a shorter, fatter tenon. On the other hand what do I know.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#6

Re: how to avoid this?........

Chip in Plano

>I agree that the tenon is small. Use the biggest one you can grip. The other thing I've learned is that wobbles occur when the piece is turning unsupported not because I didn't squeeze the life out of my tenons. I've got 2 pieces in the 'Someday I'm gonna fix it' box that look like yours including one that is dry walnut. I'm almost finished with my bowl steady so that 'someday' is coming soon. I' going to turn all my hollow forms with outside support. So a catch while hollowing doesn't cause the HF to twist and start wobbling....resulting in a fractured tenon.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#7

Re: poor photo - back on the horse that threw me

Mike Hamilton

>Actually, the nipple you see at the top of the photo is left from working between centers and is small enough that it fits down inside the chuck. I left it for possible need to go back between centers. The tenon for the chuck is almost the full width of the base and was less than 3/16 thick. There was a 1/8 or so shoulder for registering against the chuck jaws.

I followed everyone's advice and went back between centers to turn another tenon - smaller diameter to make a wider shoulder, deeper tenon at 1/4 inch or so. So far, so good. I'm using a 3/8 inch bowl gouge to hollow and the piece is (now) about 3.5 by 3.5 inches.

Thanks,

Mike

Re: how to avoid this?........

#8

Re: how to avoid this?........

Mike Nelson

>Mike, use at least 2" jaws for a hollow form that size and depth. Make sure the tenon is only an eighth inch or so larger than the jaws for a tight fit. If you are like some folks..and get catches occasionally you will end up with a UFO stuck in the sheetrock above your lathe..like some guy I know.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#9

Re: poor photo - back on the horse that threw me

Mike Nelson

>The bowl gouge was probably the culprit on what looks like a 6" deep by 3" vase, could make for a nice catch!

Re: how to avoid this?........

#10

Re: how to avoid this?........

Bill Hale

>If I am turning a softer wood I make my tennon and run a little thin CA at the base to stsbelize between the tennon and the base of the bowl. As the others have said it looks long and narrow. Once the work starts to wobble it becomes less stable with revolution. Be sure to angle the sides of the tennon to match the taper of the jaws.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Show Low AZ.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#11

Re: how to avoid this?........

adrien

>I've also heard that setting the base of the tenon deeper than the periphery��IOW angling the base around the tenon so that the outside sits higher than the central portion���ensures that the piece sits firmly against the chuck, thus preventing any wobble, helps minimize this problem.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#12

Richard Allen

Re: how to avoid this?........

Richard Allen

>Most times hollow forms are made endgrain.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: how to avoid this?........

keith tompkins

>Hi Mike, A couple of things that can be done...flatten the base, and glue on a sacrificial block. I use titebond, and have never had a glue-joint failure. It works very well when you want to use every bit of the wood, including what normally would be wasted on the tenon. Also, try a three-wheel steady rest....a big help.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#14

Re: how to avoid this?........

john lucas

>After reading all the responses I was surprised no one mentioned that the tenon is side grain. You stand a very good chance of loosing the work due to tenon breakage even if you make it bigger. Not that it can't be done you just can't be aggressive while turning. I would use a glue block and epoxy to turn a side grain vessel unless it's pretty small.

I've turned a lot of side grain bowls and only lost a few due to tenon damage but when you start hanging a piece of wood out there 6" or more you put a lot of force on the tenon. In that case a larger tenon with good square shoulder will often due the trick. The square shoulders are the most important part. The wood sits on these shoulders and it reduces the amount of rocking you get. The rocking increases the chance of the piece flying out of the chuck and also increases the chance of breaking the tenon.

Re: how to avoid this?........

#15

Hmmm? Trying to figure out why........

Barry Irby

>a glue block would be stronger than the wood itself? If the chuck had a good solid grip on walnut and the "area" of the tenon was say ten square inches, what would gluing something to the same area be stronger. I'm not arguing, just trying to get it straight in my head.

My experience is much more limited than yours but I have had only a few tenon failures. (Often at the worst possible moment, such as during a demo for the Turning club) I am not a big fan of glue blocks. Too lazy and don't want to wait for the Titebond to cure.

I have good luck with tenons when I cut them a little deeper than the one shown. So that it recesses into the chuck a 1/4 or 3/8", but does not rest on the bottom of the jaws, and when there is a good shoulder on the base of the piece to rest on the face of the chuck. I also find it important to cut the profile of the tenon to match the shape of the internal or gripping surface of the jaws very closely and the size should be near the "closed" dimension of the jaws.

My jaws are dovetailed and I find it very worthwhile to dovetail the tenon so that the jaws clamp the piece without the leading edge of the dovetail "biting" the tenon. In other words, if you put a straight tenon into dovetail jaws the jaws act as if they have teeth and try to bite the tenon off the base of the piece. At that point the tenon is already weakened.

I'm just wondering if the glue block were of stronger less split prone wood does it hold better? Maybe the glue block would not fail, but wouldn't the wood fail anyway if you got a catch and imparted enough stress to crack that ten square inches or whatever?

Re: how to avoid this?........

#16

Re: how to avoid this?........

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Mike, the list of reasons as to why a tenon can snap off is as long as the list of people who usually post here on this forum, and maybe longer. It could be one of many, or even a combination. Looking at the piece, I would tend to think that the culprit might be leverage coupled with a flaw in the wood.

I have personally snapped off more tenons than I can remember. Often it is from cutting too fast and hard on a piece of wood. Sometimes it happens when I am coring a bowl. Almost always it has to do with pushing the process faster than that particular piece of wood can handle. I have seen the 40% rule, and had it quoted to me by a "world famous turner" very recently at a demo. I have never seen that to be the case, either in hollowing a bowl or coring it. While a tenon can be too small, and I avoid that, I almost never make them as big as 40%. In fact, when I am making a bowl, the tenon often ends up somewhere between 25% and 30%, figuring on the way I make my bowls and observing the 1/3 rule for top to bottom ratio.

If it were me, I would examine the wood closely to see if there are flaws apparent. I would also examine my technique to see if it was a catch that did the deed, or perhaps just too much too fast in the way of stock removal. Depending on how high the bowl is compared to its width affects that. Of course, cutting close to the center on a narrow bowl blank of any height requires a slower feed rate than on a wider bowl because the surface speed of the wood is much slower. A feed rate that works for a wider bowl further out towards the edge just can't quite, uhhh, cut it, for one that is narrower. Something has to give, and in a lot of cases, it is the tenon.

Good luck with your diagnosis.

Bill

Re: how to avoid this?........

#17

Re: Hmmm? Trying to figure out why........

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Wally taught me that glue blocks were used for two reasons. The first was that they were used with a faceplate or a screw chuck. The second was that they saved wood so thinner wood could be useful for turning. Chucks as we now know them were not available and/or too expensive not all that many years ago.

A glue block with a faceplate mounting would be incredibly strong.