Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Short Bowl Gouges

Posts

Short Bowl Gouges

#1

Short Bowl Gouges

Roy Girolami

>As had to happen eventually, I have shortened my bowl gouge through grinding to where it only has a little bit of the groove left. I have noticed it doesn't cut as long as it used to before needing to be sharpened. i wondered if the HSS gouges are tempered along the length like a CS gouge and I have gotten beyond the hard part.

Anybody know for sure?

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

#2

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

Gordon Seto

>I am wondering the same thing.

I have some unhandled gouges that I use with the Kelton and Oneway handles; on some the grub screws would leave dents and some won't. I have not tried on the flute end of the gouges. The observation that I can make is some tool tangs are softer than the grub screws.

I don't know whether they are by design to get us to replace our gouges sooner or the softer the tang, the less brittle it becomes.

Gordon

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

#3

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Anybody know for sure?

You should be able to get a feel for the hardness along the tool by "scratching" it at various places with something, for example a small triangular jewler's file.

BTW, preserving tool length is one argument for sharpeners such as the Tormek since each sharpening using the jig takes off only the tiniest amount of metal. I don't think I've taken more than 1/4" off my favorite gouges in the last several, likely less, honing many times between sharpenings.

JKJ

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

#4

Re: When most tool steels....

Jamie Donaldson

>...are hardened, only the working part of the shaft is actually hardened. This also is something of a safety factor, to keep the tangs from being brittle and subject to breakage.

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

#5

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>HHS and carbon steel can be hardened with a induction heater, this is a fast and simple way to heat the steel before it's quenched. In a matter of seconds steel can be put in a coil, heated and dropped into a tank of oil. The down fall of this process is the steel is only hard on the outside and has a soft core (case hardened) and they don't hardened the entire length only what is in the coil. The hardness of each part needs to be checked 100% because the process is controled by timing. The process is amazing to watch.

On the other hand the steel I use CPM 10V has about 50 hours total time in a vacuum furnace and a day in the cryogenics. The entire length is hardened and the cost to manufacture is much higher.

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

#6

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

Pete in Holland

>Curious - - Are you sharpening by hand or with a jig? Just wondering how much material was leaving your tool each time you ground?

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

#7

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

Roy Girolami

>The gouge I'm presently using is probably over 15 years old. I tend to grind the edge before using and occasionally during use. I don't hone the edge. I only grind enough to get it back to sharp.

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

#8

Re: Short Bowl Gouges

john lucas

>You didn't mention whether or not your gouge was HSS. I know several older turners who used non HSS gouges and it was fairly common for them to reharden the tools after they got short and lose the ability to hold an edge. Apparently in the older gouges only the first 1/3 or 1/2 of the gouge was really hardened. If that's what you have simply reharden it.

I know some of the HSS gouges are hardened through and through, tang and all because they put the whole thing in the furnace. Others probably use the electric heat treating that Doug mentioned.