Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turning?

Posts

Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turning?

#1

Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turning?

Philip Morris

>Are standing dead/diseased trees still good for tuning?

There is a Bradford Pear tree in a nearby neighborhood that has turned black as if covered with soot (leaves and all). I have been told that it was probably overstressed by the heat and drought we have had here in Jackson, Mississippi this summer and succumbed to some kind of disease. It appears to have been alive this spring since it does have a lot of its foilage.

I was wondering about approaching the homeowner about cutting it down, but did not want to if it would recover or if the wood was no good.

If the wood is still potentially good, is the soot looking stuff something that presents any hazards in cutting or turning?

Thanks,

Philip

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turning?

#2

Richard Allen

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turn

Richard Allen

>The wood is likely Ok. That is a LOT of wood and a lot of work. Is the black stuff a hazard? Lots of "stuff" is a hazard in woodturning and the black stuff may be a hazard, it was to the tree. But the black stuff is likely fine given the usual precautions you would take with to protect your from wood dust.

I would let someone else take the tree down and ask them for some of the wood.

Good luck

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turning?

#3

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turn

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I've never done Bradford pear, but I harvest and turn diseased trees, standing dead trees, storm damaged trees and already laying on the ground dead trees. The only issues I've encountered are rot and bugs. Depending on your preferences, these things can be a plus or a minus. I'm not a tree, so I don't worry too much about getting tree diseases myself.

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turning?

#4

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turn

Clay Foster

>If it was still alive this spring, I bet the wood still has a lot of moisture in it. The piece of green Bradford pear I've turned cut really nice. The black stuff will probably clean right off with a power washer or a car wash.

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turning?

#5

Don't know anything about Bradford pear

Don Henthorn

>but I had a pear orchard in California and one of the things we had to fight was fire blight. It was called fire blight because the leaves would turn black like they had been burned. It would spread very fast and if not treated would kill a tree in a season. It was easily spread to other trees by birds and insects so one had to watch closely for any outbreak. I have no idea if this is what happened to that tree but if was then the trash from the tree should be burned so it doesn't spread to other susceptible trees. The wood itself is probably not dangerous if the bark is disposed of properly (that means burnt) and the wood properly dried.

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turning?

#6

Re: Are Standing Dead/Diseased Trees Good for Turn

Philip Morris

>Ya'll,

Thanks for the insights. Think I will call a local tree service to get a little more information about what may have affected the tree before I jump in. I don't want to bring something to my neighborhood that would be problematic.

Thanks again,

Philip