Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

My aforementioned box

Posts

My aforementioned box

#1

Steven Antonucci

My aforementioned box

steve antonucci

>Here is a picture of the work in progress. Whenever I get a piece that I am not happy with, I start thinking crazy thoughts. thoughts like, "Carve it", "color it"...

I'm not thrilled with this one. I sprayed it with lacquer last night to confirm that "it's not done yet". I'm currently thining that I will be carving the top and inlaying much more of the abalone shell...

What don't I like about it? I think it's too tall and too plain.

Comments welcome.

Steven


img

Re: My aforementioned box

#2

Steven Antonucci

detail of abalone inlay 

steve antonucci

>


img

Re: My aforementioned box

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: My aforementioned box

Mike Stafford

>Steve, I think you lid is out of proportion to the body of the box. The box is well formed and finished nicely but proportions are everything in small objects. And the proportions between the lid and the body of a box can make it or break it....I have many broken boxes....

Re: My aforementioned box

#4

Steven Antonucci

I agree, but...

steve antonucci

>When I started, the proportions were thirds- usually a good rule of thumb. I think the bead makes the lid appear shorter than it is, which is 1/3 the the overall height (exactly) and the width is 2/3 of the height (within 1/8").

I'm also not thrilled with the straight down side on the bottom of the box. It lacks any movement or visual interest. I may just remount it and taper it with a "swoop". The lid is decidedly going to get some more abalone inlays and perhaps some carved elements...

Just goes to show, its as much art as science. Version 2 coming someday soon...

Steven

Re: My aforementioned box

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: I agree, but...

Mike Stafford

>If you were to reduce the diameter slightly under the lid and have the major diameter at the bottom I think it would change the appearance drastically. You are probably talking of doing just that. Also, if the angle of the picture was reduced it would have a tremendous effect on the the way the box looks.

Re: My aforementioned box

#6

Steven Antonucci

That's part of the plan

steve antonucci

>Still going to carve it and inlay more stuff...too.

Steven

Re: My aforementioned box

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: That's part of the plan

keith tompkins

>Steve, for what it's worth, the base and the top compete with each other. If the top were the same basic shape as the base, it would work. I would reconsider adding more inlay or carving...if you are not happy with the overall shape, nothing you do will make the piece feel right to you.

Two things you can do: One, put the piece on a shelf and study it for a while. The other thing that I highly recommend is to make a sketch of the piece, then make several more sketches,showing changes or revisions to the piece. Hope this helps.

Re: My aforementioned box

#8

Re: My aforementioned box

Karen F.

>Hi Steve, That looks like a piece of Carob I remember. I think the abalone looks a little too small. What about a small finial of a complimentary wood? I like the looks and color of the box but it looks like a dot on top. But it's not like I'm a great box maker at all. Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: My aforementioned box

#9

Steven Antonucci

You are correct, Sir!

steve antonucci

>To quote the old Johnny Carson routine...

It is the Carob you sent. I know that it needs more than the dot, but I resisted the finial thing since it seems to almost be a cliche at this point. I had a piece of ebony in my hand and had started thinking about what kind of finial I would turn when I stopped...

I had a dream last night that I think put a new idea for the bottom in my head. I'll repost it when I finish, but I think it will make a huge difference. As for the top, the next time you see it, it will have significantly more inlay. That's all I've got to say about that (Gump) - for now.

Steven