>Everyone loves that satisfying "pop" of a snug fitting lid- you know what I mean! It comes off with just the right amount of pressure, but not to much...
So a question for all of the "professional" box makers out there- how do you assure the fit every time? I've probably made 10 boxes in my life, and only 3-4 of them "fit" perfectly. Obviously, the rest are loose (or I would have cut them smaller...)
Do you get it close and sand to fit? How much room do you leave for finish? If you go over, what can you do to fix it? (I have one in the shop that is over by the thickness of a piece of masking tape right now!)
>I think Raffan puts a VERY slight outward curve on the inside lip and puts a small dovetail or bead on the edge of the outside lip. That way you should get a little pop without having to match a perfect fit.
One of the members of a turning group/gathering I'm in is a master of perfect fitting lid boxes. He checks here once in a while, so maybe he'll throw some tips in here. His rely on getting the perfect fit. He's a member of the Lehigh Valley turners. Other than that, I'll leave it to him if he wants to post.
>I just purchased via ebay Richard Raffans 'Making Boxes' and yes, he puts a slight convex shape on the tenon and a very small dovetail on the lid. Just received it and wathced it last night, so haven't had a chance to practice yet.
Always make the female part of the box first. So, make the lid first when the lid fits over a rim on the base. The last thing you do is final fit the rim on the base using a parting tool (this is the male part). If you fit the lid too soon and remove wood from the interior of the base, then the rim may change shape and your fit is lost.
Sometimes I use Jimmy Clewes method, where a taper is cut on the rim and the lid is eased onto the taper while the lathe is running. A mark where the lid and rim meet should be apparent. Then you cut a slight taper the other way producing a ridge less pronounced than "^" at the mark. Try fitting the lid. It should go on, possibly with effort. If it is too snug, TOUCH it with some 400 sandpaper. Try again. If still too snug, TOUCH it with a parting tool, removing dust and not much more.
>Yes, I think the Clewes method is the best. There is sometimes a slight problem when cutting the reverse taper because the tool hits the shoulder. You need a quite small skew , or, what I did was to grind a tiny parting tool( you can make it out of just about anything) with a distinct angle at the end. With this tool you can push the tool straight in, perpendicular to the spindle axis, and easily get the reverse taper at the shoulder without running into the shoulder.
>I had the priviledge to take a Richard Raffan class this summer, and bought two of his boxes too.
There is no magic in how he makes them, all of the material is in the "Making Boxes" book, though to see him work either in person is something else of course!
I would say many but not all of his boxes are in the near perfect fit category. He certainly is a firm believer in never letting inferior product out of the workshop.
As others have said, there is careful attention to parallelism of the rebate in the top. Stable, dry wood is another key point... partially turning them and letting them dry fully is recommended.
The careful fitting of the box lids is done (by Richard) entirely with a skew (scraping cut), touching up its sharpness on the "bottom"
facet just slightly.
I find the toughest thing is knowing when to stop messing with it myself!
>I do like Ed. I use my parting tool like a mini skew with the angle slightly skewed. This leaves a cleaner cut. I don't sand the male or female portion of the lid if possible because sanding almost always rounds the tenons slightly and they don't fit as good.
>I always make the lid first and fit the flange on the body of the box to the lid.
Just like Richard Raffan, I make sure the lid flange is parallel and check that several times with the calipers. I sand and finish the interior of the lid being careful not to sand the lid flange.
When I start the body of the box I turn a tapered flange that will just start to go into the lid. Then I hollow the box and sand it. I don't try to fit the lid until all of that has been accomplished. Then I take a razor sharp skew laying flat on the tool rest I present the edge to the tapered flange on the body of the box near the shoulder. Carefully I remove dust and I do mean dust until I can jam fit the lid on the body. I try to shape the body flange so that it is slightly bulbous in the center. That makes it somewhat easy to start the lid and then it tightens up as I push it on. The idea is to have the diameter of this bulbous portion just a smidgeon larger in diamter than the internal diameter of the lid flange when it is all said and done. I want this fit to be tighter than I want when the box is finished so that I can shape the lid and body at the same time. I then sand the lid and body and ready them for finish.
I remove the lid and make minute adjustments so the lid will now be easier to remove. This is done with the skew laying flat and again just by removing dust. I want the lid to stay on for the next steps but removable so that I can apply my finish.
After finishing the lid and box body I apply finish to the body flange but not a lot. Once the finish is complete I check the lid and if necessary I will adjust the fit with a 3M pad. Usually that is enough to get the fit where I want it. If not I give the flange a few swipes with some 600 grit paper and follow that up with some wax.
No matter how careful you are you will make the body flange too small once in a while. The best thing to do is turn it off and cut another. It is hard to put wood back on. The fit of the lid changes seasonally as well.
I am reminded of the American woodworker visiting a Japanese grand master woodworker. The American was admiring a sweater box that had wonderful handcut dovetails and a very precisely fitting sliding lid. The American remarked that the lid must swell shut and be impossible to remove during the Summer. The Japanese woodworker smiled and said, "This is true but I do not need my sweaters in the Summer."
>I think you mean rotate the handle a little CLOCKWISE ( so the left part of the taper will be smaller toward the spindle; that's how to get the 'V'). The point I was trying to make is that when you do this, the shaft of the parting tool may hit the edge of the shoulder. That's why I use a small skew or a specially -made parting tool with a skewed edge. ( I'm assuming that it's the male part of the box lid you're working on and that you're standing in the normal position with the opening facing toward the tail stock, and that you have already tapered the right half of this part of the lid.)
>There's a turner in our club(CAW) ,Doc Johnson, who does it still a different way: He does everything in the usual way, but when it comes to the critical part of fitting the male part of the lid, he simply turns a tiny bead near the center of the lid. He seems to get the 'snap' every time.
To cut the original slight taper you would rotate clockwise and move the handle to the left. This will produce a taper sloping down from left to right.
Then the Lid is engaged with the taper and a mark will occur on the taper. Now, cut a taper that slopes downward from right to left between the left side of the rim and the mark the lid made. THIS taper is cut by rotating the parting tool counterclockwise and moving the handle to the right. Moving from left to right the rim should go up and then down. The crest of that rim will be compressed slightly, giving the snug fit.
>When you cut the left taper, if you rotate the tool HANDLE counter- clockwise, then the left edge of the tool tip will move away from the wood and the right edge of the tool top will dig into the center of the lip. This action will produce a taper going down from the shoulder to the right , which is the opposite of what you want. You must be doing something other that a slight scraping action, which is all that is required.
>about scraping? This is a cut, done above the center - and the rotation I described is the correct one for that cut. You want to drop the left side of the parting tool to make this cut, hence CCW.
>I'm beginning to think that what you're doing is rotating the tool about the long axis of the tool( i.e. a hand twisting motion.) Is that right? I was originally picturing you rotating the tool ( a body swaying motion) about a vertical axis down through the tool. I find that to get the 'snap' all you need is an extremely subtle scrape that just barely removes some dust. Anyway, it's really satisfying when it works just right. Sorry about the confusion.
>I suppose I'm beating this to death, but I finally see how you do it; and I see it's advantages. With the parting tool above center, you are using it something like a skew. So yes, you would twist the tool about its long axis counter-clockwise to get the left taper -- something like the beginning of the left side of a bead. What I like about your way is that the left corner of the parting tool should reach all the way to the shoulder without hitting anything. My method, turning my body to the left to swing the tool CLOCKWISE about a vertical axis, runs the shaft of the tool into the shoulder. (That's why I ground a special scraping tool on an angle.) I'll try it your way next time.