Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

The Documentary...The War

Posts

The Documentary...The War

#1

The Documentary...The War

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Are any of you watching the Ken Burns film on WW2? I've heard that many young people are not. This is a huge part of our history. Sadly, many of the younger generations don't seem to be interested in their history.

I am one of the few on WC who was involved in the war. I'm learning a few things from the film that I either didn't know or had forgotten. I wasn't aware that the news media showed no photos of dead Americans during the first year of our participation. I had forgotten much about the race riots. I do remember how people came together more than ever before or since. I can remember how angry I was at what happened to West Coast Japanese. I had several friends and schoolmates who were Japanese and ended up in concentration camps.

I joined the Navy in early 1942. After some duty stations in the US, I was assigned to a new Destroyer in late 1943. We were involved in the invasion of the Mariannas...Saipan, Tinian, Guam. Later we were part of the invasion of Palau, later thought to have not been necessary. We took part in the invasion of Leyte in the Phillipines. I was wounded there during an air raid. We were involved in the invasion of Iwo Jima, a very bloody affair. We were at Okinawa, which most people don't realize was bigger than Normandy. The largest concentration of warships in history. I was wounded again during a kamikaze attack. I ended up in a hospital on Guam for several weeks. After the ship was repaired I went back aboard and we returned to Okinawa. About 2 months later we were again hit by a kamikaze. After some repairs, we headed back to the States on one engine. We were refueling at Saipan on the day the war ended. That's condensing 3-1/2 years into one paragraph.

So far, the film has shown an equal amount on the war in the Pacific and war in Europe. Lately, the news media has tended to ignore the war in the Pacific theatre. It's as if the war started at Normandy. The war in the Western Pacific, Southeast Asia, and China was huge. Much larger in scope than anything previous.

Just thought that you might be interested. They say that a thousand WW2 vets are dying each day...hey that's pretty scary if you're one of them.

Wally

Re: The Documentary...The War

#2

Re: The Documentary...The War

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Wally,

You know I have been watching as well and I am gripped amd humbled by the stories, the strief, the unision and division. I know from my late father who was there at the same time as you Wally in the USN that things were not always topics for free discussion. I knnow he'd be watching as well and finding facts that are new to him.

I like the way Burns tells a story, his documentry on baseball was incredible, this is also at that scale.

Bless you and all vets for your dedication, thank you.

Take care,

Jim

Re: The Documentary...The War

#3

Re: The Documentary...The War

Allen Neighbors

>Wally, being a two-year vet of VietNam, I am one person who is aware of many of the things that you went through for the cause of freedom and right. I am thankful for you and others who went across the sea during those years of conflict.

I have three Uncles and three Cousins that went to Guam, Iwo Jima, Okinawa, and also to the European Theatre.

I believe yours is still the Greatest Generation!! It would be an honor to meet you and get to shake your hand.

Re: The Documentary...The War

#4

Re: The Documentary...The War

GaryG in MD

>I can't take my eyes off it. I was born in a Company hospital during The War. My Mother nearly died as a result. My Dad was mining copper and was not permitted to enlist because the mines, of course, had been "nationalized". As a result, they kept scrapbooks of photos from Life magazine and newspapers. I grew up, during the Korean War, reading those scrap books. I still have them. If there was ever a Necessary War, that was it. Ken Burns has done his usual amazing job of personalizing it. You're right that it is a terrible shame that the average young person today isn't interested. If ever they should be interested in the realities of war, it's today. I'll watch every minute. If you have HD, you'll find that the audio is pretty amazing too. Some of the concussions will just about flap your drapes. ...Gary

Re: The Documentary...The War

#5

Re: The Documentary...The War

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>We are not young but Dan and I have been watching it. Many of the things you did not know or had forgotten we had never heard of.

Re: The Documentary...The War

#6

Re: The Documentary...The War

Sean Troy

>I've been watching it. Makes me think of the stories my Dad used to tell me. He was a B-17 piolt then flew a B-29

Re: The Documentary...The War

#7

Re: The Documentary...The War

Kevin Gerstenecker

>I have been watching what I can, and using my DVR to record the rest to be watched at a later date. I think Ken Burn's Civil War was excellent, and I bought the DVD set. Ken Burns is a national treasure, IMO, his work is just that good. I will purchase this documentary when it becomes available, as I had several uncles in WWII and the many stories of the great war interest me very much. Wally, you and the other Veteran's of this war should be given the utmost respect for what you endured. 2 of my Uncle's were also at Okinawa during the battle. They never spoke of it much, but you could tell they were and are profoundly affected by this war. My Mother often said that when my now passed Uncle John returned home from the pacific theater he was barely recognizable, and a changed man forever. Wally and others, thank you for your service to our great nation. It means more to some than you know.

Re: The Documentary...The War

#8

Re: The Documentary...The War

john lucas

>Wish I had time to watch it. My dad flew 26 missions as a belly gunner on the B17. I've always been interested in the behind the scenes history of wars. What really happened and why we were there is worth studying.

Re: The Documentary...The War

#9

Re: The Documentary...The War

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>John,

In the second episode there was an amazing story of a man who was like your dad, he was a B-17 belly gunner. John, you need to beg borrow or what ever, but you need to see it.

Take care,

Jim

Re: The Documentary...The War

#10

Re: The Documentary...The War

Jim King

>Wally: Here is another one like yourself. Lost Batallian and POW several years and spent his time working on the Bridge over the River Kwai. Dan Buzzo from San Antonio. As they say the greatest generation.


img

Re: The Documentary...The War

#11

Re: The Documentary...The War

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>He does inject a personal side to his documentaries that makes them personal to the viewer. I do remember the Victory at Sea series from the 50's? but they omitted some of the things that would have offended the sensibilities of the day. I was born while my uncle (Ray) was interred at a Stalag camp in Germany, 17 to be exact. He was a flight engineer (top turret gunner) in B-17's and was shot down twice. Once over the channel and the second during one of the Swienfort raids which lead to his internment after spending many months hiding with the French underground.

Ray

Re: The Documentary...The War

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: The Documentary...The War

Mike Stafford

>I grew up in a family where there were many war veterans from WWI and WWII. My grandfather served in the Navy during WWI and had many harrowing tales to tell about German U-boats. My father and two of his brothers served in WWII. My dad's oldest brother was a sergeant and would bring out a KP knife that he used to kill a German who was part of a party that infiltrated their field camp behind the lines. He was not a front line soldier he was a mess cook for troops supporting Patton.

My father went into the service in the Army and came out in the Air Force. Most of his duty was in Guam and the Philippines. He was a POW guard most of his time in the Philippines and he was responsible for overseeing a Japanese carpentry crew. He said it was the best duty in the war as long as you were respectful to these men. They wanted the work, took pride in what they did and were masterful carpenters. This was high praise coming from a man who built houses and cabinets all of his adult life.

All of my father's 5 brothers served in the military during WWII, the Korean War or during peace. Patriotism was a frequent topic of discussion at our house and I developed an admiration for these men because of the stories they told. It was very obvious how much they loved this country. My father and his brothers are turning over in their graves I am sure because of the way the American soldier is now being slandered by some of our leaders. People today have no idea what sacrifice truly is.

In one day of practice for D-Day more soldiers were lost in a training accident than have been lost in Iraq and Afghanistan combined. More people died on 9/11 than died at Pearl Harbor. I don't know what it will take for people to realize that there are truly people out there who want to kill us just because we exist. Yet we have very little commitment to those who volunteer, VOLUNTEER, to fight for our freedom. I cannot say thank you enough to those who fought to give us the freedom to sit here and read and write these words.

Re: The Documentary...The War

#13

Steven Antonucci

My Grandfather fought in Okinawa

steve antonucci

>My grandmother never let us see the letters home, but I know he was in Okinawa with the USMC. Technical Sargeant Francis Harold Burke.

I haven't seen the show, but only because I don't know when it's on. I'll set the TiVo tonight...

Steven

P.S. If you've never seen HBO's "Band of Brothers", rent it...

Re: The Documentary...The War

#14

Steven Antonucci

Is it the story of the "belly landing"?

steve antonucci

>I saw that in the Smithsonian Air and Space Museum and I stood there bawling my head off... while people around me walked around oblivious.

Steven

Re: The Documentary...The War

#15

Re: The Documentary...The War

Brent at Robust

>Wally, I watch very little TV, but have carved out the hours needed to watch this. Like you, my Dad served in the Pacific. He was a paratrooper and saw action in and around New Guinea. He never spoke of it, but reading the famous historian, William Manchester's recollection of his experience as a Marine in Guadalcanal and Tarawa brought some of the poignancy of Dad's experience to me. Manchester also wrote the definitive biography on McArthur, well worth reading IMHO. I must admit I watch the Pacific coverage very closely. It's a million in one chance, but I look for images of my dad in the archival footage. Thanks for your service Wally.

Re: The Documentary...The War

#16

Re: The Documentary...The War

Curt Stivison

>Wally, having been in Viet Nam I know a little of what you have seen, but the sacafices made by your generation were tremendous. God Bless You and all the others who were there.

CW

Re: The Documentary...The War

#17

Re: The Documentary...The War

Jorge Castaneda

>Wally,

I was im 5th grade the day they drop the bomb, I was reading about the war since I was 3 and I still remember a lot and still there is too much else to learn.

We are lucky you made it back and I thank you for your service.

Jorge

Re: The Documentary...The War

#18

Thank You for Serving...

Ron McKinley

>My Dad was in WWI in France and was too old for WWII. I was only 3 when Pearl Harbor was attacked. Two cousins are buried in Normandy and another cousin flew B-29s in the Pacific. I was too young for Korea but served two tours in Vietnam.

I've always felt guilty about missing WWII. That was truly the Great Generation. And yes I've watched every episode.

We're now embroiled in WWIII that's going to last for generations but most people just don't get it--yet! Civilization as we know it is in great danger now, just as it was in WWII. Thanks again for serving......Ron

Re: The Documentary...The War

#19

Re: The Documentary...The War

Ron in Drums PA

>It's a great show, it's a shame of the problems it had before it aired.

My father fought at Normandy and the Bulge. I have some great photos that he took of both battles.

Re: The Documentary...The War

#20

Politicians Who Start Wars....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Should be required to lead the charge....

Wally

Re: The Documentary...The War

#21

Re: The Documentary...The War

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>It's a million in one chance, but I look for images of my dad in the archival footage.

My father flew a combat tour in Europe as a navigator on a B-24. When he returned stateside he applied and was approved for flight training.

Fast forward to 1993. I handed him the June issue of the magazine Air Classics that had among the articles, one on two men who went through flight training. One was fresh out of high school, one had served a combat tour in Europe as a bombadier.

Something I would have missed but he caught instantly was that the combat veteran had been one of his three roomates. (All officers) But it got even better. The picture of the guy in the article was one dad himself had taken. An exact duplicate is in his scrapbook.

Yeah, the odds are long ..... but you never know.

Re: The Documentary...The War

#22

Re: The Documentary...The War

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I'm watching to see if I get a glimpse of a destroyer with a big 793 on the bow...that'll be me. My ship, the USS Cassin Young is a national historical monument...Sits across the dock from Old Ironsides in Boston Harbor....I've visited her a couple of times.

Wally

Re: The Documentary...The War

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Documentary...The War

keith tompkins

>I'm watching as I can....my grandfather served in WW1, I am named in honor of my mother's cousin who was a B-17 pilot in WW2. He never returned from a mission over Germany. I have a nephew who was severely wounded in Iraq, a sniper bullet hit near his collarbone and exited near his hip. He is slowly recovering in a Maryland military hospital after five major surgeries. Another nephew is a Marine Corps captain stationed in Japan...top gun pilot. My older brother served in Vietnam, as did my brother-in-law....he's terribly disfigured from tripping a booby-trapped grenade. Will we ever learn?

Re: The Documentary...The War

#24

my ship...CA 31 was the yacht for FDR and truman

robert davis

>

Re: The Documentary...The War

#25

Re: The Documentary...The War

Steve Russell

>Hello,

My father served on the Battleship Maryland (BB-46) during WW2. Like you, I also check out all of the old documentaries for a glimpse of dad, even though it's a million to one shot. I do have lots of WW2 documentaries and there are several shows that feature the Battleship Maryland during some of her more famous battles, like the battle of Leyte Gulf.

It's really strange watching these battles knowing that dad was in the thick of it, years before I was even born. Dad was wounded during a "Kamikaze" suicide plane attack on the Maryland on the evening of 29 November 1944, while operating off Leyte. The picture below shows the Maryland the moment the Japanese plane struck the ship.

Dad was a regular member of the Battleship Maryland survivors society. The surviving shipmates got together every year for a meeting/convention and dad was always proud to attend. He mentioned that the group was getting smaller every year, as members kept passing away. Dad passed away three years ago and I know that he's back with all of his Maryland shipmates now. The greatest generation indeed...

Steve Russell

EWW, WVP, EWWFS

The Woodlands, Texas


img