Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Speaking of "fire-safe"

Posts

Speaking of "fire-safe"

#1

Speaking of "fire-safe"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>It was suggested to me today that, since my dust collector is in the garage (rather than in the basement shop where I work), I should pipe in a pair of 150F* sprinkler heads over the DC for fire protection from hot stuff in the collection bags. I don't cut wood with nails and such imbeded, so I'm thinking this is more than a bit of overkill. Unfortunately, the comment was made within earshot of SWMBO. She hasn't said anything, yet, but I know, sure as an on-coming freight with no headlight in the tunnel, that it's coming.

Comments??

This can present some problems because the garage is unheated so a water line would probably have to be wired with a heater to freeze-proof the water line.

[yeah, it never ends]

mm

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#3

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Mike, I know exactly where you are coming from. It is inevitable. Regarding the sprinkler heads, If you were working with recycled lumber or whatever It would be a good investment, however in my case it would be a complete waste of cash.

Norm

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#4

Option No. 2.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Thanks, John. That's certaily one way to go at it. I'm wondering, however, how it would do with a fire in the collector bags. I have a feeling that a running water sprinkler might be more effective in saturating a bag of smoking wood dust. That would not, of course, be effective for the stored gas and solvents also in the garage.

Maybe it's time to get a "pro" in to look at this. I just find it hard to separate the BS in their horror-story sales pitches.

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#5

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

Phil in NJ

>with respect to freezing, perhaps heat tracing on the pipes would be good enough?

In some applications at work (computer datacenters) we use a technology called VESDA (very early smoke detection apparatus). Very good stuff. Might be costly though.

We also use pre-action systems so the pipes are dry until smoke is actually detected.

Again, not sure there is a reasonably priced way to apply this to your situation....

-Phil

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#6

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

bill crommett in seneca

>Mark:

Because your chances of a fire are close to nil, it is time to practice your salesmanship on the ruler of the premises. If this proves non-productive, rig a smoke detector with a remote alarm in the habitable part of the house.

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#7

Re: Soft & Dry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hi Phil,

Yeah, sounds like more than I need (or want to pay for), but I'm thinking I will put in a wet line for the DC area. It's not THAT big a deal to run a low voltage line heater for the branch. Thing is, once I start on the "garage fire suppression" path, I wouldn't give odds on when (not if) the "request" will be made for a dry-chem system over the flamables storage areas. Fortunately, they're all along one wall so 2 ceiling units should cover it nicely.

Now, do I tell the insurance company that I'm such a Good Boy for putting in fire suppression to get a drop in my rates or do I shut up so they can't triple my rates for hazardous activity and then give me a 5% discount for my reward! |;-}}}

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#8

Re: Salesmanship

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>pales to insignificance, Bill, in the face of "But, Honey I'll sleep so much better . . "

Of course, I could reopen the negotiations for the separate shop so I could move all That-Nasty-Stuff-Outta-The-House. The $25,000 for the structure was one thing, but the $4,000 in added YEARLY property taxes was the kill-er!

|;-}}

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#9

Re: Salesmanship

bill crommett in seneca

>Mark: You have a point, or rather she has. I have to diqualify my self from the real picture because after I kept blowing the bag off my DC (because I converted the intake to a 6" inlet) I started blowing the out-flow directly outside towards the orchard. No more problems.

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#10

Re: Soft & Dry

bill crommett in seneca

>Mark: beware of the insurance companies. They are no longer the " share the risk" people. To make a profit, they have to keep the rates competitive, and therefore if you have a claim you will eventually end up paying for your own claim---one way or another.

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#11

Cold room sprinkler how-to

Pete in Holland, MI

>When sprinklers need to be in unheated areas subject to freezing, they are plumbed with a check valve in the system on the warm side of the wall. Charge the cold side of the wall plumbing with 100 pounds of air, and monitor it with a pressure gauge and a Schrader valve (tire valve stem). Now turn on the water.

The 40-60 pounds of water pressure cannot overcome the air pressure on the check valve. If the sprinkler seat is opened, the air pressure will drop and water will follow in.

This is how it is done commercially.

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#12

Re: Cold room sprinkler how-to

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Thanks Pete!

Makes perfect sense and easy to do as well!!!

mm

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#13

Re: "fire-safe" Alternate options

Brodie Brickey

>Mark,

I certainly understand your need for fire protection. One of the things to seriously consider:

Your sprinkler head isn't going to open up until the fire reaches a certain temperature in the entire room or affected area.

As a result, you may very well have just as large of a blaze to put out with water, as you would with an A-B-C dry chemical. Another option if it is an enclosed area is Halon. Halon isn't fun to breathe, but it isn't really toxic. It doesn't make a huge mess, and it doesn't damage motors and what not.

Your water damage with a sprinkler system will far exceed your fire damage (picture going away for the weekend, and coming back to the sprinkler system still running throughout the garage). With a dry chem or halon system you will be back up and running sooner with less likelihood that you will be filing an insurance claim.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: Speaking of "fire-safe"

#14

Re: "fire-safe" Alternate options

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hi Brodie,

Thanks for the thoughts. I'm not in a position to enclose the DC as too much other stuff runs right by it, but it is located in a corner so that a heat spike is likely to be more localized over the collector bags where the sprinkler would be located. As far as the going away situation, its been my sop for years to empty the DC bag and kill the breakers for both the shop and the compressor before leaving for more than a day trip. Heck, I even unplug the toaster, the coffee pot, and the cell phone chargers! |;-}

The Halon systems are only used around here for computer and electronics areas because of the cost of both the set-up and the chem. I'm not worried about a bit of water in the garage, it runs out under the door, and there's nothing in there that a good shower's going to hurt.

Had a guy over the other day and he recommended a 135* sprinkler head so that the entire garage wouldn't have to get so hot (155 is the next up) for the system to activate. Of course he also tried to sell me on a sophisticated supression system made just for garages. The house and the garage are hardwired for smoke, so I'm not too worried about a 2am garage fire catching us asleep; we'd have lots of time to get out with the cats. The danger would be the wood dust catching and then spreading to the vehicles and other gas tanks parked in there. That could take the house before the trucks arrived. No flamables are stored within 15' of the DC, and the sheetrock is all fire-stop rated, so I think the water head and an audible external alarm will be enough.

Thanks again for the suggestions!

mm